Macro ReviewHow to read
Thematic · The decision vs the source

The Fed hiked; 40% of core inflation is in prices a hike slows

The Fed raised rates in September, while most of today's core inflation comes from prices a higher barely reaches within two years.Does the policy rate reach the inflation it is being raised against?

Said 13 Sept 2026 · revised 15 Sept 2026Data to Sep 2026 (inflation) · rates to 16 Nov 2026 · updated 17 Nov 2026
share of core inflation40%Sep 2026 · 56% · from Sources & rate sensitivity · trigger 45% · not crossed
Core PCE less its 2019 average+1.48ppSep 2026 · core 3.12% vs 1.65%
3.90%from 17 Sep 2026 · +25bp since 15 Sep 2026hike observed
Shelter CPI, 3m 3.91%Oct 2026 · 12-month 3.38% · trigger 3.5% · crossed
Michigan 5–10-year expectations3.4%Sep 2026 (embargoed four weeks) · trigger 3.5 · not crossed
What the Committee choseHike, cycle dots+25bp · 2026 median dot 4.1% (16 Sep 2026)decided

The hike came; most of today's inflation is beyond its reach

Does the reach the inflation it is being raised against?
  • Hiking on 16 September was justified, but most of today's inflation is beyond a rate rise's reach: tested (said 13 Sep 2026).→ Exhibit
  • About a third of core inflation (40%) is in prices a rate rise can slow within two years, against 56% in 2015–19 (Sep 2026).→ Exhibit
  • Core PCE runs +1.48 points above its 2019 average; +0.28 of that is in prices.→ Exhibit
  • The Fed raised rates a quarter point, in effect 17 Sep 2026, with a 4.1% median dot for 2026: the cycle branch.→ Exhibit
  • Shelter CPI runs 3.90% over three months and 3.38% over twelve (Oct 2026).→ Exhibit
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
The rate-sensitive share climbs backabove 45% of twelve-month core PCE inflation39.9% (Sep 2026)not crossedPersonal Income and Outlays, 25 Nov 2026
Shelter re-acceleratesabove 3.5% at a three-month annualised rate3.90% (Oct 2026); on 11 Sep 3.22% (Sep 2026)crossedConsumer Price Index, 10 Dec 2026
Long-run expectations lose their anchorMichigan 5–10-year expectations at or above 3.5 in October3.4% (Sep 2026)not crossedMichigan's October survey, reported here a month later
The housing objection fallsnew-home below 8.0 by Q1 20278.4 months (Sep 2026)not crossedNew Residential Sales, 25 Nov 2026
The reasoning behind each point
  • Verdict
    Hiking on 16 September was justified, but most of today's inflation is beyond a rate rise's reach: tested (said 13 Sep 2026).

    As written on 13 Sep 2026: “The evidence supports acting on 16 September; it does not show that the instrument — the policy rate — reaches what it is being aimed at.” The verdict is “tested” because a trigger of the falsifier table has crossed; the scorecard sets what the log said against what has happened since.

  • Rate sensitivity
    About a third of core inflation (40%) is in prices a rate rise can slow within two years, against 56% in 2015–19 (Sep 2026).

    Of the rest, 13% is partly rate-sensitive and 47% is not: not rate-sensitive 38%, priced off asset values 6%, raised by a hike 3%. The 2015–19 average rate-sensitive share was 56%; the September report’s trigger is 45%, 5.1 points above today's reading. The thesis quotes July 2019 as the September report measured it; on today's data July 2019 was 57%. The August print and BEA's annual revision arrive together on 30 September.

  • Excess
    Core PCE runs +1.48 points above its 2019 average; +0.28 of that is in rate-sensitive prices.

    Largest additions against 2019: Other goods (tradable) +0.42pp; Computers, software and phones +0.37pp; Health care +0.24pp. Not slowed by a hike (not rate-sensitive, priced off asset values, raised by a hike) +0.78pp; partly rate-sensitive +0.42pp.

  • Decision
    The Fed raised rates a quarter point, in effect 17 Sep 2026, with a 4.1% median dot for 2026: the cycle branch.

    Futures priced the hike at 86% on 11–12 September; the log's base case was a one-off 'recalibration'. What the theme now turns on is whether the move is one step or a cycle — the 2026 median dot at 4.1 or above: the September SEP puts it at 4.1% (16 Sep 2026), the cycle branch; the page's ending prints what that path and the hold path would move.

  • Shelter
    Shelter CPI runs 3.90% annualised over three months and 3.38% over twelve (Oct 2026).

    The trigger for a re-acceleration is 3.5% annualised, −0.40 points above today. The September report’s point stands on the pipeline, not the print: a hike raises rents at six to twelve months through the tenure shift (Dias–Duarte), while new-home months' supply reads 8.4 months (Sep 2026).

Next: Housing supply 2027–28 — shelter's path to 2028

Source: BEA; BLS; Federal Reserve Board; University of Michigan; the September 2026 report · data to the dates shownthemes.decision_source-read

What the view expected against what has happened, test by test

The September decision, the BEA revision and the view's tests: what was written on 13 Sep 2026, what happened, and each named verdict
WhatSaidHappenedVerdict
PathsThe 16 September decision — the FOMC rows of the September report’s 3×3 gridSaid · 13 Sept 2026the log's base case: Hike, 'recalibration' dotsHappened · 17 Sept 2026+25bp, in effect 17 Sep 2026; the Committee's 2026 median dot 4.1% (16 Sep 2026)Verdictresolved: Hike, hawkish dots — a cycle — not the base case (Hike, 'recalibration' dots)
PathsThe 30 September BEA revision — the October input to the reaction matrixSaid · 13 Sept 20263 paths named, no odds: Below 0.1pp · 0.1–0.3pp · Above 0.3ppHappenednot yet decided — BEA annual update, 30 September 2026Verdictopen
TestThe rate-sensitive share climbs backSaid · 15 Sept 2026above 45% of twelve-month core PCE inflationHappened · Sep 202639.9% (Sep 2026)Verdictnot crossed
TestShelter re-acceleratesSaid · 13 Sept 2026above 3.5% at a three-month annualised rateHappened · Oct 20263.90% (Oct 2026); on 11 Sep 3.22% (Sep 2026)Verdictcrossed
TestLong-run expectations lose their anchorSaid · 13 Sept 2026Michigan 5–10-year expectations at or above 3.5 in OctoberHappened · Sep 20263.4% (Sep 2026)Verdictnot crossed
TestThe housing objection fallsSaid · 15 Sept 2026new-home months' supply below 8.0 by Q1 2027Happened · Sep 20268.4 months (Sep 2026)Verdictnot crossed

The view is tested: the word follows a rule set out in the Appendix, from the log and the tests above, never by hand.

About this exhibit
A scorecard showing, for the September decision, the BEA annual revision and the view's tests, what the dated log said, what has happened, and the verdict on each
What was said on 13 Sept 2026, and what has happened since
The 16 September decision, the BEA revision and the four tests of the view: what the dated log said, what happened, and the verdict
Source: the theme's dated log (said 13 Sept 2026); Federal Reserve Board; the pages cited per row · data to 16 Nov 2026themes.decision_source-18

How a hike reaches prices, and each bucket's share of core inflation

How a higher policy rate reaches prices, and the shares of twelve-month core PCE inflation, %, it does and does not reach, Sep 2026
Policy ratethe decision2-year yieldmoves on the dayCredit andasset pricesDemandRate-sensitiveprices40%12–24 monthsOff the chain: not slowed by a hike within two yearsPartly rate-sensitive13%some of the priceis set elsewhereNot rate-sensitive38%administered, supply-driven or imputedPriced off asset values6%fees follow markets,not spendingRaised by a hike3%imputed bank servicesrise with rates
The instrument works along one chain: the policy rate moves the 2-year yield, credit and asset prices, then demand, and demand slows the prices that respond to it — within about two years. The other buckets sit off the chain: part of each price is set by supply, administration, markets or the rate itself.
About this exhibit
A diagram of the chain from the policy rate through the 2-year yield, credit and asset prices and demand to rate-sensitive prices, with the other buckets drawn off the chain, each with its share of core inflation
A hike reaches a third of core inflation, not the rest
How a higher policy rate reaches prices, and the shares of twelve-month core PCE inflation it does and does not reach, Sep 2026
Source: BEA personal consumption expenditures; the rate-sensitivity classification; Macro Review calculations · data to Sep 2026themes.decision_source-19

The view, and the claim as written

The author's claim on 13 Sept 2026, kept as written; a figure revised since is marked where it stands

Hiking on 16 September was justified, but most of today's inflation is beyond a rate rise's reach — tested

As written on 13 Sept 2026

The evidence supports acting on 16 September; it does not show that the instrument — the policy rate — reaches what it is being aimed at.

On the September report’s classification of July 2026 core PCE inflation (3.34%), about 35% sat in components a funds rate reaches with a 12–24-month lag, 12% partly and 53% not at all — administered, supply-driven or imputed prices, asset-linked fees, and imputed bank services that a hike raises. In July 2019 the reachable share was 58%. Of the 1.70-point excess over July 2019, 13% was reachable.

Reframed on 15 September from 'hike or hold' to 'one move or a cycle': at 86% priced the market had bought the move; the open question is whether 16 September is one move or the first of several.

StatusactiveSaid13 Sept 2026Revised15 Sept 2026

Argued in the : 7 dated documents, listed with their sections under Sources in the Appendix.

Source: the September 2026 report and its research notes (7 documents, listed in the Appendix)themes.decision_source-1

Where core inflation comes from, and what the decision moved

What do the rate-sensitivity buckets, the decision, shelter and expectations say today?

Exhibit 1 · Share of core PCE inflation in each rate-sensitivity bucket, over time

Monthly, share of twelve-month core PCE inflation, %, to Sep 2026; dashed line is the 45% share that would change the view
About
About this exhibit
Monthly lines of the share of twelve-month core PCE inflation in each of the five rate-sensitivity buckets (rate-sensitive with a lag, partly, not rate-sensitive, priced off asset values, raised by a hike), with a dashed line at the share test
Where core PCE inflation sits, by the channel a hike acts through
share of twelve-month core PCE inflation, %, Sep 2016 to Sep 2026
Source: The site's own classification of BEA's PCE components; BEA Tables 2.4.4U/2.4.5U. From Sources & rate sensitivity (data to Sep 2026)themes.decision_source-2

Each bucket's share of core inflation against 2015–19, and its excess

Share of twelve-month core PCE inflation, %, in Sep 2026, its 2015–19 average, and the bucket's excess contribution over the 2019 average
BucketShare now2015–19Excess vs 2019
Rate-sensitive, with a lag39.9%56.5%+0.28pp
Partly rate-sensitive12.9%-9.6%+0.42pp
Not rate-sensitive37.9%35.3%+0.65pp
Priced off asset values6.4%5.9%+0.15pp
Raised by a hike (imputed bank services)2.8%11.9%−0.02pp

Core PCE 3.12% against a 2019 average of 1.65%. The report's test for the view failing is a rate-sensitive share above 45% that survives excluding freight costs.

About this exhibit
A table of the five rate-sensitivity buckets: each one's share of twelve-month core PCE inflation, its 2015–19 average share, and its contribution to the excess over 2019
Rate-sensitivity buckets, Sep 2026
Share of twelve-month core PCE inflation now, its 2015–19 average, and the bucket's excess contribution over 2019
Source: The site's own classification of BEA's PCE components; BEA Tables 2.4.4U/2.4.5U. From Sources & rate sensitivity (data to Sep 2026)themes.decision_source-3

Each source's contribution to core inflation above its 2019 average

Contribution to twelve-month core PCE inflation in Sep 2026 less its 2019 average contribution, by source, percentage points
About this exhibit
Horizontal bars of each spending category's contribution to twelve-month core PCE inflation less its 2019 average contribution, in percentage points
Excess over 2019 by source, Sep 2026
Contribution to twelve-month core PCE inflation now less its 2019 average, percentage points; the table adds each source's 2019 average
Source: Contributions calculated on this site on BEA components: excess = contribution now less its 2019 average. From Sources & rate sensitivity (data to Sep 2026)themes.decision_source-4

The Fed's target range and overnight market rates, daily

Daily, %, latest year; dashed grey: target range top and bottom; black: interest on reserves (IORB); orange: effective fed funds (EFFR); blue: SOFR
About this exhibit
Daily lines of the top and bottom of the Fed's target range, interest on reserve balances, the effective fed funds rate and SOFR
The decision: target range, IORB, EFFR and SOFR
%, 17 Nov 2025 to 16 Nov 2026
Source: Board of Governors (IORB); Federal Reserve Bank of New York reference rates (not affiliated with this site). From Policy rates (data to 16 Nov 2026)themes.decision_source-5

Latest policy and money-market rates and their change over each horizon

Latest value, %, and change in bp over each horizon up to a year; shaded against 2016–2019; percentile since 2016
SeriesLevel1d1w1m3m1yPct since 2016Level, recentAs of
Policy and money-market rates
Target range, top4.00%±0bp±0bp±0bp+25bp±0bp7313 Nov 2026
Target range, bottom3.75%±0bp±0bp±0bp+25bp±0bp7313 Nov 2026
Interest on reserve balances (IORB)3.90%±0bp±0bp±0bp+25bp±0bp7316 Nov 2026
Effective fed funds rate (EFFR)3.88%±0bp±0bp±0bp+25bp±0bp7313 Nov 2026
Secured overnight financing rate (SOFR)3.90%±0bp+1bp+1bp+25bp−15bp6513 Nov 2026
About this exhibit
A table of the target range top and bottom, IORB, EFFR and SOFR: latest level, change over a day, a week, a month, three months and a year, and percentile
Policy rates, latest and changes
Level and changes over business-day horizons, shaded against 2016–19; the target range and market rates follow the Board's IORB with NY Fed's next publications
Source: Board of Governors (IORB); Federal Reserve Bank of New York reference rates (not affiliated with this site). From Policy rates (data to 16 Nov 2026)themes.decision_source-6

Inflation in the CPI's shelter, rent and owners' equivalent rent

Monthly, %, to Oct 2026; twelve-month change except shelter's three-month annualised rate (blue); dashed line is the 3.5% test for the three-month rate
About this exhibit
Monthly lines of shelter CPI inflation over twelve months and over three months annualised, plus twelve-month rent and owners' equivalent rent inflation, with a dashed line at the three-month test
Shelter CPI — the largest rate-sensitive block
%, Oct 2021 to Oct 2026
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI. From Shelter and rents (data to Oct 2026)themes.decision_source-7

Inflation expectations of households and bond markets, over time

Monthly, %, to Oct 2026; Michigan survey medians, next year and long run; 5y5y forward and 10-year breakevens, monthly averages; dashed: the 3.5 test
About this exhibit
Monthly lines of Michigan households' median inflation expectations for the next year and the next 5–10 years, and the 5y5y forward and 10-year breakeven inflation rates, with a dashed line at the test
Expectations — the thing the hike insures against
%, Oct 2021 to Oct 2026
Source: University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers (published data, four-week embargo); Board of Governors H.15 (breakevens, monthly averages). From Expectations (data to Oct 2026)themes.decision_source-8

Months' supply of new homes for sale, over time

Monthly, months of sales at the current pace, Jan 2015 to Sep 2026; dashed line is the 8.0 test
About this exhibit
A monthly line of new-home months' supply since 2015, with a dashed line at the test
Months' supply of new homes at the decision
months, Jan 2015 to Sep 2026
Source: U.S. Census Bureau and HUD, New Residential Sales. From New-home supply (data to Sep 2026)themes.decision_source-10

Four tests of the view, none crossed so far

What would change the view?

Each test of the view with current data, against its threshold

Each test with a published reading: latest value, threshold, state and what crossing would mean; thresholds from the September report
About
StatusTestLatest readingThresholdIf crossedThreshold source
not crossedReachable share of twelve-month core PCE inflation rises above 45%39.9% (Sep 2026)Sources & rate sensitivity> 45.0%Demand, not composition, is driving the excess and the theme fails — provided the rise survives excluding freight-cost pressure on core goods and transport services (the classification is by channel, not by cause).the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §1.2 falsifier (refined 15 Sep); §4.4 register · 15 Sept 2026
crossedCPI shelter above 3.5% at a three-month annualised rate3.90% (Oct 2026); on 11 Sep 3.22% (Sep 2026)Shelter and rents> 3.50%Shelter is re-accelerating in the pipeline year; the reachable block is not disinflating and the buyer's-market read fails.the September 2026 report · §1.6c housing falsifier; §4.4 #13 · 13 Sept 2026
not crossedMichigan 5–10-year inflation expectations at or above 3.5 in OctoberOctober 2026 survey3.4% (Sep 2026)Expectations≥ 3.5%Expectations become the binding argument for the hike; the counter-argument is no longer 'not yet binding'.The page carries the Michigan survey with its four-week published-data embargo, so the October reading arrives here in November.the September 2026 report · §1.2 falsifier; §4.4 #4 · 13 Sept 2026
not crossedTwelve-month cross-section trimmed mean of PCE components below 2.8 by Decemberby December 20262.83% (Sep 2026)PCE< 2.80%Inflation is no longer broad at about 3¼% on the mandate index.The live series is the 24/31 trim calculated on this site in PCE, on twelve-month changes over 218 signed components; the September report’s figure (3.09% for July on 177 components) used an earlier script, so levels differ by construction.the September 2026 report · §4.4 #1 · 13 Sept 2026
not crossedThe Committee holds on 16 September (the hike call fails)+25bp since 15 Sep 2026 (3.65 → 3.90, 16 Nov 2026)Policy rates≤ 0 bpThe central call on the decision fails; the framing argument about reach stands either way.Read from the Board's IORB, which moves with the target range; NY Fed's range fields follow with its next publication. Dissent counts are not in any data series.the September 2026 report · §1.6a falsifier; §4.4 #11 · 13 Sept 2026
not crossedCore goods CPI accelerating for two consecutive months from October0.16% (Oct 2026); 0 consecutive risesCPI> 0.00%2 in a rowThe August producer pipeline (diesel, freight) has carried into consumer goods: Kashkari's seriality case is empirically met and a cycle is justified.Accelerating is read as a higher month-on-month change than the month before, on BLS's seasonally adjusted index.the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §4.5 falsifier · 15 Sept 2026
not crossedCore PCE below 2.8% by the December meeting, with Brent under $85by 8–9 December 20263.12% (Sep 2026)Sources & rate sensitivity< 2.80%The insurance was never needed. Only the core PCE leg is tracked here; Brent is subscription data and not displayed.the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §4.5 falsifier · 15 Sept 2026
not crossedMonths' supply of new homes falls below 8.0 by the first quarter of 2027by Q1 20278.4 months (Sep 2026)New-home supply< 8.0 monthsThe housing objection to a sequence is removed; 2022, not 1973, becomes the right analogue.the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §4.5 falsifier · 15 Sept 2026
About this exhibit
A table of the tests that have published data: status, latest reading, threshold, what crossing would mean, and where the threshold was set
The tests with a live reading
Thresholds from the September report; status from the latest data. 1 crossed · 0 closing · 7 not crossed · 4 pending · 1 not tracked here.
Source: the September 2026 report (thresholds); the pages named in each row (readings)themes.decision_source-11

Twelve-month trimmed-mean and median PCE inflation over time

Monthly, twelve-month change, %, to Sep 2026; dashed line is the 2.8 test level
About this exhibit
Monthly lines of the trimmed mean and the weighted median of twelve-month price changes across PCE components, with a dashed line at the test
Trigger input: twelve-month trimmed mean and median of PCE components
%, Sep 2016 to Sep 2026
Source: Trims calculated on this site on BEA Table 2.4.4U/2.4.5U components. From PCE (data to Sep 2026)themes.decision_source-12

Monthly change in core goods CPI prices over time

Monthly change in the seasonally adjusted core goods CPI, %, to Oct 2026
About this exhibit
A monthly line of the month-on-month change in the seasonally adjusted core goods CPI
Trigger input: core goods CPI, month on month
% month on month, Oct 2021 to Oct 2026
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI. From CPI (data to Oct 2026)themes.decision_source-13

The decision resolved; the October revision is next

What paths did the log name, and which happened?

The outcomes named for the September decision, and which happened

The outcomes the September report named, what each meant and which happened; market quotes and the author's dated odds sit in the folds
About
What happened · +25bp, in effect 17 Sep 2026; the Committee's 2026 median dot 4.1% (16 Sep 2026)
  1. Hike, 'recalibration' dots+25bp with projections that present the move as a one-off adjustment rather than the start of a cycle (2026 median dot unchanged at 3.8, the supply-shock sentence retained).
  2. Hike, hawkish dots — a cycle what happened+25bp with a 2026 median dot at or above 4.1%, signalling further moves.
  3. HoldTarget range unchanged at 3.50–3.75%; the complement of the futures-implied hike probability.
What the market and others said, as quoted
  • Fed funds futures priced 86% for +25bp (85–91% across six outlets, 11–12 Sep); Polymarket 80–82%; Kalshi 80.5 / 19.5 / 0.5. (the September 2026 report · §1.6a key points · 11 Sept 2026)
  • A 'cycle' hike (dots at 4.1%, sentence dropped) is the hawkish alternative 'at roughly one chance in three'. (the September 2026 report · §3.2 rate reaction matrix · 13 Sept 2026)
The record: the author's assessment on 13 Sep 2026, revised 14 Sep 2026

A dated judgement, kept as written and never revised here; it is not a market price or a model's output.

  • 14 Sept 2026
    Hike, 'recalibration' dots 55%Hike, hawkish dots — a cycle 31%Hold 14%

    Carried unchanged when the grid was re-derived on the oil-path weights revised after the Salalah postponement.

    the report's exhibit tables (as published) · comment: 'FOMC rows unchanged at 55/31/14' · 14 Sept 2026

  • 13 Sept 2026
    Hike, 'recalibration' dots 55%Hike, hawkish dots — a cycle 31%Hold 14%

    Hold set from futures pricing (86% for a hike); the 86 points split 55 / 31 on the dots, the cycle branch being the September report’s 'roughly one chance in three'.

    the September 2026 report · §4.2 the 3×3 grid; §3.2 · 13 Sept 2026

About this exhibit
Cards for the outcomes the September report named for the September meeting (a one-off 'recalibration' hike, a hike signalling a cycle, a hold), with the one that happened marked, and market quotes and the author's dated odds in folds
The 16 September decision — the FOMC rows of the September report’s 3×3 grid
The decision and projections of 16 September 2026
Source: the September 2026 report · §4.2 the 3×3 grid; §3.2 · 13 Sept 2026themes.decision_source-scenario-fomc_16sep

Possible sizes of BEA's September revision to core PCE

Cut to twelve-month core PCE inflation, percentage points, from the BEA annual update, 30 September 2026; the report gives no odds
About
  1. Below 0.1ppWaller's 'a few tenths' fails; the September report’s falsifier 3 fires.
  2. 0.1–0.3ppIn the range of the external estimates (JPMorgan −0.1pp, Goldman −0.2pp on core).
  3. Above 0.3ppMore than the external estimates.

The September report names the three sizes of revision as the row added to its rate reaction matrix but gives no probability for any of them; none is shown.

About this exhibit
Cards for the possible sizes of the cut BEA's annual update makes to twelve-month core PCE inflation and what each would mean, with no odds
The 30 September BEA revision — the October input to the reaction matrix
BEA annual update, 30 September 2026
Source: the September 2026 report · §3.2 rate reaction matrix · 13 Sept 2026themes.decision_source-scenario-bea_revision

What would each path move?

: the 16 September branches as the policy paths the Scenarios set prices, and what each would move

Each hike path's 10-year yield, mortgage rate and S&P 500

Model-conditional: each path's 10-year, against 5.12% on 16 Nov 2026; mortgage-rate change at a year, with band; S&P 500, premium and growth held
Hike, 'recalibration' dotsthe Hold path on the Scenarios set · one move framed as a one-off: after it, the hold path
The 10-year this path justifies4.07%−106bp from 5.12% on 16 Nov 2026
Mortgage rate a year on−101bp90% band −120 to −83bp

S&P 500 +29.6% (9,610) if the premium and growth were unchanged — the fair-value model's arithmetic on that 10-year, not a forecast.

Hike, hawkish dots — a cyclethe SEP path on the Scenarios set · the path the 16 September dots set: a 2026 median of 4.1% (16 Sep 2026)
The 10-year this path justifies4.12%−101bp from 5.12% on 16 Nov 2026
Mortgage rate a year on−97bp90% band −114 to −79bp

S&P 500 +27.8% (9,477) if the premium and growth were unchanged — the fair-value model's arithmetic on that 10-year, not a forecast.

Hold: the decision was not a hold.

The same policy paths as on The hike's transmission and Housing supply 2027–28, under this page's names for them.

The channel these paths run through · The policy rate → the 2-year and the 1y1y forward: +100bp on the federal funds effective rate (monthly average) → 2-year +58bp, 1y1y +48bp in the month, the same month; the 2-year carries 58% of the funds rate's own path at 12 months; 90% band 43 to 73bp. Record: 1990–2008 2-year 61bp, 1y1y 56bp; 2009–2026 2-year 45bp, 1y1y 18bp. The transmission table carries it with its sample and its model.

What each path would do to core PCE, unemployment and real GDP is read on Thematic impact, under Outlook.

About this exhibit
Cards, one per hike path (one-off and cycle), each giving the 10-year yield the path justifies against the anchor, the mortgage-rate change a year on with its band, and the S&P 500 with the premium and growth held
What would each path move?
Model-conditional: the ten-year column is the fair value the rules grid gives each policy path at today's term premium (What is priced); the S&P 500 column is the valuation identity's answer to that ten-year with the premium and near-term growth held (Scenarios); the mortgage column is the ten-year's move through the transmission table's pass-through at a year, with its band (Transmission). They are sensitivities with their models named, not positions or targets.
Source: the Scenarios and Transmission pages; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026 and Oct 2026themes.decision_source-14

Timeline and the report's exhibits

Dated events, and the report's exhibits mapped to live pages

The tests waiting on a date, an event or subscription data

Thresholds from the September report; status from the latest data. 1 crossed · 0 closing · 7 not crossed · 4 pending · 1 not tracked here.
About
StatusTestLatest readingThresholdIf crossedThreshold source
pending2026 median dot at or above 4.1 with two or more participants dissenting for morethe September SEP is not carried by any published page–The Committee has chosen the cycle and the September report’s base case (a recalibration) is wrong.the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §4.5 falsifier · 15 Sept 2026
not tracked hereThe statement drops the supply-shock sentence, or the press conference uses 'look through' affirmativelyevent — read from the record, not a data series–The Chair's test is not breadth; the 'recalibration' base case fails.the September 2026 report · §3.2 falsifier; §4.4 #18 · 13 Sept 2026
pendingThe 30 September BEA annual update lowers twelve-month core PCE by less than 0.1ppdated 30 Sep 2026 — read from the release when published–Waller's 'a few tenths' fails; the measurement leg of the composition argument weakens.the September 2026 report · §1.2 falsifier; §4.4 #3 · 13 Sept 2026
pendingCore PCE excluding financial services and health care accelerates past 3%no page of this site carries this aggregate (issue: 2.87–2.90% in July, up 36bp over four quarters)–The excess is not composition; the rest of the basket is inflating above 3%.the September 2026 report · §1.2 Analysis 5; §4.4 #2 · 13 Sept 2026
pendingAtlanta Fed sticky-price CPI rises for two consecutive monthsthe Atlanta Fed series is not carried by any published page–Persistence is not fading; the one-off reading of the energy shock weakens.the September 2026 report · §1.2 falsifier; §4.4 #5 · 13 Sept 2026
Source: the September 2026 report (thresholds); the pages named in each row (readings)themes.decision_source-20

The dated events behind the view

Events with their source; scheduled dates are marked, and events read from a data series say so
  • 17 Jun 2026
    June SEP: median funds rate 3.8% for end-2026 and 3.6% for end-2027; core PCE 3.3 / 2.5 / 2.1 for 2026–28; Chair Warsh submits no dots.

    research note: Hike or hold markets (13 Sep 2026) · §3.1 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 29 Jul 2026
    FOMC holds at 3.50–3.75% by 9–3; Hammack, Kashkari and Logan prefer +25bp.

    research note: Hike or hold case (13 Sep 2026) · §1.1 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 31 Jul 2026
    Kashkari's dissent statement: policy has a role against 'a series of successive supply shocks that might lead to entrenched higher inflation'.

    research note: Hike or hold case (13 Sep 2026) · §1.2 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 28 Aug 2026
    Warsh at Jackson Hole: 54% of the PCE basket above 3% over twelve months, 49% over six; 'Otherwise, we have work to do.'

    research note: Hike or hold case (13 Sep 2026) · §1.7 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 3 Sept 2026
    Waller: in July 'nonmarket services prices accounted for approximately half of the increase in core prices'; the BEA method change 'could lower 12-month PCE inflation by a few tenths'.

    the September 2026 report · §1.2 key points · 13 Sept 2026

  • 10 Sept 2026
    August PPI: final demand +5.4% y/y, intermediate goods +11.5%, truck freight +2.0% in the month — diesel more than a third of the monthly rise in final-demand goods.

    the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §4.5 · 15 Sept 2026

  • 11 Sept 2026
    August CPI: all items +3.4% y/y, core +2.4% y/y and +0.3% m/m against +0.2% expected; futures move to about 86% for a September hike.

    the September 2026 report · §1.6a key points; Executive summary · 13 Sept 2026

  • 12 Sept 2026
    Goldman Sachs changes its call to a 25bp hike on 16 September.

    research note: Hike or hold markets (13 Sep 2026) · §0.2, §3.2 (T3) · 13 Sept 2026

  • 13 Sept 2026
    Issue published: 35% of core PCE inflation reachable with a lag, 12% partly, 53% not at all.

    the September 2026 report · §1.2 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 15 Sept 2026
    Issue §4.5 reframed as 'one move or a cycle': the dissenters ask for a sequence, the market has priced a step.

    the report's status note · round 9 · 15 Sept 2026

  • 17 Sept 2026
    The Board's interest on reserve balances moves to 3.90% (+25bp) from 17 Sep 2026. data

    Policy rates · series iorb (Board PRATES) · 17 Nov 2026

  • 30 Sept 2026
    BEA annual update: portfolio-management fees re-deflated with a CES-based quantity extrapolator, revising 2021Q1–2026Q1; August PCE.

    research note: Inflation sources outlook (13 Sep 2026) · §1 · 13 Sept 2026

  • 28 Oct 2026
    FOMC (27–28 Oct): the second hike, if the SEP signalled a cycle.

    the September 2026 report · §4.3 what to watch · 13 Sept 2026

  • 4 Nov 2026
    Quarterly refunding announcement: the term-premium event.

    the September 2026 report · §4.3 what to watch · 13 Sept 2026

  • 9 Dec 2026
    FOMC with SEP (8–9 Dec): the market's modal year-end range is 4.00–4.25%. scheduled

    the September 2026 report · §4.3 what to watch · 13 Sept 2026

Source: the September 2026 report and the pages cited per rowthemes.decision_source-15

The September report's exhibits and the live page for each

Each named exhibit as the September report printed it, fixed at its 11 Sep 2026 data date, with the page that now carries it live
No.StemExhibitLive page
18E2o_reach_by_dateContribution to core PCE inflation by the channel through which a hike reaches it, July 2019, 2022 and 2026Sources & rate sensitivity
15E2l_core_excess_vs_2019Change in contribution to core PCE inflation by category, July 2026 vs July 2019Sources & rate sensitivity
16E2l2_core_excess_2022_vs_2019Change in contribution to core PCE inflation by category, July 2022 vs July 2019Sources & rate sensitivity
20E2m_core_drilldownThe sixteen largest contributors to core PCE inflation, July 2026, with driver and channelSources & rate sensitivity
21E2n_momentum_mapTwelve-month against three-month annualised inflation by PCE category, July 2026Sources & rate sensitivity
22E2r_source_outlookSource by source: driver, dated outlook and channelSources & rate sensitivity
14E2p_market_vs_nonmarketCore PCE and market-based core PCE, twelve-month, 2005–2026PCE
136E-W1_source_instrument_matrixSource → instrument: what a 25bp move reaches, by source of the current inflationSources & rate sensitivity
137E-W2_committee_mapThe Committee map: look-through vs act-anyway, with the July vote and June dotsquoted figures — no live page
63E11_expectations_tableWhat is priced, called and bet for 16 SeptemberPolicy rates
27E2g_expectations_splitUMich one-year expectations vs the 5y5y forward and five-year breakeven, 2019–2026Expectations
49E14c_rents_vs_cpi_shelterPrivate rent indices vs CPI shelter, latest twelve-month changeShelter and rents
150E24a_hike_case_both_sidesThe case for and the case against, in the participants' own wordsquoted figures — no live page
151E24f_reversal_lagHow long each tightening into a supply shock survived before it was reversed, single moves against sequencesquoted figures — no live page
152E24b_supply_shock_analoguesEight episodes of policy meeting a supply shock, and what followedquoted figures — no live page
153E24c_months_supply_at_decisionMonths' supply of new homes at the moment of each decisionNew-home supply
149E23_fomc_oil_gridThe 3×3 grid: FOMC decision × oil path, with cell probabilities and the bookGulf chokepoints
About this exhibit
A table of the September report's exhibits: number, title and the live page that now carries each
The September report's exhibits, and where each lives now
Exhibit numbers as the report printed them on 15 September; each stays fixed at the 11 September data date and points to the page that carries it live
Source: the September 2026 report, exhibit listthemes.decision_source-16

Reconciliation to the issue

Do the 's printed figures still come back from the data?1 of 3 unchanged

The report's July figures against the same month in revised data

Rate-sensitive share of core PCE inflation and core PCE inflation, %, Jul 2026, as printed on 13 Sep 2026 and as revised since
FigurePeriodReportNowChangeStatusPage
Rate-sensitive share of core PCE inflation (the report's method)Jul 202635%39%+4revisedSources & rate sensitivity
Core PCE inflation, twelve monthsJul 20263.34%3.00%−0.35revisedSources & rate sensitivity
CPI shelter, three months annualisedAug 20262.10%2.10%±0.00unchangedShelter and rents
About this exhibit
A two-row table setting the September report's July rate-sensitive share and core PCE inflation against the same month in today's data, with the change and status
The report's figures against the same period now
Each figure is the report's, read at its own period in the source page's current data (1 unchanged, 2 revised). A revision is the publisher's and is shown here rather than held against the page (the author's decision of 5 Oct 2026).
Source: the September 2026 report (13 Sep); the pages each row names, as they stand todaythemes.decision_source-21

Method

References, the status rule, odds and the terms62 checks, all pass
About this page

The September report argued that the evidence supported acting on 16 September while the policy rate does not reach most of the inflation it is aimed at. This page keeps that claim live: it reads the rate-sensitivity classification (whether a higher funds rate can slow a price within about two years), the decision, shelter and expectations from the US Macro pages and scores the report's own tests against them.

Definitions

  • Theme
    What the page reads.

    The theme asks whether a funds-rate increase reaches the sources of today's inflation. The rate-sensitivity classification is the Sources & rate sensitivity page's (by channel, not by cause); this page reads its shares and excesses, the policy rates from the Policy rates page, shelter from the CPI's shelter series and expectations from the Expectations page, and adds nothing computed.

  • References
    Copied, never recomputed.

    Every live number on this page is a copy of a published US Macro page, taken with that page's date, its as-of date and the value's place in it. Nothing is recomputed. On every update each copied value is compared with the source page, matched by date label rather than position; a mismatch, or a source page whose own checks fail, stops publication.

  • Status
    How triggers are scored.

    crossed — the threshold condition holds on the latest observation (for a run, on each of the last n); closing — not crossed, the series has printed since the September report's data date (11 September 2026), and the gap to the threshold is half or less of the gap on that date; not crossed — otherwise; pending — the observable is dated in the future or no page of this site carries it yet; not tracked here — an event, or subscription data this site does not display. Colours flag attention, not good or bad news for the book.

  • Odds
    Logged, not revised.

    Odds come only from the September report's documents and are kept in a dated file, one row per revision with the reason and the source document; this site never revises them. Each path states its basis: market-implied (a quoted market price), model (a documented model of this site's own) or the author's judgement (a dated assessment anchored to the quoted evidence). Only market-implied and model odds are drawn as odds; the author's judgement is shown in the folded record of each set, labelled with the date it was made.

  • Verdict
    How the verdict word is set.

    The verdict word is set by rule on every update: resolved — the log records the thesis as resolved; tested — a trigger of the falsifier table has crossed and the log has not yet closed the theme; under pressure — the log marks the theme closing, or a falsifier trigger is closing; holding — otherwise. The words of the verdict restate a passage of the logged claim, which this update checks is in the log.

  • Terms
    The words of the view.

    · · · .

  • Documents
    Where the view was argued.
    • the September 2026 report · §1.2 Analysis 4 — the excess over 2019 and what a policy rate can act on · 13 Sept 2026
    • the September 2026 report · §3.2 Warsh and the reaction function; Exhibit E-W1 source → instrument · 13 Sept 2026
    • research note: Hike or hold case (13 Sep 2026) · §0.3–0.6 and §3 — what the policy rate does to each source · 13 Sept 2026
    • research note: Hike or hold markets (13 Sep 2026) · §0.3–0.4 — the priced surprise and the dots · 13 Sept 2026
    • research note: Inflation sources outlook (13 Sep 2026) · Sources 1–8 — dated outlook by source · 13 Sept 2026
    • research note: Discussions and decisions (13 Sep 2026) · §6 findings 1, 10, 11 · 14 Sept 2026
    • the September 2026 report (as published on 15 Sep) · §4.5 One move or a cycle · 15 Sept 2026
  • Housing
    Months' supply is pending.

    Months' supply of new homes at the decision is the September report’s discriminating variable (9.6 in July 2026 — level with November 1973, above June 2022's 9.4). It is copied from the New-home supply page.

  • Licences
    What is not displayed.

    All live series are published or calculated on this site on published data. Brent, futures pricing and prediction markets are not displayed: they are subscription data. The September SEP's medians are copied from What is priced.

Source: Macro Reviewthemes.decision_source-17

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.