Macro ReviewHow to read
Thematic · Private credit & life insurers

Blue Owl's listed private-credit fund trades 24.1% below its book value

Stress in private credit has moved from retail funds' redemption queues to insurers' annuity books, where loans carry no quoted price; listed funds and insurers' shares are the marks that exist.Has private-credit stress moved from the retail funds to the annuity balance sheet — and where would it show first?

Said 13 Sept 2026 · revised 15 Sept 2026Data to 16 Nov 2026 (prices) · weekly statistics to 13 Nov 2026 · updated 17 Nov 2026
Blue Owl's listed fund vs book value−24.1%16 Nov 2026 · $10.83 vs $14.26 book · was −22.3% on 11 Sep · the view breaks inside −10%
FS KKR's listed fund vs book value−36.8%16 Nov 2026 · $11.57 vs $18.30 (Q2) · was −35.0% on 11 Sep
Brighthouse vs its $70 cash offer−38.7%16 Nov 2026 · $42.88 · was −28.4% on 11 Sep · awaits regulators
Listed private-credit funds, year to date−4.2%16 Nov 2026 · the ETF (BIZD) · US market +9.6%
Rate paid on reserves ()3.90%from 17 Sep 2026 · +25bp since 11 Sep · what the funds' bank lines price off

listed proxies These are share prices of listed funds, managers and insurers (Yahoo Finance), not marks on the loans; the Appendix says whose prices they are.

Stress has moved to the annuity books, where nothing is marked

Has private-credit stress moved from the retail funds to the annuity balance sheet — and where would it show first?
  • Private-credit stress has moved from retail funds' redemption queues to life insurers' annuity books, where nothing is marked: holding (said 13 Sep 2026).→ Exhibit
  • Blue Owl's listed fund trades 24.1% below its book value and FS KKR's 36.8% below (16 Nov 2026).→ Exhibit 1
  • The five managers the June report flagged are down as much as 32% this year, against a market up 10%.→ Exhibit
  • Brighthouse is −33.8% this year and F&G −22.9%, while diversified life insurers are up.→ Exhibit
  • The hike took the rate the Fed pays on reserves () to 3.90% from 17 Sep 2026, raising the cost of the funds' bank lines.→ Exhibit
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
The listed marks close their discountOBDC's discount to net asset value inside 10%, with ADS Q3 requests above Q2'slisted prices and requests — quoted, not scorednot tracked hereADS third-quarter requests, October 2026
Dispersion among life insurers reversesa BHF/FG-type basket beats diversified life insurers by 10pp in Q4the window opens 1 Oct 2026not tracked herethe fourth quarter's close, 31 Dec 2026
The published book stops being clean (investment grade)Baa minus the 10-year above 2.5ppsubscription data — quoted from the September report, not trackednot tracked hereMoody's Baa yields, quoted
The published book stops being clean (high yield)high-yield option-adjusted spread above 550bpsubscription data — quoted from the September report, not trackednot tracked hereICE BofA index data, quoted
The reasoning behind each point
  • Verdict
    Private-credit stress has moved from retail funds' redemption queues to life insurers' annuity books, where nothing is marked: holding (said 13 Sep 2026).

    As written on 13 Sep 2026: “The stress migrated: from the redemption queues of the retail funds to the annuity balance sheet. The vulnerable leg is credit, and the vulnerable holder is the annuity writer, not the bank.” The verdict is “holding” because no trigger of the falsifier table has crossed; the scorecard sets what the log said against what has happened since.

  • Listed marks
    Blue Owl's listed fund trades 24.1% below its book value and FS KKR's 36.8% below (16 Nov 2026).

    On the September report's data date the discounts were 22.3% and 35.0%; FSK went ex-dividend ($0.44 since the NAV date), and adding it back the discount is 34.4%. The listed BDC ETF is −4.2% this year against +9.6% for the US market. The falsifier needs OBDC's discount inside 10% together with higher ADS requests in Q3.

  • Canaries
    The five managers the June report flagged are down as much as 32% this year, against a market up 10%.

    By name: Blue Owl −31.9% to Apollo −16.1% this year; since the June report they run from −10.0% to +0.7% against the US market's ±0.0%. None of the five thirteen-week Jensen alphas is distinguishable from zero (|t| ≥ 2) in the week to 13 Nov 2026: no further de-rating on a risk-adjusted basis. Oracle, the AI-credit link, is −46% over the year.

  • Insurers
    Brighthouse is −33.8% this year and F&G −22.9%, while diversified life insurers are up.

    The seven diversified names in the September report's map range from +13.2% to +39.9% this year. Brighthouse closed at $42.88 on 16 Nov 2026, 38.7% below Aquarian's signed $70 cash offer (28.4% on 11 Sep): the market prices a material chance that regulators block the sale of an annuity writer to a private-capital buyer.

  • Bank line
    The hike took the rate the Fed pays on reserves (IORB) to 3.90% from 17 Sep 2026, raising the cost of the funds' bank lines.

    The September report’s point: the same move raises the discount rate on illiquid marks at once. The Fed's lending line is $10.2bn in the week to 11 Nov 2026 (the Fed balance sheet page) — context, with no threshold in the September report. Bank lending to non-bank lenders is read from the Bank lending page.

Next: Corporate spreads — the traded credit book

Source: Yahoo Finance share prices; Federal Reserve Board; the September 2026 report · data to the dates shownthemes.private_credit-read

The September report's paths and tests against what has happened since

Each named test and path set: what the dated record said on 13 Sep 2026, what has happened since, and the verdict
WhatSaidHappenedVerdict
PathsWhere the stress sits into the fourth quarterSaid · 13 Sept 20263 paths named, no odds: Migrated to the annuity balance sheet — the September report’s reading · The retail leg resumes as bank lines reprice · The migration story is wrong — the falsifierHappenednot yet decided — Q3 redemption requests (October) and the listed marksVerdictopen
PathsWhen a default cycle becomes a policyholder problemSaid · 13 Sept 20262 paths named, no odds: Charges and disclosure in force at year-end 2026 · Charges slip to 2027 — the September report’s expectationHappenednot yet decided — the NAIC capital charges and private-letter-rating disclosureVerdictopen
PathsDispersion among listed life insurersSaid · 13 Sept 20262 paths named, no odds: Dispersion by ownership type persists · The thin-disclosure writers catch up — the falsifierHappenednot yet decided — the fourth quarter of 2026Verdictopen
TestThe listed marks close their discountSaid · 13 Sept 2026OBDC's discount to net asset value inside 10%, with ADS Q3 requests above Q2'sHappenedlisted prices and requests — quoted, not scoredVerdictnot tracked here
TestDispersion among life insurers reversesSaid · 13 Sept 2026a BHF/FG-type basket beats diversified life insurers by 10pp in Q4Happenedthe window opens 1 Oct 2026Verdictnot tracked here
TestThe published book stops being clean (investment grade)Said · 13 Sept 2026Baa minus the 10-year above 2.5ppHappenedsubscription data — quoted from the September report, not trackedVerdictnot tracked here
TestThe published book stops being clean (high yield)Said · 13 Sept 2026high-yield option-adjusted spread above 550bpHappenedsubscription data — quoted from the September report, not trackedVerdictnot tracked here

The view is holding: the word follows a rule set out in the Appendix, from the log and the tests above, never by hand.

About this exhibit
A scorecard of the path sets and the tests named in the September report, each with what was said, what has happened and a verdict
What was said on 13 Sept 2026, and what has happened since
The sets of paths and the falsifier's tests: what the log said, what the prices show, and the verdict
Source: the theme's dated log (said 13 Sept 2026); Yahoo Finance prices · data to 16 Nov 2026themes.private_credit-20

Where private credit ends up, and where it has a price

The chain from the borrower to the saver and the annuitant: the listed shares are its only market prices
Borrowersmid-sized firmsPrivate-creditfundsloansBankscredit linespriced off the policy rateListed funds (BDCs)share price vs bookSemi-liquid fundsretail saverssold toredemption queue · 5% capInsurer'sgeneral accountbought byBermuda sidecarcessionno recaptureAnnuitantspromisesAnnuity writerslisted shares
Retail money leaves through a queue capped at 5% a quarter; the paper keeps being bought by insurers' general accounts, which cede it to Bermuda sidecars with no recapture, and it ends as annuitants' savings. The listed shares (in colour) are the only market prices on the chain; the loans themselves are never marked in a market.
Source: the September 2026 report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026); Macro Reviewthemes.private_credit-21

The view, and the claim as written

The author's claim on 13 Sept 2026, kept as written; a figure revised since is marked where it stands

Private-credit stress has moved from retail funds' redemption queues to life insurers' annuity books, where nothing is marked — holding

As written on 13 Sept 2026

The stress migrated: from the redemption queues of the retail funds to the annuity balance sheet. The vulnerable leg is credit, and the vulnerable holder is the annuity writer, not the bank.

Q1 2026 was the first quarter in which accepted redemptions at semi-liquid funds exceeded inflows, and in Q2 every major non-traded BDC hit its 5% cap; requests are easing because annuity general accounts and Bermuda sidecars keep taking the paper with no published mark. Listed BDCs trade 22–35% below net asset value, and the two listed annuity writers with the thinnest disclosure fell by about a quarter this year while diversified life insurers rose. A hike raises the cost of the bank lines and the discount rate on illiquid marks at once.

Carried unchanged into the 15 September edition, which removed the return model's private-credit breadth reading (its signal convention is under revision); the thesis now rests on balance sheets and listed marks alone.

StatusactiveSaid13 Sept 2026Revised15 Sept 2026

Argued in the : 5 dated documents, listed with their sections under Sources in the Appendix.

Source: the September 2026 report and its research notes (5 documents, listed in the Appendix)themes.private_credit-2

Annuity writers and the flagged managers are down; listed funds trade far below book

What do the prices that exist say about where the stress sits?

Share prices of annuity writers against diversified life insurers

Index of the 31 Dec 2025 close, daily, to 16 Nov 2026 · Brighthouse and F&G against MetLife, Prudential and the IAK insurance ETF
About this exhibit
Daily share prices indexed to the last close of last year: Brighthouse and F&G (annuity writers) against MetLife, Prudential and the IAK insurance ETF
Annuity writers against diversified life insurers, this year
indexed, 31 Dec 2025 = 100, 31 Dec 2025 to 16 Nov 2026
Source: Yahoo Finance adjusted and unadjusted closes, taken 17 Nov 2026; arithmetic calculated on this site.themes.private_credit-5

Share prices of listed private-credit funds and Blue Owl against the market

Index of the 31 Dec 2025 close, daily to 16 Nov 2026: listed BDCs (BIZD), OBDC, FSK, Blue Owl (OWL) and the US market (VTI)
About this exhibit
Daily share prices indexed to the last close of last year: the BDC ETF (BIZD), Blue Owl Capital Corp., FS KKR, Blue Owl Capital Inc. and the US market (VTI)
Listed BDCs and the most exposed manager against the market
indexed, 31 Dec 2025 = 100, 31 Dec 2025 to 16 Nov 2026
Source: Yahoo Finance adjusted and unadjusted closes, taken 17 Nov 2026; arithmetic calculated on this site.themes.private_credit-3

Exhibit 1 · Listed fund discounts to book value and Brighthouse's discount to its offer

% below net asset value (Blue Owl Capital Corp., FS KKR) or the $70 offer (Brighthouse), daily to 16 Nov 2026; dashed: −10% breaks the view
About this exhibit
Three daily lines this year: Blue Owl Capital Corp. and FS KKR share prices as % below net asset value, and Brighthouse as % below Aquarian's cash offer, with a dashed line at the level that would break the view
Discounts to filed value and to the cash offer
% below net asset value or offer, 31 Dec 2025 to 16 Nov 2026
Source: Yahoo Finance adjusted and unadjusted closes, taken 17 Nov 2026; arithmetic calculated on this site.themes.private_credit-4

Share-price returns this year by name and group

Share-price return this year to 16 Nov 2026, %, by name and group; blue: fell, red: rose; the table adds the return since the June report
About this exhibit
Horizontal bars: share-price return this year for every name in the report's universe (June canaries, alternative managers, listed BDCs, life insurers and annuity writers, benchmarks), falls in blue and gains in red
The flagged managers and annuity writers are down; diversified insurers are up
Share price return this year to 16 Nov 2026, %, by name and group; the table adds the return since the June report
Source: Yahoo Finance share prices; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026themes.private_credit-22

The rate paid on reserves against overnight funding rates

%, daily, since 2 Jan 2026 · interest on reserve balances (IORB), secured overnight financing rate (SOFR), effective federal funds rate (EFFR)
About this exhibit
Daily percent: interest on reserve balances (IORB), SOFR and the effective fed funds rate (EFFR); IORB steps up with the hike and the other two follow
What the hike moved: IORB and overnight funding
%, 2 Jan 2026 to 16 Nov 2026
Source: Board of Governors (IORB); Federal Reserve Bank of New York reference rates (not affiliated with this site). From Policy rates (data to 16 Nov 2026)themes.private_credit-8

Fed lending to banks: discount window, facilities and repo

$bn, Wednesday levels, weekly, 2 Jan 2019 to 11 Nov 2026 · context only: the report sets no threshold
About this exhibit
Weekly $bn (Wednesday levels): Fed loans and facility LLCs (discount window and facilities) and repurchase agreements (standing repo and FIMA)
The Fed's lending line (context, no threshold)
$bn, Wednesday levels, 2 Jan 2019 to 11 Nov 2026
Source: Board of Governors, H.4.1. From Balance sheet (data to 11 Nov 2026)themes.private_credit-9

Commercial bank loans to non-bank financial institutions

Billions of dollars, loans to nondepository financial institutions, weekly, 8 Nov 2023 to 4 Nov 2026
About this exhibit
One weekly line: commercial banks' loans to nondepository financial institutions, billions of dollars
Bank lending to non-bank lenders
$bn, 8 Nov 2023 to 4 Nov 2026
Source: Board of Governors, H.8. From Bank lending (data to 4 Nov 2026)themes.private_credit-11

Investment-grade corporate bond spread and the excess bond premium

Basis points, monthly, to Sep 2026 · 10-year HQM corporate par yield less the 10-year Treasury, and the excess bond premium (to Sep 2026)
About this exhibit
Monthly: the 10-year HQM corporate par yield less the 10-year Treasury, and the excess bond premium, in basis points
The traded credit book
basis points, Sep 2016 to Sep 2026
Source: Corporate spreads. From Corporate spreads (data to Sep 2026)themes.private_credit-13

Private-credit figures the September report quoted, from funds to insurers

Named sources' figures as the September report quoted them by 13 Sep 2026: official reports, fund disclosures, defaults, insurer balance sheets, Bermuda and regulation
WhatAs quotedSource
The official viewpublished dataFed Financial Stability Report (8 May), FSB (6 May), IMF GFSR (April): a rising but contained vulnerability; 45% of the Fed's market contacts cite private credit (43% in autumn 2025); the FSB: the asset class 'has not been tested in a severe downturn'. About $3tn; the FSB puts ~$800bn of AI capex on private credit.the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points · 13 Sept 2026
Semi-liquid fundspublished dataFed FSR Box 4.1: perpetual BDCs $306bn gross / $161bn net; interval funds $119bn / $80bn — about 20% of private-credit AUM; accepted redemptions exceeded inflows in Q1 2026, the first time ever.the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (b) cycle-state table — Fed FSR Box 4.1 · 12 Sept 2026
Redemption requestssubscription dataBlue Owl OCIC: ~22% of shares in Q1, 18.8% in Q2, 5% cap kept. Apollo Debt Solutions: 11.2% in Q1 (45% honoured), 16.8% in Q2 (5% honoured); Q3 requests 'running half of Q2' (Apollo, 4 Aug). Blackstone BCRED: ~10% in Q2, 5% accepted. Every major non-traded BDC hit its 5% cap in Q2.the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points; research file H (b) · 13 Sept 2026
Defaults, realised and shadowsubscription dataProskauer 2.51% in Q2 (from 2.73%); KBRA 3.1% by count; Lincoln International bad-PIK proxy ≈5.9%; Fitch 6.0%; FSB ~5% including selective defaults. $39.4bn of lender foreclosures in 2025–26, three-quarters from the 2021–22 vintages; a fifth of direct loans are software, marked down 1.9% of par.the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points · 13 Sept 2026
The bank linepublished data$2.6tn of bank commitments to non-bank financials, a quarter to private equity, BDCs and private credit (+17% y/y); FSB direct bank exposure $220–500bn; the top five banks provide 63% of BDC lending, below 0.5% of their assets. H.8: lending to non-bank lenders +19% a year.the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points; §1.7 analysis · 13 Sept 2026
Life insurerssubscription dataPrivate credit ~$1tn, 17% of life-insurer balance sheets (JLK, June 2026; $849bn or 14% on the Chicago Fed's 2024 data); 82% of the $276.8bn insurer CLO book; 37% of assets illiquid. PE- and alternative-manager-owned annuity writers: ~$900bn of liabilities, 35% of new annuity sales, six of the top ten Level-3 holders ($592bn industry-wide, AM Best, August 2026).the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — the exposure chain · 13 Sept 2026
Bermudasubscription data$0.8tn of reserves ceded offshore, 81% to Bermuda; sidecars hold $375bn of assumed liabilities, growing ~32% a year, with 'no recaptures' (Morningstar DBRS via Artemis, 3 Sep 2026). Athene ceded $166bn, 83% of gross reserves, to Athene Annuity Re; Global Atlantic $94bn, 66% (year-end 2023, Moody's, Feb 2025).the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — Bermuda; by name · 13 Sept 2026
Filed values used on this pagepublished dataOBDC net asset value $14.26 a share (30 Jun 2026); FSK net asset value $18.30 (Q2 2026); Brighthouse: Aquarian's $70.00 cash offer (about $4.1bn), approved by stockholders on 12 February, closing expected in 2026 subject to regulatory approvals.the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (b) cycle-state table; REPORT §3.3 the market's own map · 12 Sept 2026
Regulationpublished dataNAIC CLO C-1 factors 0.03–2.73% investment grade and 12.59–70.82% below, with a thin-tranche penalty, and collateral-loan charges targeted for 31 December 2026, likely to slip to 2027; private-letter-rating disclosure from year-end 2026; AG 55 first reports due 1 April 2026; NAIC retracted its private-ratings report on 8 April; Treasury consulting state regulators from Q2.the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — regulation · 13 Sept 2026
About this exhibit
A table of figures quoted from the September report's documents, each with source and date: the official view, semi-liquid funds, redemption requests, defaults, bank lines, life insurers, Bermuda, filed values and regulation
The chain behind the marks — as the report quoted it
Official reports, fund disclosures, default indices, insurer balance sheets, Bermuda and regulation; quoted with date and source
Source: the September 2026 report's documents, quoted with dates; not a data feedthemes.private_credit-14

None of the view's tests is tracked on this page

What would change the view?

What would change the view, test by test

Thresholds from the September report; status from the latest data. 0 crossed · 0 closing · 0 not crossed · 0 pending · 5 not tracked here.
About
StatusTestLatest readingThresholdIf crossedThreshold source
not tracked hereOBDC's discount to net asset value below 10%, and ADS third-quarter redemption requests above the second quarter'sOctober 2026 (Q3 requests)listed prices are subscription data and ADS requests arrive in October — not tracked; on Yahoo Finance prices: OBDC −24.1% against its 30 Jun NAV on 16 Nov 2026, −22.3% on 11 Sep–The retail leg has recovered and the stress did not migrate: the private-credit thesis is wrong.the September 2026 report · §3.3 falsifier; §4.4 #19 · 13 Sept 2026
not tracked hereA BHF/FG-type basket outperforms diversified life insurers by 10pp in Q4Q4 2026Q4 window opens 1 Oct 2026; share prices are subscription data — not tracked–Dispersion by ownership type has closed; the market no longer prices the private-credit-in-insurance signal.the September 2026 report · §4.4 #20 · 13 Sept 2026
not tracked hereBaa corporate yield minus the ten-year Treasury above 2.5ppMoody's Baa yields are subscription data and carried by no page of this site — quoted, not tracked (1.51pp on 10 Sep, issue). The published investment-grade read is the HQM 10-year par spread and the excess bond premium in the spreads tracker (Corporate spreads).> 2.50 ppThe published credit book is no longer clean; the stress is not confined to where there is no published mark.the September 2026 report · §1.7 falsifier; §4.4 #14 · 13 Sept 2026
not tracked hereICE BofA high-yield OAS above 550bpICE BofA index data are subscription data (FRED keeps a three-year window) and carried by no page of this site — quoted, not tracked; 2.70% on 10 Sep (issue)> 5.50%High-yield credit is pricing the stress the private book does not mark.the September 2026 report · §1.7 falsifier · 13 Sept 2026
not tracked hereNFCI credit subindex above +0.5 with bank consumer standards tightening at a net 20% of banksChicago Fed NFCI needs written permission — quoted, not tracked; credit subindex −0.06 in the week of 4 Sep; July SLOOS: cards +6.7% net tightening (issue)–Financial conditions have tightened where the loans are made, not only where the index looks.the September 2026 report · §1.7 falsifier · 13 Sept 2026
Source: the September 2026 report (thresholds); the pages named in each row (readings)themes.private_credit-15

The paths the report named, without odds

Where does the stress sit into the fourth quarter?

Paths for where private-credit stress sits into the year's last quarter

The September report's reading, October watch item and the case against, each named, no odds · decided by Q3 redemption requests (October) and the listed marks
About
  1. Migrated to the annuity balance sheet — the September report’s readingThe retail leg eases because the institutional leg keeps buying: general accounts and Bermuda sidecars absorb marks a listed BDC cannot, with no published price and no recapture provision.
  2. The retail leg resumes as bank lines repriceQ3 requests at ADS and OCIC rise again and the listed discounts widen; the September report’s October watch item.
  3. The migration story is wrong — the falsifierOBDC's discount to net asset value below 10% and ADS third-quarter requests above the second quarter's.

The September report states its reading, what to watch in October and the falsifier, without a probability for any of them; none is shown.

About this exhibit
A text card: named paths, with no odds: stress migrated to annuity balance sheets (the report's reading), the retail leg resumes as bank lines reprice, or the migration story is wrong (the falsifier)
Where the stress sits into the fourth quarter
Q3 redemption requests (October) and the listed marks
Source: the September 2026 report · §3.3 analysis and falsifier; §4.3 What to watch (Oct) · 13 Sept 2026themes.private_credit-scenario-migration

Timings for insurers' new capital charges on private credit

When the NAIC's capital charges and private-letter-rating disclosure take effect, this December or later, each timing named · no odds given
About
  1. Charges and disclosure in force at year-end 2026CLO C-1 factors (0.03–2.73% investment grade, 12.59–70.82% below) and collateral-loan charges apply from 31 December 2026; holdings with only a private letter rating are disclosed from year-end.
  2. Charges slip to 2027 — the September report’s expectationDisclosure arrives at year-end but the capital charges wait; until then the general account keeps absorbing marks and the listed discounts remain the only honest price signal.

The September report says the capital charges are targeted for 31 December 2026 and 'likely to slip to 2027' — a qualitative expectation, not a probability; none is shown.

About this exhibit
A text card: timings, with no odds, for the NAIC's new capital charges on CLOs and collateral loans and for private-letter-rating disclosure: in force at the year-end, or charges slipping to next year (the report's expectation)
When a default cycle becomes a policyholder problem
The NAIC capital charges and private-letter-rating disclosure
Source: the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points (regulation) and analysis · 13 Sept 2026themes.private_credit-scenario-transmission

Paths for the gap between annuity writers and diversified insurers

The fourth quarter of 2026: the gap persists, or a BHF/FG-type basket beats diversified insurers by 10 percentage points (the test) · no odds given
About
  1. Dispersion by ownership type persistsAnnuity writers with thin asset disclosure and alternative-manager entanglement keep lagging diversified life insurers, which are rewarded for the rate level.
  2. The thin-disclosure writers catch up — the falsifierA basket of the BHF/FG type outperforms diversified life insurers by 10 percentage points in Q4.

The September report names the persistence of dispersion by ownership type as a claim with a falsifier and no probability; none is shown.

About this exhibit
A text card: paths for the year's last quarter, with no odds: annuity writers keep lagging diversified insurers, or a BHF/FG-type basket beats them (the falsifier)
Dispersion among listed life insurers
The fourth quarter of 2026
Source: the September 2026 report · §4.4 #20; §3.3 the market's own map · 13 Sept 2026themes.private_credit-scenario-insurers

What would each path move?

None of this theme's branches is on the Scenarios set; the nearest standing estimate is the credit channel the stress would run through

S&P 500 response to a credit move, per unit of shock

No path is projected · the transmission table's latest same-day S&P 500 response, %, per unit shock to the credit factor, with its band

Nothing is projected here. Migrated to the annuity balance sheet — the September report’s reading, The retail leg resumes as bank lines reprice and The migration story is wrong — the falsifier: no model on the site prices where private-credit losses sit.

The channel a path would run through · Credit → the S&P 500: +1% on the credit factor (high-yield return net of the 10-year), daily → S&P 500 +2.71% the same day, the same session; 90% band 2.24 to 3.18%. Record: with the market also taken out of the factor, −0.07 (t −1.7): most of the beta is the equity in high yield; the excess bond premium or the HQM spread → the equity premium is not modelled. The transmission table carries it with its sample and its model.

What each path would do to core PCE, unemployment and real GDP is read on Thematic impact, under Outlook.

About this exhibit
A text card: no path is projected; instead the transmission table's estimate of the S&P 500's same-day response to a rise in the credit factor, with its band
What would each path move?
Model-conditional: no branch of this page is projected on the Scenarios set, so no asset effect is printed for any of them; the channel beneath is the transmission table's estimate per unit of shock, not a projection of a branch.
Source: the Scenarios and Transmission pages; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026 and Oct 2026themes.private_credit-16

The full universe, the timeline and the report's exhibits

Every name on the latest prices, the dated events, and the report's exhibits mapped to live pages

Share-price returns and risk measures for each name, by group

Returns, %, year to date, since the June and September reports, over a year and from the 52-week high · beta and 13-week alpha against VTI
About
SymbolCloseYTDSince 12 JunSince lock1 yearFrom 52w highBeta 3yAlpha 3mt
June canaries
OWL Blue Owl Capital Inc.9.35−31.9%+0.7%−9.5%−30.4%−39.0%1.92−40%−0.50
KKR KKR & Co. Inc.95.47−24.7%−0.6%−5.6%−19.8%−32.7%1.76−7%−0.10
APO Apollo Global Management, Inc.119.98−16.1%−10.0%−7.0%−6.6%−20.4%1.72+8%+0.13
ARES Ares Management Corporation130.19−16.7%−1.5%−0.1%−7.4%−24.0%1.57±0%±0.00
BX Blackstone Inc.117.01−21.0%−2.8%−8.1%−13.9%−25.5%1.35−41%−0.59
ORCL Oracle Corporation119.09−38.1%−34.9%−20.5%−45.8%−51.7%1.72−29%−0.47
Alternative managers
CG The Carlyle Group Inc.38.62−33.3%−15.0%−8.8%−26.1%−40.4%1.76−59%−0.96
TPG TPG Inc.46.93−22.8%+11.6%−0.4%−14.9%−29.3%1.65+18%+0.27
BAM Brookfield Asset Management Ltd.50.89+0.1%+9.0%+7.7%+2.6%−8.0%1.25−11%−0.19
BN Brookfield Corporation40.39−11.5%−10.4%+5.9%−7.7%−17.4%1.35−29%−0.67
Listed BDCs
ARCC Ares Capital Corporation19.08+1.8%+4.1%−0.9%+4.3%−3.2%0.61−9%−0.53
OBDC Blue Owl Capital Corporation10.83−4.3%+2.8%+0.6%+2.9%−9.1%0.65−15%−0.44
BXSL Blackstone Secured Lending Fund23.75−0.7%+6.1%+0.4%+1.0%−5.2%0.44−4%−0.22
FSK FS KKR Capital Corp.11.57−11.5%+13.0%+1.0%−12.0%−16.8%0.58−8%−0.16
MAIN Main Street Capital Corporation56.18−0.4%+11.9%+1.4%+3.9%−7.3%0.63−15%−0.70
GBDC Golub Capital BDC, Inc.12.40−1.1%−1.8%−0.5%−0.4%−5.4%0.45−12%−0.48
BIZD VanEck BDC Income ETF12.39−4.2%+2.8%−1.7%−1.1%−7.2%0.58−15%−0.73
Life insurers and annuity writers
CRBG Corebridge Financial, Inc.35.71+21.5%+26.2%+3.7%+26.9%−1.8%1.33+45%+1.11
BHF Brighthouse Financial, Inc.42.88−33.8%−32.0%−14.4%−34.8%−35.6%0.92−103%−1.87
LNC Lincoln National Corporation41.36−2.8%+13.4%−4.6%+5.5%−11.0%1.12−16%−0.38
FG F&G Annuities & Life, Inc.23.07−22.9%−18.6%+1.2%−26.2%−31.4%0.96−67%−0.59
JXN Jackson Financial Inc.137.59+32.1%+27.4%+0.3%+50.3%−2.2%1.37+40%+1.03
PRU Prudential Financial, Inc.122.91+13.2%+14.6%+3.1%+20.8%−2.9%0.79+15%+0.40
MET MetLife, Inc.101.45+32.0%+15.6%+5.1%+32.5%−1.5%0.91+29%+0.97
EQH Equitable Holdings, Inc.55.28+18.4%+26.4%+3.6%+26.9%−1.5%1.24+47%+1.12
PFG Principal Financial Group, Inc.112.27+30.4%+1.8%−3.4%+37.5%−5.3%0.88+4%+0.11
VOYA Voya Financial, Inc.102.47+39.9%+12.5%−0.9%+48.3%−2.3%0.92+7%+0.17
GL Globe Life Inc.159.39+14.9%−4.1%−6.7%+21.9%−14.1%0.68−47%−0.98
AFL Aflac Incorporated128.08+18.0%+9.3%+11.1%+14.4%−0.6%0.30+12%+0.33
IAK iShares U.S. Insurance ETF153.86+15.5%+14.2%+7.2%+18.2%±0.0%0.42+14%+0.51
KIE State Street SPDR S&P Insurance ETF66.06+11.1%+13.8%+6.3%+13.8%−0.3%0.47+6%+0.21
Benchmarks
VTI Vanguard Morningstar Total Stock Market ETF364.30+9.6%±0.0%−2.9%+11.7%−5.0%–––
XLF State Street Financial Select Sector SPDR ETF58.18+7.5%+9.8%+2.0%+12.7%−1.7%0.80+11%+0.45
HYG iShares iBoxx $ High Yield Corporate Bond ETF76.73±0.0%−1.6%−1.4%+1.5%−2.5%0.21−7%−1.13
SPY State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust739.95+9.4%+0.3%−2.9%+11.3%−5.0%0.99+1%+0.84

A thirteen-week alpha is shaded only where |t| ≥ 2 — the report's test for a de-rating distinguishable from zero.

About this exhibit
A table of every name the report tracks, by group, with close, returns (year to date, since the June report, since the September report's data date, one year, from the 52-week high), beta and 13-week alpha with its t
The report's universe on the latest prices
Returns to 16 Nov 2026 and since the report's data date (11 Sept 2026); beta, alpha and t on weekly returns to 13 Nov 2026; groups as the report drew them
Source: Yahoo Finance adjusted and unadjusted closes, taken 17 Nov 2026; arithmetic calculated on this site.themes.private_credit-7

The dated events behind the view

Events with their source; scheduled dates are marked, and events read from a data series say so
  • 19 Nov 2025
    Blue Owl calls off the OBDC/OBDC II merger after an investor revolt; OBDC about 20% below net asset value.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • 12 Feb 2026
    Brighthouse stockholders approve Aquarian's $70-a-share cash take-private.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points · 13 Sept 2026

  • 18 Feb 2026
    Blue Owl permanently restricts withdrawals from Blue Owl Capital Corp II and sells $1.4bn (30%) of its assets.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • Late Mar 2026
    The median listed BDC's price-to-NAV bottoms at 0.74.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points; §1.7 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 2 Apr 2026
    Blue Owl caps OCIC and OTIC at 5% after $5.4bn of redemption requests.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • 8 Apr 2026
    The NAIC retracts its 2024 private-ratings report.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — regulation · 13 Sept 2026

  • 8 May 2026
    Fed Financial Stability Report: accepted redemptions exceeded inflows at semi-liquid funds in Q1, the first time ever.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • 12 Jun 2026
    The June report’s price lock for the private-credit 'canaries'.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — the June canaries, re-run · 13 Sept 2026

  • 23 Jun 2026
    Apollo Debt Solutions: Q2 requests 16.8% of shares, 5% honoured.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • 2 Jul 2026
    Blue Owl: $4.7bn of Q2 requests (OCIC 18.8%); seven other managers also breach the 5% cap.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • 4 Aug 2026
    Apollo: ADS third-quarter requests 'running half of Q2'.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points · 13 Sept 2026

  • 5 Aug 2026
    AM Best: Level-3 assets $592bn; six of the top ten holders PE- or asset-manager-backed.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list · 12 Sept 2026

  • 3 Sept 2026
    Morningstar DBRS (via Artemis): Bermuda sidecars hold $375bn, 'no recaptures'.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — Bermuda · 13 Sept 2026

  • 13 Sept 2026
    Issue published: the vulnerable holder is the annuity writer, not the bank.

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 analysis · 13 Sept 2026

  • 15 Sept 2026
    the report as published on 15 September removes the return model's private-credit breadth reading: the model's signal convention is under revision.

    the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §2.6 analysis · 15 Sept 2026

  • 1 Oct 2026
    Apollo targets daily net asset values for its private-markets products.

    the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · (c) 2026 stress-event list (scheduled) · 12 Sept 2026

  • Oct 2026
    On the September report’s watch list: ADS and OCIC third-quarter redemption requests; OBDC and FSK discounts — whether the retail leg resumes as bank lines reprice.

    the September 2026 report · §4.3 What to watch · 13 Sept 2026

  • 31 Dec 2026
    NAIC target date for CLO and collateral-loan capital charges (likely to slip to 2027) and private-letter-rating disclosure. scheduled

    the September 2026 report · §3.3 key points — regulation · 13 Sept 2026

Source: the September 2026 report and the pages cited per rowthemes.private_credit-17

The September report's private-credit exhibits and the pages that now carry them

Each named exhibit as the September report printed it, fixed at its 11 Sep 2026 data date, with the page that now carries it live
No.StemExhibitLive page
140E-PC2_canaries_rerunThe June canaries on September prices: year to date, one year, since the June lockPrivate credit & life insurers
142E-PC4_insurer_dispersionListed life insurers, year to date, by ownership type; BHF's bar is the discount to Aquarian's pending $70 cash offerPrivate credit & life insurers
141E-PC3_rolling_alphaRolling three-month Jensen alpha vs VTI, 2024–2026Private credit & life insurers
62E15b_bdc_price_to_navListed BDC price to NAV, latestPrivate credit & life insurers
139E-PC1_exposure_chainThe exposure chain: borrower → fund → general account → annuitant, with the bank line alongsidequoted figures — no live page
143E-PC5_redemption_requestsNon-traded BDC redemption requests by quarterquoted figures — no live page
144E-PC6_realised_vs_shadow_defaultsRealised vs shadow default measuresquoted figures — no live page
145E-PC8_bermuda_sidecarsBermuda sidecar liabilitiesquoted figures — no live page
146E-PC9_naic_timelineThe regulatory clockquoted figures — no live page
56E15_credit_spread_40yBaa corporate yield minus ten-year Treasury, 1986–2026, with percentile bandCorporate spreads
57E15c_hy_oas_historyHigh-yield, CCC and investment-grade spreads, 2023–2026 (three-year licence window)quoted figures — no live page
58E15d_public_credit_through_shockPublic credit through the shock: HYG, LQD, BKLN, BIZD and TLT, indexed to 31 Dec 2025quoted figures — no live page
60E9k_bank_lending_growthBank credit growth by loan category, latestBank lending
61E9i_bank_capacityBanks' capacity, standards and lending: FDIC, stress test, SLOOS, H.8Bank lending
About this exhibit
A table: each private-credit exhibit in the September report (number, title) and the live page that now carries it, or 'quoted figures — no live page'
The September report's exhibits, and where each lives now
Exhibit numbers as the report printed them on 15 September; each stays fixed at the 11 September data date and points to the page that carries it live
Source: the September 2026 report, exhibit listthemes.private_credit-18

Method

References, prices, discounts, licences and the status rule92 checks, all pass
About this page

The September report argued that private-credit stress migrated from the redemption queues of the retail funds to the annuity balance sheet, where nothing is marked to market. This page reads the marks that do exist — listed BDC discounts, the managers' shares, the annuity writers' shares — beside the policy rate the hike moved, and scores the report's tests.

Whose prices these are listed proxies

Share prices on this page are Yahoo Finance data, shown with their attribution. They are listed proxies — BDCs, alternative managers and life insurers — not the private-credit market itself, which does not trade; read them as the market's view of the listed wrapper rather than as marks on the underlying loans.
Source: Yahoo Finance share prices, with their attributionthemes.private_credit-1

Rolling three-month Jensen alpha against VTI

% a year, annualised 13-week intercept, 5 Jan 2024 to 13 Nov 2026
Source: Computed here from Yahoo Finance weekly closes: 13-week OLS intercept against VTI, annualised; the September report’s method. (data to 13 Nov 2026)themes.private_credit-6

Definitions

  • Theme
    What the page reads.

    The theme follows the private-credit chain from the funds to the life-insurance balance sheet. Balance sheets have no published mark, so the page reads the marks that exist — listed BDC discounts, the managers' shares and the annuity writers' shares — beside the policy rate a hike moves and the Fed's lending line. The rest of the chain is quoted from the September report with dates.

  • Prices
    Returns, betas and alphas.

    Share prices are Yahoo Finance adjusted closes (returns, betas, alphas) and unadjusted closes (discounts), taken on this update date; a bar is read only once its session had closed (16:00 New York, plus 15 minutes) when its file was taken. Returns, 156-week betas and 13-week Jensen alphas follow the September report’s script (pc_rerun.py) on weekly Friday log returns against VTI; the weekly statistics use completed weeks only. On every update the September report’s reproduction file is re-derived from the fresh download at 11 September and compared value by value.

  • Discounts
    Against filed value and the offer.

    A discount is the unadjusted close divided by the latest filed net asset value per share (OBDC 30 June, FSK Q2) or by Aquarian's agreed $70 cash offer for Brighthouse, less one. Net asset values are quarterly; a new filing moves the anchor.

  • Proxies
    What the prices are.

    Share prices on this page are Yahoo Finance data, shown with their attribution. They are listed proxies — BDCs, alternative managers and life insurers — not the private-credit market itself, which does not trade; read them as the market's view of the listed wrapper rather than as marks on the underlying loans.

  • Model
    A reading withdrawn.

    The 13 September report cited the package return model's private-credit breadth (no manager with a positive predicted-return step). The 15 September edition removed that reading because the model's signal convention is under revision; this page does not show it.

  • Status
    How triggers are scored.

    crossed — the threshold condition holds on the latest observation (for a run, on each of the last n); closing — not crossed, the series has printed since the September report's data date (11 September 2026), and the gap to the threshold is half or less of the gap on that date; not crossed — otherwise; pending — the observable is dated in the future or no page of this site carries it yet; not tracked here — an event, or subscription data this site does not display. Colours flag attention, not good or bad news for the book.

  • Odds
    None given.

    The September report gives no probabilities for this theme. The scenario sets name the reading, the October watch item and the falsifiers without odds.

  • Verdict
    How the verdict word is set.

    The verdict word is set by rule on every update: resolved — the log records the thesis as resolved; tested — a trigger of the falsifier table has crossed and the log has not yet closed the theme; under pressure — the log marks the theme closing, or a falsifier trigger is closing; holding — otherwise. The words of the verdict restate a passage of the logged claim, which this update checks is in the log.

  • Terms
    The words of the view.

    · · · · · .

  • Documents
    Where the view was argued.
    • the September 2026 report · §3.3 Private credit — the canaries, the balance sheet behind them, and who is exposed · 13 Sept 2026
    • the September 2026 report · §1.7 Credit and quality — clean health, or unmarked risk? · 13 Sept 2026
    • the report's research note on private credit (12 Sep 2026) · Headline read; (b) cycle state; (c) 2026 stress events; (d) exposure chain · 12 Sept 2026
    • the report's working note on private-credit sources · §5 Transmission to banks and insurers; §9 Falsifiers · 12 Sept 2026
    • the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §3.3; §2.6 (model readings removed) · 15 Sept 2026
  • Licences
    What is quoted only.

    Share prices are Yahoo Finance data, shown with their attribution, and the arithmetic on them is calculated on this site. The policy rates and the H.4.1 balance sheet are published. ICE BofA spreads and the Chicago Fed NFCI need a licence or written permission; fund redemption data, default indices, AM Best, Morningstar DBRS and Moody's figures are quoted only.

Source: Macro Reviewthemes.private_credit-19

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.