Macro ReviewHow to read
Outlook · Synthesis · Range and scenarios

Refitted each quarter, the S&P 500's widest band held 43 of 46 quarter-ends

How far could each market move over the next quarter and year, and what would each named path do to it?

ETF closes · 13 Nov 2026Treasury par yields · 16 Nov 2026Updated 16 Nov 2026
S&P 500, the 90% band's record93%held 43 of 46 quarter-ends, refitted each quarter · Kupiec p 0.40consistent with nominal
S&P 500, next 13 weeks±0.0%−11.4%10th–90th, four in five+12.9% median, no change by construction · from 13 Nov 2026
10-year Treasury yield, next 13 weeks±0bp−58bp10th–90th, four in five+57bpchange · zero-drift median, no change by construction · from 16 Nov 2026
WTI crude (USO), next 13 weeks±0.0%−23.1%10th–90th, four in five+29.3%zero-drift median, no change by construction · from 13 Nov 2026
Stocks and bonds both down 5%4.9%share of paths, 13 weeks · independence 5.6%
10-year, the 90% band's record85%46 quarter-ends to 2026 Q2, refitted each quarter · Kupiec p 0.27consistent with nominal

In brief

The 's range for each market, centred on no change, the record of how often its bands have held, and what each named path does to the median
  • Refitted each quarter on the data to that date, the S&P 500's widest band held 43 of 46 quarter-ends since 2015.→ Exhibit 6
  • Over the next quarter the S&P 500 lands between −11.4% and +12.9% in four cases of five, with no view on direction.→ Exhibit 1
  • The 10-year moves between −58bp and +57bp over the next quarter in four cases of five.→ Exhibit 2
  • WTI crude ranges from −23.1% to +29.3% over the next quarter in four cases of five.→ Exhibit 2
  • Stocks and long Treasuries both fall 5% or more over the next quarter in 4.9% of the model's paths.→ Exhibit 12
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
The S&P 500 window from 2026 Q3 leaves its 90% bandS&P 500 change from the 30 Sep 2026 close outside −11.0% to +13.1% at session 65−1.1% after 32 of 65 sessions (13 Nov 2026)pendingthe close of 4 Jan 2027 (session 65)
The 10-year window from 2026 Q3 leaves its 90% band10-year change from the 30 Sep 2026 close outside −69bp to +71bp at session 65−17bp after 31 of 65 sessions (16 Nov 2026)pendingthe close of 6 Jan 2027 (session 65)
The bands are too narrow for the regimemore than one 90% miss for the S&P 500, or for the 10-year, in eight consecutive quarter-ends1 and 2 in the last eight (2024 Q3 – 2026 Q2)crossedeach window as it completes (next 4 Jan 2027)
The bands are too wideeight consecutive quarter-ends inside the S&P 500's 50% band1 in a row to 2026 Q2not crossedeach window as it completes (next 4 Jan 2027)
The reasoning behind each point
  • Coverage
    Refitted each quarter on the data to that date, the S&P 500's widest band held 43 of 46 quarter-ends since 2015.

    Out of sample: at each quarter-end from 2015 Q1 to 2026 Q2 the S&P 500's GARCH(1,1)-t is re-estimated on its returns since 2 Mar 2007 up to that date only, and the band drawn from it scores the next 65 sessions. The 90% band held 93% (Kupiec's test of the miss rate against 10%, p 0.40; Christoffersen's test that misses do not cluster, p 0.51); the 80% band 78% (p 0.77); the 50% band 33% (p 0.02) — the zero-drift centre sits under a market that rose. The 10-year, refitted the same way: 90% 85% (p 0.27), 50% 48% (p 0.77). Windows outside a refitted 90% band, by the quarter-end they start from: 2016 Q3; 2018 Q3; 2019 Q4; 2020 Q4; 2021 Q4; 2023 Q2; 2024 Q3; 2024 Q4; 2026 Q2. The cones' own record, with the volatility model's parameters fitted on the whole sample, held 43 of 46 for the S&P 500 and 85% for the 10-year: in-sample parameters, which have seen the shocks they are scored on. 46 windows are a short record: the tests' p-values are asymptotic (χ²) and only coarse at this size.

  • Equities
    Over the next quarter the S&P 500 lands between −11.4% and +12.9% in four cases of five, with no view on direction.

    The 10th to 90th percentile from the 13 Nov 2026 close, around a zero-drift median of ±0.0%; the 5–95 band is −15.8% to +19.0%. 26 weeks: −15.6% to +18.2%; 52 weeks: −21.4% to +27.4%. With the fitted mean instead of zero drift the 13-week median moves to +6.7%. Nasdaq-100 −18.2% to +22.1%, semiconductors −30.0% to +43.1%. The width is the model's current variance state (S&P 500 daily volatility 23.2% annualised at the start) pulled towards its long-run level over the horizon.

  • Rates
    The 10-year moves between −58bp and +57bp over the next quarter in four cases of five.

    The yields model's 10th to 90th percentile; the 2-year −70bp to +70bp. 10-year over 26 weeks −79bp to +79bp; 52 weeks −110bp to +110bp. The yields model's DCC a = 0.0213, b = 0.9647; 10-year GARCH ν = 13.1. Long Treasuries (TLT, ten core markets) −7.8% to +8.5%.

  • Oil, gold, dollar
    WTI crude ranges from −23.1% to +29.3% over the next quarter in four cases of five.

    Gold −14.0% to +16.4%, the dollar (UUP) −4.1% to +4.2%; on the yields model USO −25.8% to +34.6%, gold −14.8% to +17.0%, UUP −4.1% to +4.3%. Two models on overlapping assets differ because each series' GARCH is fitted on its own set's sessions and the correlations are estimated jointly with different partners; the gap between them is a specification sensitivity in its own right. Bitcoin's cone (−32% to +48%) sits on a fit at the α + β = 1 boundary (α + β = 1.0000), so its expected variance grows with the horizon instead of settling at a long-run level.

  • Joint events
    Stocks and long Treasuries both fall 5% or more over the next quarter in 4.9% of the model's paths.

    Against independence the bonds-fail event would be 5.6% — the difference is the conditional correlation (−0.04 S&P–TLT at the start) doing its work. P(10-year +50bp and S&P 500 −10%) = 1.3%; P(10-year −50bp and S&P 500 +5%) = 3.0%; P(USO +20% and S&P 500 −5%) = 5.2%; P(gold +10% and UUP +3%) = 0.9% (ten core markets). All are model-conditional: the share of paths the fitted model assigns under its own assumptions, not a judgement.

  • Quarter
    Over the next quarter the factor model's S&P 500 median runs from −1.1% to −0.9% across the paths, all inside the range with no scenario.

    The no-scenario 10th–90th band over 1 quarter is −11.6% to +15.8%. At a year the paths' medians lie within a fraction of a point of one another, because the model's stock–bond correlation reverts towards zero; a quarter is where they part.

  • Paths
    The rate paths put the 10-year between 4.07% and 4.17%; none of them carries odds.

    The Fed paths — hold path −106bp, SEP path −100bp, above the dots −96bp — each set the 10-year at the fair value What is priced gives a policy path: the distance from today's yield, so a path asks what happens if the 10-year travels that distance, not when or why. The path above the dots takes the policy-rules grid's one path above the SEP's, +50bp then hold; its fair 10-year still sits below today's yield, so its move (−96bp) is the smallest fall of the three — the market prices more tightening than even that path. The 4 Hormuz paths are listed without odds and are not projected: they carry no oil level yet; the formula cannot price them either, because no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to oil exists among the site's estimates. No path carries a probability: no source the site reads states one. Setting the 10-year conditions the draws rather than replacing them, so the other factors keep their tails.

  • Formula
    At the hold path's 10-year the model's value is still −29.7% from the price; the formula's full pass-through, +29.6%, is arithmetic, not a target.

    Valuation-model arithmetic: the Valuation page's two-stage model — price over trailing earnings = k [(1 + g_L) + H (g_S − g_L)] ÷ (r − g_L) — at its priced inputs (k 0.84, E0 ÷ P 3.985%, g_S 15.1% fading to g_L 4.0% over 6 years, r = 5.12% + 3.502pp), which return today's price. A path moves rf by its full distance and holds the premium and growth — full pass-through, the extreme case — so its move from today is (r0 − g_L) ÷ (r1 − g_L) − 1: +29.6% on the hold path, +27.8% on the SEP path, +26.0% above the dots. The response is convex — −22% per point of the discount rate at today's rate — because r − g_L is 4.62pp today. Oil, credit and the dollar are not modelled on the formula: the site estimates no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to them.

  • Market
    The market prices the 10-year at 5.12%, 106bp above the fair value of a hold.

    From What is priced (16 Nov 2026): the hold path's fair value is 4.065%, the SEP path's 4.115% and the market's own, the ACM-fitted 10-year, 5.111%; the 1y1y forward sits +115bp over the policy rate; the SEP medians are 4.1 for 2026 and 4.1 for 2027, 3.2 in the longer run (16 Sep 2026).

  • Unconditional
    The factor model's 1-year central band for the S&P 500 runs from −19.3% to +35.6%.

    Over 1 year the S&P 500's 10–90 band is −19.3% to +35.6% with the median at +4.7% — close to the cash leg because the simulation carries no drift, not because the engine expects it.

  • Projection coverage
    The published band held 82.4% of outcomes over the 9 quarter-ends kept out of its calibration, from 30 Jun 2024.

    Calibrated: the 10–90 band held 77.1% of 214 asset-quarters since 31 Mar 2022 (74.0–79.9%) against a nominal 80%. Calibrated, so the factor projections head this page beside the engine cones: the width scale estimated on the quarter-ends to 31 Mar 2024 (k = 1.07) held 82.4% of the held-out quarter-ends from 30 Jun 2024 (76.4–88.2), which contains 80%, and the published bands carry it. The 10–90 band held 79.4% (76.8–82.0) with fixed betas and a GARCH-t residual, 78.0% (75.0–80.9) with the betas drawn and 77.1% (74.0–79.9) with the residual bootstrapped; widened by k = 1.07 it would hold 81.3% (78.5–84.0) — applied. Drawing the betas moves the pooled coverage −1.4pp; resampling the residual instead of simulating it moves it −0.9pp. Before any scale the band held 76.4% of the first 9 quarter-ends (to 31 Mar 2024) and 77.8% of the 9 since. A scale estimated on the first half moves the second to 82.4%, which holds, so it is applied. The backtest published before 24 September left the residual out of the band it scored and mapped the four factor-proxy ETFs through betas, so it tested a narrower object than the page drew. The verdict sits on a knife-edge: the uncalibrated band's interval misses 80% by 0.1pp, and under 1 of the 4 alternative seed triples the spec lists it contains 80% instead — so the page's placement owes as much to the simulation's seed as to the bands.

  • Index
    Over three years each +10bp on the 10-year has moved the S&P 500 −1.08%, with credit and the dollar held.

    Per 1% of crude ±0.00%; the 13-week band is about ±8%. Rates beta −1.08 (SE 0.32), oil beta −0.002 (SE 0.027), R² 0.26, residual 1.69% a week, credit and the dollar held; windows end on 13 Nov 2026. The band is almost all residual risk: √13 × 1.69% × 1.2816 = 7.8pp against a beta-uncertainty part below 2pp in every cell of the grid. Nothing in oil and rates alone justifies an index-level view over a quarter.

  • Valuation route
    On the valuation formula a half-point rise in the 10-year moves the S&P 500 −9.8%; oil is not modelled.

    A half-point fall lifts it +12.1%. The grid's valuation route is the Valuation page's two-stage model at the stated 10-year with everything else held (k 0.84, E0 ÷ P 3.985%, near-term growth 15.1% fading to 4.0% over 6 years, r = 5.12% + 3.502pp), which returns today's price at the zero column. It is one row, not a grid: the site estimates no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to oil, credit or the dollar, so those are printed as not modelled rather than given a number. The response is convex (−22% per point of the discount rate at today's rate), which is why −50bp lifts the index by more than +50bp lowers it. Model-conditional: what the identity implies under stated inputs, not a forecast. The branch table on this page runs the same identity for every named scenario.

  • Pair
    The energy − discretionary pair swings 15 points between the hollow-deal and escalation oil moves, against a band of about ±16.

    −7.6 to +7.6: not larger than its uncertainty. Energy's oil beta +0.37 against discretionary's −0.06 per 1% (156 weeks); the band treats the two regressions' errors as independent (their residual correlation is +0.06, so the independent band is wider than a direct regression of the pair would give: 3.49 vs 3.38% a week).

  • Sectors
    A rise in crude lifts oil & gas E&P most, +0.50% per 1%, and hurts homebuilders most.

    Homebuilders −0.10% per 1%. Next: energy +0.37% and consumer discretionary −0.06% per 1% of crude. Per +10bp on the 10-year: homebuilders −2.38%, regional banks −2.21%; least affected consumer staples −0.54%. These are total effects (the market is not in the regression), so they include what comes through the index.

Projections · The claim is that the published bands hold what happens about as often as they say: widened by k = 1.07 on the first half, the 10–90 band held 82.4% of the 108 held-out asset-quarters from 30 Jun 2024 to 30 Jun 2026 (90% bootstrap interval 76.4–88.2%), which contains 80%, so the claim is not falsified on this sample.

Scenarios · The band, not the point, is the model's claim: it is contradicted if the S&P 500's realised 13-week return falls outside the 10th–90th band of the cell at the realised factor moves. To 13 Nov 2026 the moves were +14% oil, +47bp, credit −0.1%, dollar +3.1%: the model gives −7.0% (−14.9 to 1.0) against a realised −2.6% — inside the band.

Earnings · The read that the index's earnings level rests on an extended profit share fails if the after-tax share is back at its 2015–19 average (9.8%, the Profits page's threshold) for two consecutive quarters; the national-accounts read fails if the 0.2pp gap between index EPS growth and profits growth closes to under 0.1pp; the fan is contradicted if calendar-2027 EPS growth lands outside −9% to +22%, and its reading of consensus if the quoted calendar-2027 growth falls below +9.9%.

Next: Range record and stress tests — the range's record and worst weeks

Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculations · data to 13 Nov 2026cross.cones-read

How far each market could move over 3, 6 and 12 months, with no view on direction

The 's distribution over the next quarter, half-year or year, centred on no change so it measures width, not direction; the 's range for every asset beside it

Exhibit 1 · The selected market's recent path and its simulated range ahead

% from the 13 Nov 2026 close: the path so far (black), then 20,000 simulated paths' 5th–95th, 10th–90th and 25th–75th percentiles and median, zero drift
Range: simulated shocksAbout
About this exhibit
The selected market's path over the past sessions relative to the latest close, then the volatility model's cone: the 5th–95th, 10th–90th and 25th–75th percentiles and the median, zero drift by default; the page's selectors change the market, horizon and drift
S&P 500: 13 weeks cone
S&P 500, % from the latest close: the path so far, then the volatility model's 5th–95th, 10th–90th and 25th–75th percentiles, no drift. Its 90% band has held 93% of 46 quarter-ends.
Ten core markets engine, 20,000 paths from the 13 Nov 2026 state; x is sessions from the latest close; the median path ends at ±0.0%: the band is centred on no change and says how far, not which way. Model-conditional: the distribution the fitted model implies from its variance and correlation state, not a forecast.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.cones-2

Exhibit 2 · The selected market's return percentiles by horizon and drift setting

Cumulative simple return from the 13 Nov 2026 close, %; 5th to 95th percentile; zero drift, then fitted mean below; same paths as the simulated range
Range: simulated shocksAbout
Horizon5th10th50th90th95th
13wzero drift−15.8%−11.4%±0.0%+12.9%+19.0%
26wzero drift−21.3%−15.6%+0.1%+18.2%+26.6%
52wzero drift−29.0%−21.4%−0.2%+27.4%+40.3%
13wμ +0.099%/session−10.2%−5.5%+6.7%+20.4%+26.9%
26wμ +0.099%/session−10.5%−4.0%+13.9%+34.4%+44.0%
52wμ +0.099%/session−8.1%+1.7%+29.2%+64.9%+81.6%
About this exhibit
Table of the selected market's 5th, 10th, 50th, 90th and 95th percentile cumulative returns at each horizon, with zero drift and again with the fitted mean
Quantiles by horizon
S&P 500 · cumulative simple return, % · same paths as the cone
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.cones-3

Exhibit 3 · Each asset's range on the factor model, by market group

Simulated return over the chosen horizon, %: 10th–90th range, middle half and median; 10,000 paths, zero drift, from 16 Nov 2026
Range: past misses

The S&P 500 by two roads

Betas times factors, and earnings times a multiple — over the same year, from the same rates draw
Route5th10th25th50th75th90th95th
Factor routecash + Σ β·F̃ + ε−22.4−19.3−7.2+4.7+18.1+35.6+40.9
Valuation routeΔln P = Δln E + Δln PE, on today's multiple−25.2−17.0−4.7+10.2+28.4+49.5+66.6
— its earnings legthe Earnings page's default fan, NIPA bridged to EPS (−0.92 log points a year), by inverse CDF−11.9−8.0−1.4+6.6+15.4+24.0+29.9
— its multiple legthe two-stage identity at the drawn discount rate−30.9−22.9−11.4+2.6+20.7+42.3+59.5

Why the two medians differ, and why this route's tails are long. The factor route's median (+4.7%) is the cash leg: it carries no drift. This route's (+10.2%) carries the Earnings page's bridged growth (median +6.6%) and a multiple leg whose median is +2.6%, because the premium's four-quarter changes, centred on their mean (−0.08pp removed), are skewed (median −0.25pp). Its tails are the identity's convexity: the multiple is close to k ÷ (r − g), with r − g = 4.62pp today, so the discount rate's 5th percentile (6.90%) lifts it by +59.5% while its 95th (10.69%) moves it by −30.9% — a straight line through today's slope would give +37.3% and −44.8%. The tails are drawn as they come, not trimmed.

The multiple moves from today's observed 18.66×, not from a fair one, so the route does not close the valuation gap — it moves what is there by the change in its inputs. r = rf + ERP, starting at 5.12% + 3.50pp, with rf moved by this page's own rates draw and the premium by the pool of 83 four-quarter changes the Valuation page draws its own distribution from, centred on their mean (5th −1.76pp, median −0.25pp, 95th +2.00pp). The three legs are tied by that page's Gaussian copula over 82 quarters. 1 of the draws (0.01%) put the discount rate within 0.5pp of the long-run growth rate, where the identity has no finite price, and are excluded and counted here rather than clipped.

About this exhibit
Bars of each asset's simulated return on the factor model (10th–25th, 25th–75th and 75th–90th percentiles and the median) for a chosen group, with horizon and residual toggles; beneath, a table of the S&P 500's percentiles by two routes (factors, and earnings times a multiple)
Factor projections, nothing pinned
1 year ahead, 10,000 paths, zero drift, betas drawn per path, residual resampled from its own history. The S&P 500's 10–90 band is −19.3% to +35.6% with the median at +4.7% — close to the cash leg (+4.25%) because the simulation carries no drift, not because the engine expects it. The 10–90 band is widened about the median by k = 1.07. The 5–95 band is the widened 10–90 band plus a tail margin that cannot be negative. The margin is 0.46 times the simulated distance from the 10th to the 5th percentile, and from the 90th to the 95th. Both scales are estimated on the backtest's first half, and the 10–90 band's held-out test passes. Model-conditional: this is what one model says, and the Method fold names it. the engine's and the residual's shocks, with the betas' estimation error drawn per path
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.projections-3

Four rate paths, no odds, beside the market's own path

What has to happen on each path, the 10-year it gives, the S&P 500 on the valuation formula and the , and four other assets over a quarter

Exhibit 4 · Each rate path's 10-year and its effect on stocks and other assets

Each path beside the market's own, to 16 Nov 2026: the 10-year, %, factor-model medians over the selected horizon; the valuation column has none
Range: named paths, no odds
About
The rate paths and the market's own: the 10-year, the S&P 500 on the valuation formula and the factor model, four other assets, and what would have to be seen
ScenarioWhat has to happen10-year, %S&P 500, 1 quarterfactor model: median · 10th–90thThe model's value at that 10-year% from today's priceFormula's move% from today · premium and growth heldGoldmedianWTI crude (USO)medianUS dollar bullish (UUP)medianHigh yieldmedianWhat we would need to see
What the market pricesNo change: the policy path priced today, at today's term premium5.11%fair value on the market's path; par 5.12% on 16 Nov 2026+1.1%−11.6% to +15.8%−41.5%±0.0%today's price, the formula's start±0.0%±0.0%±0.0%±0.0%the reference: every row is read against it
Hold pathThe Fed follows “Hold at IORB”; the 10-year falls to that path's fair value4.07%−106bp from today−1.1%−13.4% to +13.3%−29.7%+29.6%full pass-through, no horizon+8.2%−10.4%−2.2%+2.1%10-year at 4.07%5.12% today, 106bp away
SEP pathThe Fed follows “One further +25bp (the SEP path)”; the 10-year falls to that path's fair value4.12%−101bp from today−1.0%−13.3% to +13.4%−30.4%+27.8%full pass-through, no horizon+7.8%−10.0%−2.1%+2.0%10-year at 4.12%5.12% today, 101bp away
Above the dotsThe Fed follows “+50bp, then hold (above the SEP path)”; the 10-year falls to that path's fair value4.17%−96bp from today−0.9%−13.2% to +13.6%−31.0%+26.0%full pass-through, no horizon+7.4%−9.5%−2.0%+1.9%10-year at 4.17%5.12% today, 96bp away

No odds: the site reads no source that states one. At a year the factor model's medians for the paths lie within a fraction of a point of one another; a quarter is the horizon at which they part.

About this exhibit
Table: each Fed rate path beside the market's own: what has to happen, the 10-year it gives, the S&P 500 over the horizon on the factor model, the valuation model's value at that 10-year, the formula's full pass-through move, medians for gold, crude, the dollar and high yield, and what would need to be seen
The rate paths, no odds: the 10-year, the S&P 500 and four other assets
Each path beside the market's own, over 1 quarter. Factor-model medians; the formula's column has no horizon.
Every path sets the 10-year at a value a dated source publishes and holds it. The formula's column is valuation-model arithmetic: the Valuation page's two-stage model (near-term growth 15.1% fading to 4.0% over 6 years, premium 3.50pp) with the whole move in the 10-year passed to the discount rate and the premium and growth held — full pass-through, the extreme case, and a level with no date attached. The factor model's columns are the medians and bands of its simulated returns with the 10-year set on the path and every other factor drawn around it.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; New York Fed; Federal Reserve Board; FactSet; Robert Shiller; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.projections-1

Exhibit 5 · S&P 500 under each rate path against the no-scenario range, by horizon

% from the 16 Nov 2026 close, 1 month to 1 year: the factor model's 10th–90th band with no scenario, and each rate path's median
Range: simulated shocks
About this exhibit
S&P 500 % change from today at each horizon from a month to a year: the factor model's band with no scenario, and each rate path's median
The paths against the range with no scenario, on the factor model
S&P 500, % from today: the factor model's band with no scenario and each path's median at each horizon. The valuation formula's move has no horizon; it is in the paths table, beside the model's value at the same 10-year.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; New York Fed; Federal Reserve Board; FactSet; Robert Shiller; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.projections-12

The bands have held about as often as they promise, since 2015

Coverage — how often past outcomes fell inside the band drawn at the time — at every quarter-end since 2015, refitted each quarter on the data to that date; the full record is on Range record and stress tests

Exhibit 6 · The selected market's outcome after each quarter-end against the band drawn then

65-session return after each quarter-end, 2015 Q1 to 2026 Q2, %; bands refitted to that date; dot black inside 25th–75th, orange inside 5th–95th, red outside
Range: out-of-sample record
About this exhibit
For each quarter-end since 2015, the selected market's realised outcome over the next 65 sessions (a dot coloured by the band it fell in) against the 25–75 and 5–95 bands drawn at that date from the model refitted on data to that date; a toggle switches to full-sample parameters
S&P 500: the record by quarter-end
Realised 65-session outcome (dot: black inside 25–75, orange inside 5–95, red outside; grey = pending) against the bands drawn at each quarter-end from the model refitted on the data from 2 Mar 2007 to that date only, zero drift.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.cones-6

Exhibit 7 · How often each market missed its bands, scored both ways

46 quarter-ends, 2015 Q1 to 2026 Q2, 65 sessions ahead: share held, %, misses against expected, and test p-values (high: consistent with the band)
Range: out-of-sample record
Market · record90% band heldMisses (expected)Kupiec pChristoffersen pBoth, p80% band held (Kupiec p)50% band held (Kupiec p)
S&P 500Refitted each quarter93%3 (4.6)0.400.510.5778% (0.77)33% (0.02)
S&P 500The cones, full-sample parameters93%3 (4.6)0.400.510.5774% (0.32)33% (0.02)
10-year Treasury yieldRefitted each quarter85%7 (4.6)0.270.140.1878% (0.77)48% (0.77)
10-year Treasury yieldThe cones, full-sample parameters85%7 (4.6)0.270.140.1876% (0.52)48% (0.77)
WTI crude (USO)Refitted each quarter89%5 (4.6)0.850.260.5274% (0.32)50% (1.00)
WTI crude (USO)The cones, full-sample parameters87%6 (4.6)0.510.220.3878% (0.77)52% (0.77)

A p-value at or above 0.05 is read as consistent with the band's promise, not as proof the width is right. “–”: no miss was followed by another window, so clustering cannot be tested. The cones' own record has seen the shocks it is scored on; the refitted record has not.

About this exhibit
Table for the S&P 500, the 10-year yield and WTI crude, each scored two ways (refitted each quarter, and full-sample parameters): share inside the 90% band, misses against the number expected, Kupiec, Christoffersen and joint p-values, and the 80% and 50% bands' coverage
How often the bands missed, tested
46 quarter-ends, 2015 Q1 to 2026 Q2, 65 sessions ahead: the refitted record (the model re-estimated on the data to each quarter-end) and the cones' own (full-sample parameters) on the same windows. Kupiec: is the miss rate the band's promise? Christoffersen: do misses cluster? p-values from χ², coarse at this size.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.cones-11

Have the projections' bands held?

Coverage of the 10-90 and 5-95 bands at every quarter-end, for every step of the calibration and both parameter variants

Exhibit 8 · Factor model band coverage by calibration step and asset, against nominal

Share of outcomes inside the 10th–90th band, %, 18 quarter-ends from 31 Mar 2022 to 30 Jun 2026, 214 asset-quarters; dashed at the nominal 80%
Range: out-of-sample record
About
StepCoverage90% intervalHolds 80%?Per asset, below
Fixed betas, residual by GARCH-tthe construction the page published to 23 September: each asset's betas at their point estimates and its residual simulated with its own GARCH(1,1)-t79.4%76.8–82.0yes
(a) Betas drawn from their sampling distributioneach path draws its own betas from the standard errors of the regression that estimated them; the residual is still GARCH-t, which is the alternative the page keeps printing78.0%75.0–80.9yes
(b) Residual by stationary block bootstrapthe residual resampled from the asset's own history of residuals, in blocks of 21 sessions on average, instead of simulated from a fitted GARCH77.1%74.0–79.9no
(c) Calibrated width — publishedthe (b) band's 10–90 widened about its median by a scale k, and its 5–95 the widened 10–90 band plus a tail margin that cannot be negative. Both are fitted on the first half of the quarter-ends, and only the 10–90 band is tested on the second81.3%78.5–84.0yes

The calibration, fitted on one half and tested on the other

k = 1.0721 for the 10–90 band and a tail factor of 0.4590 for the 5–95 — applied to every published band
HalfQuarter-endsBefore kIntervalAfter kInterval
First: k estimated here31 Mar 2022 – 31 Mar 2024 (9)76.4%70.7–83.880.2%76.8–85.0
Second: held out, the test30 Jun 2024 – 30 Jun 2026 (9)77.8%71.5–84.782.4%76.4–88.2

calibratedthe (b) band's pooled 10–90 interval excludes 80% and the widened 10–90 band passes its held-out test, so the published bands carry k and the tail factor.

How much the verdict owes to the seed. Re-run under 4 alternative seed triples (factor draws, residual resample, beta draws), the uncalibrated band's pooled 10–90 interval contains 80% in 1 of them: 76.6% (73.9–79.4), 77.1% (74.3–80.1), 77.1% (74.5–79.9), 76.6% (73.8–79.4). The published bands use the spec's own seeds and are calibrated; 4 of the 4 alternatives would give calibrated.

Per asset: (c) Calibrated width.

Point in time throughout: the filtered state, the betas and their errors, the residual's variance and its bootstrap pool. The GARCH and DCC parameters are the full sample's, which contains the outcomes and therefore flatters these numbers. A factor-proxy ETF takes its raw factor draw, as on the page, so the betas and the residual change nothing for it; only the calibration does.

About this exhibit
Table of the factor model's band coverage at each calibration step (fixed betas, betas drawn, residual resampled, width calibrated) with intervals; then the calibration by half-sample, and bars of coverage for each asset against the nominal line
Have the bands held?
The 10–90 band at 18 quarter-ends from 31 Mar 2022 to 30 Jun 2026, 214 asset-quarters over 12 assets, drawn at each quarter-end the way the page draws it today and scored at every step of the calibration. Each interval is a 90% block bootstrap over quarter-ends: the assets are correlated — in the quarter the market fell, every band was tested by the same fall — so a binomial interval would be far too narrow.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.projections-5

Every asset under each path

The distribution of each asset's return over each horizon when a path's 10-year holds — the 's medians and bands

Exhibit 9 · Each asset's return with and without the selected path

Median, %, from 16 Nov 2026: with no path, with the path, the difference, and the 10th–90th band under the path; horizon, path and group selectable
Range: named paths, no odds
AssetMedian, no pinMedian, pinnedDifference10th90th
MSCI ACWI+4.7%+4.8%+0.1−18.6%+33.9%
Dow Jones Industrials+4.5%+4.9%+0.4−17.4%+33.4%
Emerging markets+4.6%+6.3%+1.7−25.8%+50.7%
Developed ex-US (EAFE)+4.5%+7.7%+3.2−16.3%+38.9%
Japan+4.6%+4.4%−0.2−22.2%+39.3%
China large-cap+4.3%+8.2%+3.9−24.6%+54.2%
Russell 2000+4.6%+6.7%+2.1−23.5%+48.7%
S&P MidCap 400+4.8%+6.7%+1.9−17.5%+37.1%
Nasdaq-100+4.5%+0.5%−3.9−30.1%+43.4%
S&P 500 equal weight+4.7%+7.8%+3.1−12.7%+32.6%
S&P 500+4.7%+2.8%−1.9−20.7%+33.0%
Europe+4.4%+8.4%+4.0−17.8%+42.8%

Why the pins barely move the index: a ten-year pin reaches the S&P 500 almost only through the market factor's co-movement with the ten-year in the engine's draws — +0.21% per 10bp over 1 month, +0.16% per 10bp over 1 quarter, +0.12% per 10bp over 6 months, +0.13% per 10bp over 1 year — today's correlation at short horizons, reverting to about zero, its average since 2018, by a year. Over 1 year the hold path's −106bp therefore shifts the index's mean return by −1.78pp, within noise in a distribution whose 10–90 band is 54pp wide: −1.38pp through the market, +0.02pp through credit, −0.08pp through the rest and −0.34pp through the index's own ten-year beta once the market is in the regression (+0.033% per 10bp, t = 3.44, beyond the site's |t| > 2).

What is priced puts the same path at +11.3% for the S&P 500 because it is a different model: a total-effect beta (−1.08% per +10bp from 156 weekly returns since 24 Nov 2023 on oil, the ten-year, HYG − LQD and the dollar, with no market factor, so the index's own co-movement with yields in that window is inside it) times the −106bp still to come, with oil, HYG − LQD and the dollar held fixed and no horizon; here nothing is held fixed and the market's response is the engine's correlation at each horizon.

About this exhibit
Table: each asset's median return with and without the selected path's pin, the difference, and the 10th–90th band under the pin, at the selected horizon (horizon, path and asset group selectable)
Every asset under “Hold path”, 1 year ahead
The median with the pin against the median without it, and the 10–90 band under the pin (10-year yield −106bp). A pin conditions the draws rather than replacing them, so the difference is what the engine's correlations carry from the pinned factor to the rest — not a separate forecast. The 10–90 band is widened about the median by k = 1.07. The 5–95 band is the widened 10–90 band plus a tail margin that cannot be negative. The margin is 0.46 times the simulated distance from the 10th to the 5th percentile, and from the 90th to the 95th. Both scales are estimated on the backtest's first half, and the 10–90 band's held-out test passes. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.projections-4

Earnings under nominal-GDP scenarios

Where the model takes EPS over eight quarters under stated nominal GDP growth - conditional arithmetic, not forecasts

Exhibit 10 · EPS growth under each nominal GDP growth rate, against consensus

Four-quarter growth of trailing reported EPS, %, from Q2 2026 under three nominal GDP growth scenarios, with the regression's out-of-sample band.
About
About this exhibit
Chart: four-quarter growth of trailing reported EPS over the paths' quarters under each nominal GDP growth scenario, with the regression's out-of-sample error band and FactSet consensus points.
The regression's eight-quarter EPS paths under nominal GDP scenarios
Four-quarter growth of trailing reported EPS from Q2 2026 under 4, 5 and 6% nominal GDP growth, with the regression's out-of-sample band.
Model-conditional, not forecasts (headline, ex-2008–10). Four-quarter growth of trailing reported EPS from Q2 2026: nominal GDP at 4, 5 or 6%, the dollar and WTI held at their Oct 2026 prints, the margin gap closing over eight quarters; band ± the out-of-sample RMSE. The three paths are scenarios named paths, no odds and the band is the regression's out-of-sample error out-of-sample record; they are the regression's answers under stated paths, not the model's expectation, which is the fan's +4.7% for calendar 2027. Consensus is FactSet's quoted calendar-year growth, drawn at each year's fourth quarter. Every quarter shown, the paths, the selected band and the consensus points are on the axis.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Robert J. Shiller; Federal Reserve Board (H.10); EIA; FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.earnings-4

Exhibit 11 · Calendar-year EPS growth: the regression's range, the model and consensus

4-quarter EPS growth at Q4 2027 under nominal GDP growth of 4, 5 and 6%; the regression's answer, not the model's expectation (last row).
ItemValueMeaning
Low+5.6%4% nominal GDP scenario, Q4 2027
The regression's mid+14.1%5% scenario (the regression's path at Q4 2027) named paths, no odds
High+22.6%6% scenario
Out-of-sample RMSE21.8ppheadline model, Q1 2022 – Q2 2026 out-of-sample record
The model's expectation (the fan)+4.7%the model's fan, carried to EPS: median, 10th–90th −9.3 to +21.8% past misses
Consensus, calendar 2027+15.1%FactSet, quoted 11 Sept 2026
Gap, mid − consensus−1.0ppinside ± the out-of-sample error
About this exhibit
Table: calendar-year EPS growth under each nominal GDP growth scenario, the regression's out-of-sample error, the model's expectation, consensus and the gap.
The regression's calendar-2027 band against consensus
4-quarter EPS growth at Q4 2027 under nominal GDP growth of 4, 5 and 6%; the regression's answer, not the model's expectation (last row).
Headline model, Q1 1990 – Q4 2019, Q4 2008 – Q3 2010 excluded, conditional on those nominal-growth paths. It is the expected earnings of the Valuation page's one-stage comparison column only: that page's two-stage model takes its near-term growth from the fan, not from this band.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Robert J. Shiller; FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.earnings-15

What moves that hurt together are worth, against independence

What the model assigns to a few combinations of moves at once, and what independence alone would have given

Exhibit 12 · How often paired moves happen together by horizon, against independence

Share of paths from the 13 Nov 2026 close in which both legs hold, %, at 65, 130 and 260 sessions; legs alone and their product
About
EventEngine13 weeks26 weeks52 weeks
P(both)with meanP(A) · P(B)if independentP(both)with meanP(A) · P(B)if independentP(both)with meanP(A) · P(B)if independent
WTI crude (USO) +20% and S&P 500 −5%spine5.2%2.9%18 · 274.8%7.6%3.3%25 · 338.3%10.8%2.8%32 · 3812.2%
TLT −5% and S&P 500 −5% (bonds fail as a hedge)spine4.9%1.6%21 · 275.6%8.2%1.8%28 · 339.4%11.7%1.4%35 · 3813.3%
Gold +10% and dollar (UUP) +3%spine0.9%3.0%20 · 183.7%2.5%10.4%26 · 266.9%4.7%24.0%31 · 3310.3%
10-year +50bp and S&P 500 −10%yields1.3%0.6%13 · 141.8%3.1%1.0%20 · 214.1%6.2%1.2%27 · 287.8%
10-year −50bp and S&P 500 +5%yields3.0%5.6%13 · 303.9%5.4%12.1%20 · 357.1%8.6%18.9%27 · 3910.7%
WTI crude (USO) +20% and S&P 500 −5%yields6.3%3.6%20 · 295.8%8.6%3.9%26 · 348.9%11.4%3.1%32 · 3912.4%
Gold +10% and dollar (UUP) +3%yields0.9%3.0%21 · 183.9%2.5%10.0%27 · 267.1%4.6%23.5%32 · 3310.6%
About this exhibit
Table of paired events across the two engines at each horizon: share of paths in which both legs hold (zero drift, and with the fitted mean), each leg's own share, and their product under independence
Joint events
Share of paths in which both legs hold at the horizon, zero drift (with the fitted mean in grey); the marginals and their product show what the correlation adds. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.cones-4

Factor paths

The simulated factors, with no scenario and under each path

Exhibit 13 · Simulated moves in the market factors, with and without a path

Cumulative over the selected horizon (default 1 year) from 16 Nov 2026: price factors %, yield factors bp; bands of the simulated draws
Range: past misses

Yield factors, basis points

About this exhibit
Chart: simulated bands of the nine raw factors, cumulative over the selected horizon (price factors %, the two yield factors bp), with no scenario and under the selected path
Factor paths over 1 year — The ten-year at the hold path's fair value
The nine raw factors as the engine simulates them, cumulative over the horizon: price factors in percent, the two yield factors in basis points. Under the branch, the pinned factor is a single value and the others are shifted by their regression on it; each draw keeps its own residual, so the unpinned factors keep their tails. Model-conditional. the engine's shocks, drawn forward
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.projections-2

The paths that are not projected

Every named path whose 10-year has no signed, dated source, and why the formula cannot price it either

Exhibit 14 · The paths that are not projected

Scenarios of the 8 with no dated 10-year or oil value, each named with the reason it is not priced, as of 16 Nov 2026
  • The ten-year up by the term premium's last three months

    The expected path of short rates stays where it is and the ten-year rises by as much as the ACM term premium rose over the last three months — compensation for duration repricing again, not the Committee. The adverse branch for bonds: the only one in the set in which yields go up.

    Not projected: no decision by the author.

  • Hollow deal

    Washington blesses the Iran–Oman corridor and keeps the blockade; a reopening by regional consent without a US–Iran agreement (Brent $80–95 in the grid).

    Not projected: its pin would be read from the author's signed scenario file for the Hormuz thesis, which has not been written yet; and the valuation identity cannot price an oil branch either — no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to oil exists among the site's estimates, so oil is not modelled. The pin would be the author's signed scenario file's “hollow” oil level.

  • Attrition

    Both sides hold to 3 November: transits 5–20 a day, shut-ins of 5.7 mb/d through 4Q (Brent $100–115).

    Not projected: its pin would be read from the author's signed scenario file for the Hormuz thesis, which has not been written yet; and the valuation identity cannot price an oil branch either — no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to oil exists among the site's estimates, so oil is not modelled. The pin would be the author's signed scenario file's “attrition” oil level.

  • Escalation

    A mistake path — a Pickaxe strike on IAEA-verified movement, Gulf energy infrastructure, or an Iranian missile that hits a US ship (Brent above $120).

    Not projected: its pin would be read from the author's signed scenario file for the Hormuz thesis, which has not been written yet; and the valuation identity cannot price an oil branch either — no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to oil exists among the site's estimates, so oil is not modelled. The pin would be the author's signed scenario file's “escalation” oil level.

  • Genuine deal

    A sequencing device is found — an escrow or custodian for the HEU that makes Iran's irreversible concession simultaneous with America's reversible one.

    Not projected: the log states no Brent level for this branch, so it is listed and not projected.

No path carries odds: none of the 6 theme logs holds a dated row of judgement odds written by the author, so the set is printed as paths with their effects and no central path is claimed.

About this exhibit
List of the named scenarios with no dated 10-year or oil level (the 10-year up by the term premium's last three months, hollow deal, attrition, escalation, genuine deal), each with its definition and the reason it is not priced
The named paths that are not projected
5 of 8 branches are not projected. They are here rather than absent: a scenario set that quietly dropped the branches it could not price would look more complete than it is.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.projections-7

The joint model's bands, held in a fold until their record passes

The conditional BVAR's 1- and 4-quarter bands on each path, and the coverage record that keeps them here

Exhibit 15 · The macro variables and the 10-year under each Fed and Hormuz path

Change from 16 Nov 2026 at 12 months, with 90% bands; conditioned on each path's funds rate and crude; record: 0 of 12 cells pass
PathConditions at 4qNonfarm payrolls%, change from todayUnemployment rateppCore PCE prices%, change from todayCPI, all items%, change from todayIndustrial production%, change from today10-year Treasurypp
Hold paththe policy steps of the path What is priced defines (no move); WTI heldfunds rate 3.75%crude ±0% (log)+3.11+0.88 to +5.34 simulated shocks+2.96+1.38 to +4.55 simulated shocks+3.18+2.35 to +4.00 simulated shocks+4.11+2.90 to +5.33 simulated shocks+3.54−0.31 to +7.40 simulated shocks+4.00+3.18 to +4.82 simulated shocks
SEP paththe policy steps of the path What is priced defines (+25bp in quarter 1); WTI heldfunds rate 4.00%crude ±0% (log)+3.26+1.03 to +5.49 simulated shocks+2.89+1.30 to +4.47 simulated shocks+3.19+2.37 to +4.02 simulated shocks+4.15+2.93 to +5.36 simulated shocks+3.64−0.21 to +7.50 simulated shocks+4.04+3.22 to +4.86 simulated shocks
Above the dotsthe policy steps of the path What is priced defines (+50bp in quarter 1); WTI heldfunds rate 4.25%crude ±0% (log)+3.42+1.19 to +5.65 simulated shocks+2.81+1.22 to +4.40 simulated shocks+3.21+2.39 to +4.04 simulated shocks+4.18+2.97 to +5.40 simulated shocks+3.75−0.11 to +7.60 simulated shocks+4.08+3.26 to +4.90 simulated shocks
Hollow dealBrent at $87.5, the mid-point of range the log states (2026-09-13), from the September report's locked $104.61; the funds rate heldfunds rate 3.75%crude −18% (log)+3.18+0.95 to +5.41 simulated shocks+2.87+1.28 to +4.45 simulated shocks+2.96+2.14 to +3.79 simulated shocks+3.44+2.22 to +4.65 simulated shocks+3.50−0.36 to +7.35 simulated shocks+3.86+3.04 to +4.68 simulated shocks
AttritionBrent at $107.5, the mid-point of range the log states (2026-09-13), from the September report's locked $104.61; the funds rate heldfunds rate 3.75%crude +3% (log)+3.10+0.87 to +5.33 simulated shocks+2.98+1.39 to +4.57 simulated shocks+3.21+2.38 to +4.04 simulated shocks+4.21+3.00 to +5.43 simulated shocks+3.55−0.31 to +7.40 simulated shocks+4.02+3.20 to +4.84 simulated shocks
EscalationBrent at $120, the floor of the open range the log states (2026-09-13), from the September report's locked $104.61; the funds rate heldfunds rate 3.75%crude +14% (log)+3.06+0.83 to +5.29 simulated shocks+3.04+1.45 to +4.63 simulated shocks+3.34+2.51 to +4.17 simulated shocks+4.63+3.41 to +5.85 simulated shocks+3.58−0.28 to +7.43 simulated shocks+4.10+3.28 to +4.92 simulated shocks

The coverage record (thresholds: Kupiec p ≥ 0.05, independence p ≥ 0.05, at least 20 origins)

Variable · horizonInsideKupiec pIndependence pPasses
Nonfarm payrolls · 1q81 of 103 (79%)0.000.00 (103)no
Nonfarm payrolls · 4q65 of 103 (63%)0.000.04 (26)no
Unemployment rate · 1q73 of 103 (71%)0.000.00 (103)no
Unemployment rate · 4q62 of 103 (60%)0.000.51 (26)no
Core PCE prices · 1q74 of 103 (72%)0.000.02 (103)no
Core PCE prices · 4q58 of 103 (56%)0.000.16 (26)no
CPI, all items · 1q67 of 103 (65%)0.000.02 (103)no
CPI, all items · 4q52 of 103 (50%)0.000.62 (26)no
Industrial production · 1q81 of 103 (79%)0.000.07 (103)no
Industrial production · 4q69 of 103 (67%)0.000.56 (26)no
10-year Treasury · 1q80 of 103 (78%)0.000.56 (103)no
10-year Treasury · 4q58 of 103 (56%)0.000.19 (26)no

Model-conditional: a conditional forecast's bands are the plug-in Gaussian quantiles of the model around the stated paths; parameter uncertainty is not integrated out, and the record is what says whether that matters.

About this exhibit
Table: change from today in payrolls, unemployment, core PCE, CPI, industrial production and the 10-year at the selected horizon under each Fed and Hormuz path, with bands; and the coverage record table
The joint model's bands on each path — in a fold until their record passes
A conditional BVAR of 8 monthly series since 1990-01 (6 lags; Minnesota prior, tightness 0.2, decay 1), conditioned on each path's funds rate and crude oil; the 90% band at 4q. Record: 0 of 12 cells pass on 103 quarter-end origins since 2000-03.
Model-conditional: the bands are the model's plug-in Gaussian quantiles around the stated paths, parameter uncertainty not integrated out. A variable in log levels reads as its change from today; a rate as its level. The record re-estimates the model at every quarter-end, conditions on the paths later realised and scores each band against the outcome with Kupiec's coverage test and Christoffersen's independence test at the thresholds printed below; the bands sit above the folds only when every cell passes — which they do not yet. The dollar is left out: the Board's broad dollar index starts in January 2006 and the earlier major-currencies index was discontinued in 2019; no series the site reads covers 1990 onward, so the dollar is not a variable (the scenario set pins none on it).
Source: BLS; BEA; Federal Reserve G.17 and H.15; EIA; Macro Review calculations · data to 2026-09cross.projections-13

What an oil move and a 10-year move do, with credit and the dollar held

What an oil move (rows) and a 10-year move (columns) do over the horizon, with credit and the dollar held unchanged: the point and its 10th–90th band; and the valuation formula's row

Exhibit 16 · The selected asset's change for each oil and 10-year move

%, point and 10th–90th band over 13 weeks, 156-week betas to 13 Nov 2026; rows: oil moves, columns: 10-year moves; credit and the dollar held
Range: named paths, no odds
About
Click a cell to list every asset at it.
Oil \ 10-year−75bp−50bp−25bp±0bp+25bp+50bpnow+75bp+100bp
−40%+8.2%-0.2 to 16.5+5.5%-2.6 to 13.5+2.8%-5.2 to 10.7+0.1%-7.8 to 8.0−2.6%-10.7 to 5.5−5.3%-13.6 to 3.0−8.0%-16.7 to 0.7−10.7%-19.8 to -1.5
−30%+8.1%-0.2 to 16.5+5.5%-2.6 to 13.5+2.8%-5.1 to 10.7+0.1%-7.8 to 8.0−2.6%-10.6 to 5.4−5.3%-13.6 to 2.9−8.0%-16.6 to 0.6−10.7%-19.8 to -1.6
−20%Hollow deal+8.1%-0.2 to 16.5+5.4%-2.6 to 13.5+2.7%-5.1 to 10.6±0.0%-7.8 to 7.9−2.6%-10.6 to 5.3−5.3%-13.5 to 2.8−8.0%-16.6 to 0.5−10.7%-19.7 to -1.7
−10%+8.1%-0.3 to 16.5+5.4%-2.7 to 13.5+2.7%-5.2 to 10.6±0.0%-7.8 to 7.9−2.7%-10.6 to 5.2−5.4%-13.5 to 2.8−8.1%-16.5 to 0.4−10.7%-19.6 to -1.8
±0%Attrition+8.1%-0.3 to 16.5+5.4%-2.7 to 13.5+2.7%-5.2 to 10.6±0.0%-7.8 to 7.8−2.7%-10.6 to 5.2−5.4%-13.5 to 2.7−8.1%-16.5 to 0.3−10.8%-19.6 to -1.9
+10%now +14%, +47bp+8.1%-0.4 to 16.5+5.4%-2.8 to 13.5+2.7%-5.2 to 10.6±0.0%-7.9 to 7.8−2.7%-10.6 to 5.2−5.4%-13.5 to 2.7−8.1%-16.5 to 0.3−10.8%-19.6 to -2.0
+20%Escalation+8.0%-0.5 to 16.6+5.3%-2.8 to 13.5+2.6%-5.3 to 10.6±0.0%-7.9 to 7.8−2.7%-10.6 to 5.1−5.4%-13.5 to 2.6−8.1%-16.5 to 0.2−10.8%-19.6 to -2.1
+30%+8.0%-0.6 to 16.6+5.3%-2.9 to 13.6+2.6%-5.4 to 10.6−0.1%-8.0 to 7.8−2.8%-10.7 to 5.1−5.5%-13.5 to 2.6−8.1%-16.5 to 0.2−10.8%-19.5 to -2.1
+40%+8.0%-0.7 to 16.7+5.3%-3.0 to 13.6+2.6%-5.5 to 10.7−0.1%-8.0 to 7.8−2.8%-10.7 to 5.2−5.5%-13.5 to 2.6−8.2%-16.5 to 0.2−10.9%-19.6 to -2.2
+60%+7.9%-1.0 to 16.9+5.2%-3.3 to 13.8+2.5%-5.7 to 10.8−0.1%-8.2 to 7.9−2.8%-10.9 to 5.2−5.5%-13.7 to 2.6−8.2%-16.6 to 0.1−10.9%-19.6 to -2.2

Bold: |point| exceeds the half-band (the betas can tell the scenario from noise). Oil changes are log changes in USO; the 10-year change is in the Treasury par yield.

About this exhibit
Grid: the selected asset's change over the horizon (point and 10th–90th band) for each oil move (rows) and 10-year move (columns), credit and the dollar held; Hormuz scenarios marked on the oil rows; the realised quarter marked 'now'; a route toggle shows the S&P 500 on the valuation formula
S&P 500: index change from the betas
Point ± 10th–90th over 13 weeks on 156-week four-factor betas to 13 Nov 2026; credit and the dollar held unchanged. Shaded columns: the September review's cell-yield range 4.70–5.35% against 4.96%. Row marks: the Hormuz log's branches with a Brent range, at their mid-points (the log's revision of 14 Sept 2026), no odds attached; the genuine deal has no Brent level and is not placed. "now" = the realised 13 weeks to 13 Nov 2026. The rows and columns are stated moves ; the band is the regression's residual over the horizon and its betas' error .
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve Board (H.10); Macro Review calculationscross.scenarios-1

Exhibit 17 · The selected asset's change by 10-year move, at the selected oil move

%, point and 10th–90th band over 13 weeks, 156-week betas to 13 Nov 2026; oil row as selected in the grid
Range: past misses
About this exhibit
The selected asset's point and 10th–90th band over the horizon across the 10-year moves, for the oil row selected in the grid
S&P 500 across the 10-year columns at oil +20%
Point and 10th–90th band over 13 weeks; 156-week betas. The 10-year is the axis the index is sensitive to; the oil row is the one selected in the grid. The band barely narrows toward the zero cell: it is mostly residual risk, and the axis is drawn to hold both its edges.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve Board (H.10); Macro Review calculationscross.scenarios-3

Every asset at the cell

Every asset at the chosen cell of the surface, with its 10th–90th band and whether the point exceeds it

Exhibit 18 · Every asset's move at the selected oil and 10-year move

%, point and 10th–90th band over 13 weeks at the selected grid cell; 156-week betas to 13 Nov 2026, credit and the dollar held
Range: past missesAbout
AssetPoint10th90thHalf-bandBeta share of varianceExceeds band
Index
S&P 500SPY−5.4%−13.5%+2.6%8.06%no
S&P 500 equal weightRSP−6.4%−13.4%+0.6%7.06%no
Nasdaq-100QQQ−6.0%−17.7%+5.7%11.75%no
Russell 2000IWM−9.9%−20.3%+0.6%10.43%no
Sectors
TechnologyXLK−6.5%−21.3%+8.2%14.75%no
Communication servicesXLC−4.1%−14.0%+5.8%9.95%no
Consumer discretionaryXLY−8.2%−19.3%+2.8%11.04%no
Consumer staplesXLP−3.2%−10.3%+4.0%7.16%no
Health careXLV−3.6%−13.1%+5.9%9.55%no
FinancialsXLF−6.6%−15.8%+2.6%9.26%no
IndustrialsXLI−7.1%−15.7%+1.6%8.75%no
EnergyXLE+3.9%−8.4%+16.3%12.47%no
MaterialsXLB−6.4%−15.9%+3.1%9.56%no
UtilitiesXLU−4.5%−13.7%+4.8%9.35%no
Real estateXLRE−8.2%−16.3%−0.1%8.14%yes
Industries
SemiconductorsSMH−8.3%−29.3%+12.7%21.04%no
Oil & gas E&PXOP+6.8%−7.4%+21.0%14.26%no
Regional banksKRE−10.8%−26.1%+4.4%15.25%no
HomebuildersXHB−14.0%−28.1%+0.2%14.12%no
TransportsIYT−8.5%−19.6%+2.5%11.05%no
RetailXRT−8.3%−20.2%+3.7%11.94%no
REITsVNQ−8.4%−16.3%−0.5%7.95%yes
Style spreads
Growth − valueGRW-VAL−0.9%−11.3%+9.4%10.34%no
Momentum − S&P 500MOM−2.2%−10.3%+6.0%8.14%no
Quality − S&P 500QUAL+0.1%−2.3%+2.4%2.34%no
Small − largeSMALL−4.4%−12.0%+3.1%7.63%no
Equal − cap weightBREADTH−0.9%−6.0%+4.1%5.14%no
Low vol − S&P 500LOWVOL+1.6%−4.4%+7.5%6.03%no
Cyclicals − defensivesCYC-DEF−3.2%−11.4%+4.9%8.14%no
AI complex − defensivesAI-DEF−4.2%−23.0%+14.6%18.84%no
Pair
Energy − Consumer discretionaryXLE − XLY+12.2%−4.4%+28.8%16.65%no

The pair's variance adds both covariance matrices and both residual variances as if the two regressions' errors were independent (their residual correlation over 156 weeks is +0.06).

About this exhibit
Table: every asset (indexes, sectors, industries, style spreads and the energy − discretionary pair) at the selected grid cell: point, 10th–90th band, half-band, the betas' share of variance and whether the point exceeds its band
Every asset at the cell
156-week four-factor betas; 13 weeks; credit and the dollar held unchanged. Bold: |point| exceeds the half-band. S&P 500 at this cell on the grid's window: −5.4%.
Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve Board (H.10); Macro Review calculationscross.scenarios-4

What actually happened last quarter

Where the last quarter sits: what crude and the 10-year actually did over 13 weeks, and whether the index landed inside the band

Exhibit 19 · Rolling 13-week change in crude oil and the 10-year yield

Weekly (Fridays), 17 Nov 2023 to 13 Nov 2026: crude, % (USO); 10-year, bp
About this exhibit
Chart: rolling 13-week change in crude (USO, %) and the 10-year yield (bp), weekly over the last three years
Realised 13-week moves in the two grid factors
Weekly (Fridays), last three years. To 13 Nov 2026: crude +14.0%, 10-year +47bp, credit −0.1%, dollar +3.1%; the S&P 500 −2.6% against the model's −7.0% (-14.9 to 1.0) at those four moves — inside the band.
Source: Yahoo Finance USO (licensed, derived statistic) and Treasury's 10-year par yield (public).cross.scenarios-7

Appendix

How the models are specified and simulated, what the coverage backtest scores, and every source behind the page249 checks, all pass
About this page
One job per model. The site's volatility model gives each market's range, centred on no change, with the record of how often its past bands held. The factor model sets each named path for the policy rate as a shift against that range, with no odds on any path. The oil and 10-year surface and the earnings paths under stated nominal growth sit beneath. Model-conditional distributions, not forecasts.

The volatility model: GARCH(1,1) with Student-t shocks per market, a scalar DCC across them

rj,t=μj+hj,t εj,t,hj,t+1=ωj+αj (rj,t−μj)2+βj hj,tr_{j,t} = \mu_j + \sqrt{h_{j,t}}\,\varepsilon_{j,t}, \qquad h_{j,t+1} = \omega_j + \alpha_j\,(r_{j,t}-\mu_j)^2 + \beta_j\,h_{j,t}
εt=Ltzt,LtLt′=Rt=diag⁡(Qt)−1/2 Qt diag⁡(Qt)−1/2,zj,t=νj−2νj  tνj\varepsilon_t = L_t z_t,\quad L_tL_t' = R_t = \operatorname{diag}(Q_t)^{-1/2}\,Q_t\,\operatorname{diag}(Q_t)^{-1/2},\quad z_{j,t} = \sqrt{\tfrac{\nu_j-2}{\nu_j}}\;t_{\nu_j}
Qt+1=(1−a−b) Qˉ+a εtεt′+b Qt,Qˉ=1T∑tztzt′Q_{t+1} = (1-a-b)\,\bar Q + a\,\varepsilon_t\varepsilon_t' + b\,Q_t, \qquad \bar Q = \tfrac{1}{T}\textstyle\sum_t z_t z_t'
SymbolMeaningFromAssumed or estimated
rj,tr_{j,t}daily log return × 100 (a yield's daily change in basis points)Yahoo Finance adjusted closes; U.S. Treasury par yields–
hj,th_{j,t}the conditional variance of market jfiltered with the fitted parameters (arch's recursion, backcast start)–
μj\mu_j, ωj\omega_j, αj\alpha_j, βj\beta_j, νj\nu_jmean, variance intercept, shock and persistence weights, the t's degrees of freedommaximum likelihood per seriesestimated
aa, bb, Qˉ\bar Qthe correlation recursion's weights and its long-run matrixquasi-maximum likelihood on the standardised residualsestimated
zj,tz_{j,t}independent Student-t draws scaled to unit variancesimulated–

Two engines: the core-markets fit (3,058 sessions from 18 Sep 2014; a = 0.0180, b = 0.9660), reused from the regime page without re-estimation, and the yields fit (3,213 sessions from 3 Jan 2014; a = 0.0213, b = 0.9647). The parameters are estimated once on the whole sample; the state (h, Q) is filtered to each date with them.

The cone, its record and the two coverage tests

Sj,H=∑t=1Hhj,T+t εj,T+t(μj:=0),cone={Qp(eSj,H/100−1)}p=5,…,95S_{j,H} = \textstyle\sum_{t=1}^{H} \sqrt{h_{j,T+t}}\,\varepsilon_{j,T+t} \quad (\mu_j := 0), \qquad \text{cone} = \{Q_p(e^{S_{j,H}/100}-1)\}_{p=5,\dots,95}
Iq=1{ yq∉[Q^lo(q),Q^hi(q)] },θ^(q)=arg⁡max⁡θL(θ; rs≤q)I_q = \mathbf 1\{\,y_q \notin [\hat Q_{lo}^{(q)}, \hat Q_{hi}^{(q)}]\,\}, \qquad \hat\theta^{(q)} = \arg\max_\theta L(\theta;\, r_{s \le q})
LRuc=−2ln⁡(1−π)n−xπx(1−π^)n−xπ^x∼χ12,π^=x/nLR_{uc} = -2\ln\frac{(1-\pi)^{n-x}\pi^{x}}{(1-\hat\pi)^{n-x}\hat\pi^{x}} \sim \chi^2_1, \qquad \hat\pi = x/n
LRind=−2ln⁡(1−π^2)n00+n10 π^2 n01+n11(1−π^01)n00π^01 n01(1−π^11)n10π^11 n11∼χ12,LRcc=LRuc+LRind∼χ22LR_{ind} = -2\ln\frac{(1-\hat\pi_2)^{n_{00}+n_{10}}\,\hat\pi_2^{\,n_{01}+n_{11}}}{(1-\hat\pi_{01})^{n_{00}}\hat\pi_{01}^{\,n_{01}}(1-\hat\pi_{11})^{n_{10}}\hat\pi_{11}^{\,n_{11}}} \sim \chi^2_1, \qquad LR_{cc} = LR_{uc} + LR_{ind} \sim \chi^2_2
SymbolMeaningFromAssumed or estimated
Sj,HS_{j,H}the cumulative move over H = 65, 130 or 260 sessions on one simulated path (20,000 paths; the record 5,000)simulated from the fitted model–
μj:=0\mu_j := 0zero drift: the band measures width, not directionassumed (the fitted mean is an option)assumed
yqy_qthe realised 65-session move from quarter-end qYahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury–
θ^(q)\hat\theta^{(q)}the market's GARCH(1,1)-t refitted on its data from 2 Mar 2007 to quarter-end q only — the out-of-sample recordmaximum likelihood at each quarter-endestimated
π\pi, π^\hat\pithe miss rate the band promises (1 − its coverage) and the rate observed, x misses in n windowsthe record–
nijn_{ij}, π^01\hat\pi_{01}, π^11\hat\pi_{11}transitions from a hit (0) or a miss (1) to the next window's, and the miss rates after eachthe record–

Model-conditional, not a forecast. The engine's own record uses the full-sample parameters (in-sample, printed beside); the refitted record uses θ̂ from data to each quarter-end only. For the S&P 500, the first series in the core-markets engine, the univariate refit is exactly the engine's marginal; for the 10-year and WTI the engine mixes t draws through the correlation factor, which keeps each variance recursion and changes only the shape. 46 windows: the χ² p-values are asymptotic.

Exhibit 20 · Specification

How the numbers are made, step by step

  1. Prices and yields. Source: Yahoo Finance daily closes; Treasury par yields (2- and 10-year). Transform: daily returns and yield changes on the sessions every series printed. Check: the backtest's outcomes equal the raw files (3 checks, all passing).
  2. The two engines. Source: the ten-core-markets fit the regime page cached (not refitted) and a yields fit here. Transform: GARCH(1,1)-t per series and a scalar DCC on the standardised residuals, filtered to today's state. Check: the filtered states reproduce the cached engine; stationarity of both recursions (5 checks, all passing).
  3. The cones. Source: step 2. Transform: core.cones: 20,000 paths from today's state at 65, 130 and 260 sessions, zero drift by default. Check: the simulator's variance identities; unit-variance t draws; quantiles monotone (7 checks, all passing).
  4. Joint events. Source: step 3. Transform: the share of paths in which both legs hold. Check: no joint probability exceeds either marginal (1 check, all passing).
  5. Coverage, two records. Source: step 2 at every quarter-end since 2015, and each asset refitted on the data to that date. Transform: the band drawn at the time against the outcome that followed; Kupiec's and Christoffersen's tests. Check: coverage nested across the 50, 80 and 90% bands; every complete quarter counted; the refitted record re-scores the same windows and fits nothing after a quarter-end (12 checks, all passing).
  • Specification
    Model-conditional, zero drift, full-sample parameters for the cones.

    The cones are model-conditional distributions, not forecasts: they are what the fitted engine implies if its parameters and its reading of today's variance and correlation state are right, with zero drift. Engine: GARCH(1,1) with Student-t innovations per series on daily returns ×100 (arch), DCC(1,1) on the standardised residuals by quasi-maximum likelihood — the ten-core-markets fit (the spine in earlier issues) is the cached 17 Sep run of the regime page (a = 0.0180, b = 0.9660, 3,058 sessions from 18 Sep 2014), reused without re-estimation (its coverage record is therefore in-sample in its parameters — the page's out-of-sample record refits each quarter); the yields engine is the same code on daily changes of the 2- and 10-year par yields (bp) and log returns of SPY, USO, GLD and UUP on 3,213 common sessions from 3 Jan 2014 (a = 0.0213, b = 0.9647).

  • Simulation
    20,000 paths, 260 sessions, fixed seeds.

    From the last filtered state — h_(T+1) = ω + α ε_T² + β h_T per series and Q_(T+1) = (1 − a − b) Q̄ + a z_T z_T′ + b Q_T, both from the fitted parameters run through the data — 20,000 paths of 260 sessions: each session draws independent Student-t innovations with the fitted ν, scaled to unit variance, correlates them with the Cholesky factor of R_t = diag(Q_t)^−½ Q_t diag(Q_t)^−½, scales by √h_t, then updates h and Q with the same recursions. Quantiles 5/10/25/50/75/90/95 of the cumulative simple return (yields: cumulative change in bp) at 65, 130 and 260 sessions (13, 26 and 52 weeks) and every fifth session for the chart. Seeds are fixed, so a rerun on the same inputs reproduces every number.

  • Drift
    Zero by default; the fitted mean as an option.

    Zero drift is the default: the median path is flat and the cone is pure variance. The option adds the fitted constant mean μ of each GARCH to every session; because the variance recursion runs on the residual, the same paths serve both settings shifted by μ per session. The fitted means are sample averages over 2014–26 and carry no information about the coming quarter; they are shown so the size of the assumption is visible.

  • Joint events
    Shares of paths.

    Joint probabilities are the share of the paths in which both legs hold at the horizon; the marginals and their product (independence) sit beside each so the part the correlation adds is visible. Events are computed in every engine that carries both assets. They are the fitted engine's probabilities under its own assumptions, not a judgement of the site's.

  • Coverage
    Quarter-ends since 2015: refitted each quarter, and the engine's full-sample record beside it.

    Two coverage records, one set of windows. At every calendar quarter-end from 2015 Q1 to the last quarter whose 65-session outcome is complete (2026 Q2; 46 quarter-ends) a band is drawn from the state at the last session on or before the quarter-end (5,000 paths of 65 sessions, zero drift) and the realised outcome (adjusted-close ratio; par-yield difference) is scored inside or outside the 50% (25–75), 80% (10–90) and 90% (5–95) bands. The out-of-sample record — the page's claim — re-estimates each asset's GARCH(1,1)-t at every quarter-end on its daily data from 2 Mar 2007 to that date only (an expanding window; the S&P 500, the 10-year and WTI) and draws the band from that fit. The engine's own record draws it from the full-sample parameters with the state filtered to the date: the parameters have seen the shocks they are scored on, so it is an in-sample-parameter record and is printed as that, never as out-of-sample. The same outcomes are also scored against the engine's bands shifted by the fitted mean (the drift option), to show how much of a central-band shortfall is the zero-drift centre rather than the width. The latest quarter-end's outcome is still running and is shown as pending, not scored.

  • Tests
    Kupiec and Christoffersen.

    Kupiec's unconditional-coverage test compares the miss rate with the band's promise (10% outside a 90% band) by a likelihood ratio, χ² with one degree of freedom; Christoffersen's independence test asks whether a miss makes the next window's miss more likely (a first-order Markov chain against independence, χ²(1)), and the two add to the conditional-coverage test, χ²(2). With 46 windows the asymptotic p-values are coarse, and adjacent 65-session windows share a session or two, so they are close to but not exactly independent. A p-value at or above 0.05 is read as consistent with the nominal rate — not as proof that the width is right.

  • Sensitivity
    Drift, tails, correlation, engine.

    Sensitivity of the 13-week edges: zero drift (default) vs the fitted mean; Student-t vs normal innovations at the same variances (a unit-variance t(ν) puts more mass near the centre and only exceeds the normal beyond about 2.5σ, so the 5–95 edges are slightly wider with normals while the far tails are thinner); the fitted DCC vs constant correlation Q̄ (a = b = 0; affects the joint events more than the marginal cones). The two engines' cones for the assets they share are a further specification sensitivity.

  • Calendar
    Two session calendars.

    Core-market sessions are the days on which all ten core markets, bitcoin included, printed a close (the regime page's convention). Yields-engine sessions are the common days of the Treasury par curve and NYSE trading (Columbus Day and Veterans Day drop out, so the next change spans two days). A 65-session horizon is about 13 weeks on either calendar.

  • Licence
    No level shown.

    Prices are Yahoo Finance data, shown with their attribution; Treasury par yields are the Treasury's own. The engines, the simulation and the backtest are computed here.

  • Runtime
    Not printed.

    Runtime is not printed: timings differ from run to run, and the page must print the same numbers whenever it is recomputed from the same files. The simulation's size is its paths and horizons above.

Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.cones-1

Exhibit 21 · How a path is priced

About
  • What this is

    Model-conditional. Every number on this page is what one named model says under stated inputs, and none is a forecast. The index-level answer to a branch is the Valuation page's two-stage identity with the pinned ten-year and everything else held; the distributions are the factor engine's — GARCH(1,1)-t per raw factor with a scalar DCC, simulated forward with zero drift from today's filtered state, mapped to each asset through betas drawn from their sampling distribution, with the asset's residual resampled from its own history — whose median is an artefact of the zero drift rather than a central case.

  • The identity

    The valuation identity, per branch (D7). Price over trailing earnings = k [(1 + g_L) + H (g_S − g_L)] ÷ (r − g_L), the Valuation page's two-stage identity, at its priced inputs — k 0.84, E0 ÷ P 3.985%, g_S 15.1% (the consensus) fading to g_L 4.0% over 6 years, r = rf 5.12% (16 Nov 2026) + ERP 3.502pp (the premium the price implies) — which return today's close (a check). A branch moves rf by its ten-year pin and holds the rest, so its move from today is (r0 − g_L) ÷ (r1 − g_L) − 1 (a check on every branch), printed as a percentage of today's price and never as an index level. The model's value under the branch is the same identity at the expected inputs — g_S 5.77% (the Earnings page's fan bridged to EPS) and ERP 5.170pp (the yield-gap premium) — with the same rf, printed as a percentage of today's price, the one hold-path gap every page copies; at a pin of zero it is that page's gap (−41.5%, a check). Held, not estimated: the premium's response to the ten-year, to spreads or to volatility, and earnings' response to growth or oil — no such elasticity exists among the site's estimates, so oil, credit and the dollar are printed as not modelled rather than given a number, and the two Hormuz branches with a Brent range cannot be priced through the identity until one is estimated. Every input is copied from the Valuation page by its published key and re-compared on each update.

  • Market pricing

    Market pricing beside the set is copied from What is priced (16 Nov 2026) by its published keys: the ten-year, each path's fair value and remaining move, the forwards against IORB, the SEP medians, that page's completion reading and its own equity amount on the SEP path. It is the observed counterpart the scenario set is read against; nothing here is recomputed from it.

  • Conditioning

    A branch pins a subset of the raw factors at the horizon. Each draw's unpinned factors become Q* = Q − B (P − x_P) with B estimated on those draws. For jointly Gaussian draws this is exact conditioning; for these fat-tailed draws it is a shift that keeps each draw's own residual, so the unpinned factors keep their tails instead of collapsing onto a mean. With nothing pinned the draws are unchanged, bit for bit, and a check says so.

  • The scenario set

    Every pin is transcribed from a dated source and re-read on each update, and printed in the source's own unit. A branch whose definition names a direction is projected only while its source still moves that way. A branch is projected only on a recorded decision — the author's decision of 3 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-03-07); the Fed paths stand on the author's decision of 26 Sep 2026 (D-2026-09-26-PATHS). A branch with none is listed with its source and not projected — today that is the ten-year up by the term premium's last three months, hollow deal, attrition, escalation, genuine deal. The Hormuz branches' keys and names are the Hormuz log's own, read from it on every update. No branch carries a probability: the set is paths only, as decided on 26 Sep 2026 (the Hormuz page keeps its dated log), and no joint probability is computed anywhere.

  • The mapping

    R = cash + Σ β·F̃ + ε, with β drawn afresh on every path. The second regression's constant is not carried: it is an in-sample average of what the factors did not explain, and adding it would assert that the same average continues. An asset that *is* a factor proxy takes its own raw factor draw and no cash leg. An asset attribution excludes from a factor because it is a leg of it gets that factor back, raw, here — and its beta is applied to the raw draw, the variable it was estimated on.

  • Parameter draws

    Parameter uncertainty: each path draws its own betas as β + se·z, z standard normal, from the Newey–West standard errors the Return attribution page publishes for its second regression (the projection regression's own, by the same estimator, for an asset with a factor restored). Only standard errors are published, not the coefficients' covariance, so the draws are independent across factors, and a Dimson exposure's error is its two lags' errors in quadrature. A path keeps its draw at every horizon.

  • The residuals

    Each asset's own second-regression residual, resampled by the stationary block bootstrap (Politis–Romano): blocks of 21 sessions on average, of geometric length, drawn from the asset's whole residual history centred on zero, since the constant is not carried. Assets are resampled independently, which changes no number printed here — every band is one asset's. The alternative printed beside it simulates the residual with its own GARCH(1,1)-t, the 11 sector residuals drawn together with today's residual correlation from the Correlations & regime page and every other asset's independently.

  • Calibration

    A width scale about the median is estimated on the first 9 quarter-ends of the backtest, to 31 Mar 2024. It is the smallest scale that would have held 80% of outcomes there: k = 1.0721 for the 10–90 band. It is then tested, unchanged, on the 9 quarter-ends after. Under the author's decision of 24 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-24-PJ2), the 5–95 band is the widened 10–90 band plus a tail margin that cannot be negative. The margin is the distance the simulation puts between the 10th and 5th percentiles, and between the 90th and 95th, times a tail factor of 0.4590. That factor is the smallest that would have held 90% of the same outcomes in the 5–95 band. Because it cannot be negative, the 5th and 95th can never cross the 10th and 90th. The 5th and 95th percentiles changed method on 24 Oct 2026: before, each was scaled about the median by a factor of its own. The scale is needed only when the uncalibrated band's pooled 10–90 interval excludes 80%. It is applied only when the widened 10–90 band then passes its held-out test. A scale that fails its own test is printed as attempted and not drawn. When applied, every published 10th and 90th percentile is p50 + k·(q − p50). Every 5th and 95th is that value plus k_tail·(q05 − q10) or k_tail·(q95 − q90), and the median and quartiles are as simulated. Today: needed, and the widened 10–90 band passes its held-out test, so it is applied. The bands head Distributions. The alternative (GARCH-t residual) is shown before any calibration.

  • Licence

    Prices are Yahoo Finance data and Treasury yields are free to use; every other input is another page's published number, with that page's own sources behind it.

Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculationscross.projections-8

Exhibit 22 · Definitions

How the numbers are made, step by step

  1. Prices and factors. Source: Yahoo Finance ETF closes; Treasury par yields; the Board's H.10 dollar. Transform: weekly log returns; the four factors (oil, the 10-year per 10bp, credit, the dollar); the factors page's weekly data. Check: the weekly data is the factors page's, to its last week (3 checks, all passing).
  2. The regressions. Source: step 1. Transform: each asset on the four factors over 156 and 52 weeks, Newey–West covariance (4 lags). Check: betas and covariances equal statsmodels and the factors page's estimator (3 checks, all passing).
  3. The grid and its bands. Source: step 2 and the stated moves (oil rows, 10-year columns, horizons). Transform: point = Σ β f; variance = fᵀ Σ_β f + H σ²; band = point ± 1.2816 √variance, at every cell, asset, window and horizon the page offers. Check: a Monte Carlo of the betas and the residual reproduces the band; the pair is energy minus discretionary; the published grid reproduces the example cells and the report's daily construction (8 checks, all passing).
  4. The valuation route. Source: the Valuation page's two-stage identity and its inputs (copies). Transform: the identity at each stated 10-year, everything else held. Check: at the priced inputs the identity returns today's price; each column re-run through the shared identity (7 checks, all passing).
  5. The September issue, reproduced. Source: the September review's quoted constants and printed cells. Transform: the September review's daily betas, TLT mapping and base row recomputed from the prices. Check: the betas, the mapping and the base-row levels reproduced (4 checks, all passing).
  6. Copies from other pages. Source: the other pages' published data, through the site's manifest. Transform: each value read from the published version of its page. Check: each source published with its checks passing; every copy equal to its source (17 checks, all passing).
  • Model
    Four factors, weekly, no market.

    Route A: weekly log returns (%) of each asset regressed over 156 and 52 weeks on four factors — crude (USO), the change in the Treasury 10-year par yield per 10bp, high yield over investment grade (HYG − LQD) and the Board's broad dollar — without the market, so each beta is a total effect (it includes what reaches the asset through the index). Newey–West covariance (4 lags, Bartlett, no small-sample correction). Windows end on the last complete week, 13 Nov 2026; the same weekly data as the Factors page (a check).

  • Grid
    Point and band.

    A cell is a pair of factor moves over the horizon H: oil in per cent, the 10-year in basis points (÷10 to the beta's unit); credit and the dollar are held at zero (the grid's stated moves are oil and the 10-year). Point = Σ β_i f_i; variance = fᵀ Σ_β f + H σ² where Σ_β is the betas' covariance and σ the weekly residual standard deviation; the 10th–90th band is point ± 1.2816 √variance. The band assumes the factor moves are given (a scenario, not a forecast) and normal residuals; it is model-conditional. A cell 'exceeds its band' when |point| is larger than the half-band. Every cell the page prints — each asset and the pair, the 156- and 52-week windows and the report's daily one, each horizon, each oil row and 10-year column — is computed here with its band, its half-band, the beta and residual parts and the beta share of the variance; checks hold the published grid to the example cells and to the report's daily construction. A Monte Carlo checks the band's arithmetic: 200,000 draws of the betas from their covariance plus a normal residual over the horizon (seed 20260917) put the 10th and 90th percentiles of 3 example cells within 0.2pp of the band's edges.

  • Pair
    Energy − discretionary.

    The energy − discretionary pair is energy's cell minus discretionary's; its variance adds the two covariance matrices and the two residual variances as if the regressions' errors were independent. Their residuals are correlated (+0.06 over 156 weeks), so the printed band is wider than a direct regression of the pair would give.

  • Route B
    The valuation route.

    The valuation route (the Valuation tab) runs the 10-year column through the Valuation page's two-stage identity — price over trailing earnings = k [(1 + g_L) + H (g_S − g_L)] ÷ (r − g_L) — at that page's priced inputs (k 0.84, E0 ÷ P 3.985%, g_S 15.1% fading to g_L 4.0% over 6 years, r = 5.12% + 3.502pp), moving rf by the column and holding the rest, so a column's move from today is (r0 − g_L) ÷ (r1 − g_L) − 1, printed as a percentage of today's price, never as an index level; beside it, the model's value at the expected inputs (g_S 5.77%, ERP 5.170pp) and the column's 10-year, as a percentage of today's price — the one hold-path gap the board and the Valuation page print. Model-conditional: what the identity implies under stated inputs. It is one row across the 10-year columns, not a grid: the site estimates no elasticity of index earnings or of the premium to oil, credit or the dollar, so those are printed as not modelled rather than given a number (the earlier route's oil elasticity was a value the reader typed, with no preset the site could stand behind). The Scenarios page's branch table runs the same identity for every named scenario, and every input is copied from the Valuation page and re-compared on each update.

  • Report
    The September report's construction.

    The September review made its target matrix from daily betas of the S&P 500 on USO and TLT since the Strait closed (−0.10, +0.31), a 156-week mapping of TLT's weekly return to the 10-year change (−0.14% per bp, R² 0.91) and the grid's Brent mid-points against $104.61 and cell yields against 4.96%. Its script is not in the repo; the construction is reproduced from its printed description with log changes for the oil mid-points and 7,591.70 × exp(r) for the level, and the cell yields are backed out of the printed base-row levels. The issue prints 'above $120' without a mid-point; 125 is this page's assumption. At 120 the printed escalation level reproduces within 0.1% under every convention tried, so the September review's script most likely used the lower bound.

  • Overlay
    The Hormuz columns.

    The Hormuz log's three branches with a Brent range — hollow deal, attrition, escalation — are marked on the grid at their mid-point changes against $104.61 (the log's revision of 2026-09-14); the genuine deal has no Brent level and is not placed. The marks carry no odds: the set is paths only, and the log's own judgement odds stay in the Hormuz page's revision record. The September review's cell yields (4.70–5.35%) are not in the repo, so the yield range is shaded rather than the nine cells placed.

  • Levels
    Index levels.

    Index levels on the factor route are 7,591.70 × SPY_t ÷ SPY_11Sep × exp(r) — the September review's close scaled by the ETF's move and the scenario return, computed here beside every cell of the index (a check ties them to the scalar cell); on the valuation route the page prints percentages of today's close only — an index level under a path would read as a target. A check ties the forward P/E × forward EPS convention to the 11 September close. The grid prints percentages because a percentage is what the regressions estimate.

  • Licence
    Vendor prices; official yields and dollar.

    ETF prices are Yahoo Finance data, shown with their attribution; Treasury yields and the Board's dollar index are free to use. The regressions, the grid and the reproduction of the September review's construction are computed here.

Source: Yahoo Finance; U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve Board (H.10); Macro Review calculationscross.scenarios-2

Exhibit 23 · The fair 10-year of each policy path: 4.07% on a hold, against 5.12% today

A path's ten-year average funds rate plus a term premium, %. Arithmetic on today's curve and a stated policy path — not a forecast.
Term premium →
Policy path ↓
The fair 10-year of each stated policy path at four term premia
Today's ACM 10-year term premium, +0.73pp2015–19 ACM average, −0.29pp2023 ACM peak, +0.46ppToday +50bp, +1.23pp
Hold at IORB (average 3.34%)4.07%3.05%3.80%4.57%
One further +25bp, then hold (average 3.39%)4.12%3.10%3.85%4.62%
+50bp, then hold (average 3.44%)4.17%3.15%3.90%4.67%
Cuts of 25bp a quarter from 2027 Q1 to 3.00 (average 3.21%)3.94%2.93%3.67%4.44%
Cuts of 25bp a quarter from 2027 Q3 to 3.00 (average 3.26%)3.98%2.97%3.72%4.48%
About this exhibit
From the policy-rules page: five stated paths for the funds rate from Oct 2026 and four term premia — today's, the 2015–19 average, the 2023 peak and today's plus 50bp. Each cell is the path's average short rate over ten years plus the column's premium. It says where the 10-year would sit if the path and the premium were known, and nothing about which path comes.
Source: New York Fed; Federal Reserve Board; U.S. Treasury; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026cross.scenarios-8

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.