Macro ReviewHow to read
Outlook · Thematic impact · Producers and refills to 2029

Brent tracks the curve only if Gulf producers keep output 3.0 /d below targets

What do Gulf producers, strategic refills and shipping costs do to Brent through 2029?

Brent futures to 13 Nov 2026864 settings, one path eachUpdated 18 Nov 2026
Brent, 2028 average$76futures $75.84, between quoted contracts of 13 Nov 2026
Brent, 2027 average$84futures $83.75 · Brent price simulation median $73.27
Produce at targets, 2028 average$58$17.58 below the default setting's 2028 average
Gulf core output, 202814.6 mb/d3.0 mb/d below the 17.6 mb/d OPEC+ targets
Refills outside the US413 mbto December 2029; the Gulf core supplies 66% of them
Total stock gap closesJul 2029commercial stocks back to their long-run level by May 2028
US reserve returns
Gulf core producers
De-escalation
Demand response
Restocking outside the US
The default setting. 2027 $83.96 · 2028 $75.66 · 2029 $71.74 · Gulf core 2028 14.60 mb/d. The key data and the takeaways read the default; the exhibits follow the selection.

In brief

What the default says: US returns over two years, base restocking elsewhere, producers trimming as stocks rise, the curve's de-escalation and demand fitted to 2026
  • Brent tracks the futures when the Gulf core trims output 3.0 mb/d below its targets in 2028.→ Exhibit 2
  • If the Gulf core produces at its targets, 2028 Brent averages $58, against $76 on the curve.→ Exhibit 2
  • Restocking 413 mb of strategic stocks outside the US adds $0.77 to 2028 while producers trim output.→ Exhibit 5
  • Commercial stocks regain their long-run level by May 2028; strategic stocks stay short until Jul 2029.→ Exhibit 6
  • Shipping adds $9.65 a Gulf barrel in November 2026; 50% reaches Brent, the rest comes off Gulf netbacks.→ Exhibit 14
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
The Gulf core returns to its targetsSaudi, Iraqi and Kuwaiti output above 17.0 /d for three months in 20279.2 mb/d restricted in the model's November 2026; targets 17.6 mb/d (OPEC, 4 Oct 2026)pendingOPEC secondary sources, monthly, from February 2027
China restocks while Brent sits above its 12-month averageChinese onshore crude stocks up more than 30 mb in a month with Brent above that average1.192 bn bbl on 19 Oct 2026; October's Brent $108.34 against a 12-month average of $86.12pendingEnergy Aspects and Kpler estimates, monthly
Global stocks stay short into mid-2027Global observed stocks still more than 300 mb below end-February 2026 in mid-2027509 mb below at end-September 2026 (IEA, October report)pendingIEA Oil Market Report, July 2027
The reasoning behind each point
  • producers
    Brent tracks the futures when the Gulf core trims output 3.0 mb/d below its targets in 2028.

    Refitted to the futures, trimming as stocks rise misses them by at most 2.0% on average in any restocking setting. Producing at targets or ramping to capacity misses them by at least 9.1%.

  • hold
    If the Gulf core produces at its targets, 2028 Brent averages $58, against $76 on the curve.

    Everything else stays at the default setting and keeps its fit. Prices then sit below the long-run level of $69.93, the December 2030 contract.

  • refills
    Restocking 413 mb of strategic stocks outside the US adds $0.77 to 2028 while producers trim output.

    The Gulf core supplies 66% of those barrels by raising output, so the price moves little. China buys faster when Brent sits below its 12-month average, which October's did not.

  • stocks
    Commercial stocks regain their long-run level by May 2028; strategic stocks stay short until Jul 2029.

    Once commercial stocks are back, the curve's level is read as premium: about $9 of the 2027 average. If that premium fades faster, the curve needs tighter stocks.

  • shipping
    Shipping adds $9.65 a Gulf barrel in November 2026; 50% reaches Brent, the rest comes off Gulf netbacks.

    War-risk insurance and excess freight both fall with tension. If 30% of the excess stays, Brent barely moves and Gulf producers bear the cost.

Next: Range and scenarios — the oil axis these paths would mark

Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-read

Brent tracks the curve only if Gulf producers keep output below targets

Who sets Brent once the Strait reopens?

Exhibit 1 · Monthly Brent by setting against futures and the Brent price simulation

$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: chosen and compared settings, futures of 13 Nov 2026, the simulation's median and the EIA's path
About this exhibit
Monthly Brent, $ a barrel, over the horizon for the chosen setting and a second setting kept for comparison, beside the futures closes read two months ahead, the long-run level, the Brent price simulation's median and the EIA's path
Monthly Brent by setting against futures and the Brent price simulation
$ a barrel: the front month's monthly average to Oct 2026, then Nov 2026 to Dec 2029 for the chosen settings.
US reserve returns: Over two years · Gulf core producers: Trim as stocks rise · De-escalation: As the curve implies · Demand response: 2026 replay, −0.050 · Restocking outside the US: Base. The dots are the futures closes of 13 Nov 2026, each placed two months before its delivery month — the month it trades as the front month — and the dotted line joins them; past the last quoted contract the curve is held at it. The dashed line is the long-run level the model returns to: the close of the December 2030 contract, the furthest contract read. It delivers after Dec 2029, so it has no dot. The Brent price simulation's median and the EIA's November path are copied from that page as published on 17 Nov 2026, matched by month, Dec 2026 to December 2027. One path per setting, no odds: model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-1

Exhibit 2 · Average Brent by Gulf producer rule and restocking setting

$ a barrel, calendar 2028, other settings as chosen; the line is the futures' 2028 average between quoted contracts
Gulf coreNoneSlowBaseFast
Trim as stocks rise$74.89$75.34$75.66$75.45
Produce at targets$54.51$55.79$58.08$59.45
Ramp to capacity$54.43$55.60$57.67$59.13
About this exhibit
Bars of average Brent in 2028, $ a barrel, for each Gulf core producer rule (trim as stocks rise, produce at targets, ramp to capacity) and each restocking setting outside the US, with the futures' 2028 average as a line
Average Brent by Gulf producer rule and restocking setting
$ a barrel, 2028; other settings as chosen.
Each bar is one setting's 2028 average; the solid bar with an outline is the chosen one. The other settings — US returns, de-escalation and demand response — are as chosen, and every bar keeps the fit of its demand response. The dashed line is the futures' 2028 average along the curve between quoted contracts. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-2

Exhibit 3 · Gulf core and UAE crude output by producer rule, against targets

Million barrels a day, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Kuwait under each rule, the UAE, and their combined targets
About this exhibit
Monthly crude output of Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Kuwait together under each producer rule, the UAE's output outside the quotas and the three countries' OPEC+ targets, million barrels a day
Gulf core and UAE crude output by producer rule, against targets
Million barrels a day, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
The Gulf core is Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Kuwait; their OPEC+ required production for November 2026 sums to 17.6 mb/d. Trimming as stocks rise cuts output when commercial stocks sit above their long-run level two months earlier, by at most 0.5 mb/d a month; producing at targets delivers the targets once the Strait allows; ramping to capacity adds 0.4 mb/d a month. The UAE ramps toward 5.0 mb/d outside the quotas. The bold line is the chosen rule. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-3

Refills elsewhere change who sells the barrels more than their price

How much do strategic refills lift Brent?

Exhibit 4 · Strategic refills and releases by holder, monthly

Million barrels a day, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: refills by the US, other IEA members and China above zero; releases still due below
About this exhibit
Stacked monthly strategic refills by holder (the US reserve, other IEA members, China) as demand above zero and releases still due under the March collective action as supply below it, million barrels a day, for the chosen setting
Strategic refills and releases by holder, monthly
Million barrels a day, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
US reserve returns: Over two years · Gulf core producers: Trim as stocks rise · De-escalation: As the curve implies · Demand response: 2026 replay, −0.050 · Restocking outside the US: Base. Refills are demand and stack above zero; the releases still due — the US reserve's exchanges, as the reserve drawdown simulation has them, and other IEA members' share of the March 2026 collective action — are supply and sit below it. China's pace rises when Brent sits below its twelve-month average and stops when it sits more than $20 above it. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-6

Exhibit 5 · Brent less the futures curve by restocking setting, monthly

$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: the chosen settings under each restocking setting, less the curve between quoted contracts
About this exhibit
Monthly Brent less the futures curve, $ a barrel, under each of the four restocking settings outside the US, the other settings as chosen, the chosen restocking setting in black
Brent less the futures curve by restocking setting, monthly
$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
US reserve returns: Over two years · Gulf core producers: Trim as stocks rise · De-escalation: As the curve implies · Demand response: 2026 replay, −0.050 · Restocking outside the US: Base, under each restocking setting outside the US; the black line is the chosen one. The curve is the futures between quoted contracts, held at the last one. Every line keeps the fit of the demand response chosen. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-7

Commercial stocks recover long before strategic stocks do

Where does the stock gap sit, and what is left in the price?

Exhibit 6 · Commercial and strategic stock gap by holder, monthly

Million barrels, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: barrels still owed to strategic stocks by holder, commercial stocks against their long-run level, and the total
About this exhibit
Barrels still owed to strategic stocks by holder (the US reserve, other IEA members, China) below zero, commercial stocks against their long-run level, and the two together, million barrels, monthly, for the chosen and the compared setting
Commercial and strategic stock gap by holder, monthly
Million barrels, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
US reserve returns: Over two years · Gulf core producers: Trim as stocks rise · De-escalation: As the curve implies · Demand response: 2026 replay, −0.050 · Restocking outside the US: Base. Below zero, the barrels still owed to strategic stocks by holder: the US reserve's loans, the other IEA members' releases and China's draw since its 4 May record. The dashed line is commercial stocks against their long-run level, where the price clears; the black line adds the two. Commercial stocks start at −198 mb at end-October: the IEA's draw and October's, less the barrels released from strategic and obligated stocks, plus the pre-war overhang at February 2026's Brent. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-11

Exhibit 7 · Brent split into stock-driven price, premium and shipping cost

$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029, the chosen settings; the dashed line is the Gulf producers' netback after shipping
About this exhibit
Stacked monthly Brent for the chosen setting: the price commercial stocks imply, the geopolitical premium and the shipping cost passed into Brent, with the Gulf producers' netback after the full shipping cost as a line, $ a barrel
Brent split into stock-driven price, premium and shipping cost
$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
US reserve returns: Over two years · Gulf core producers: Trim as stocks rise · De-escalation: As the curve implies · Demand response: 2026 replay, −0.050 · Restocking outside the US: Base. The solid line is the price commercial stocks imply; the premium and the shipping cost in Brent are stacked on it, so the top of the stack is Brent. The price stocks imply is the long-run level, $69.93, raised when stocks are short; the premium is the fitted premium at full tension times tension; the shipping cost in Brent is the share of the excess insurance and freight that reaches it. The netback is what a Gulf producer keeps after the full excess shipping cost. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-12

The Gulf core's rule moves Brent most

Which drivers move average Brent most, one at a time?

Exhibit 8 · Change in average Brent from the default, one driver at a time

$ a barrel, calendar 2028: each driver at its low and high setting, everything else at the default and nothing refitted
About this exhibit
Bars of the change in average Brent in 2028 from the default setting, $ a barrel, when one driver moves to its low or its high setting and nothing is refitted, widest swing first
Change in average Brent from the default, one driver at a time
$ a barrel, 2028; the default averages $75.66.
Each pair of bars moves one driver to its low and its high setting from the default and refits nothing; a driver with one alternative has one bar. Widest first. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-14

The fit to the curve and the tables behind each section

How the curve is fitted, what each US schedule and China's rule do, what shipping costs, and how the site's oil models compare

Exhibit 9 · Fit to the futures curve by producer rule and restocking setting

% miss against the quoted contracts of 13 Nov 2026, overall and in 2027, 2028 and 2029; each pair refitted
Gulf coreRestockingPremium, $Half-life, monthsResponse to stocksAverage miss, %Largest, %2027, %2028, %2029, %
Trim as stocks riseNone14.413.50.0300.941.80.10.0−0.7
Trim as stocks riseSlow14.312.80.0140.961.80.10.0−0.8
Trim as stocks riseBase14.311.60.0010.921.80.2−0.3−1.3
Trim as stocks riseFast13.19.20.0002.013.10.7−2.6−2.4
Produce at targetsNone14.430 (bound)–11.0629.46.3−4.2−25.1
Produce at targetsSlow2.930 (bound)–9.1226.41.0−0.1−16.8
Produce at targetsBase15.827.8–11.8229.38.6−0.9−24.5
Produce at targetsFast19.819.6–15.4732.112.3−9.9−26.9
Ramp to capacityNone14.430 (bound)–11.0629.46.3−4.2−25.1
Ramp to capacitySlow15.530 (bound)–11.1428.57.6−1.9−23.7
Ramp to capacityBase15.827.8–11.8229.38.6−0.9−24.5
Ramp to capacityFast19.819.6–15.4732.112.3−9.9−26.9
About this exhibit
Table: for each producer rule and restocking setting refitted to the futures closes, the premium, its half-life, the producers' response to stocks, the average and largest miss, and the miss by year
Fit to the futures curve by producer rule and restocking setting
%, against the quoted contracts of 13 Nov 2026.
Each pair is refitted to the 19 quoted contracts: the premium at full tension, its half-life, and — for the trim rule — how hard output responds to stocks. The average miss is the root mean square of the log misses at the quoted contracts; the yearly misses are along the curve between them. A half-life at the bound of 30 months means the fit wants the premium to stay. The demand response is the middle one.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-4

Exhibit 10 · Strategic refills outside the US the curve would need, by rule

Times the base restocking, refitted with the premium for each Gulf core rule; refills in 2028, million barrels a day
Gulf coreTimes the base restockingRefills outside the US, 2027, mb/d2028, mb/dBarrels by December 2028, mbAverage miss, %
Trim as stocks rise0.000.000.0001.63
Produce at targets6 (bound)2.692.521,9308.13
Ramp to capacity0.000.000.00011.06
About this exhibit
Table: the scale on the base restocking's pace and volume that best fits the futures under each producer rule, the refills outside the US it implies in 2028 and by December 2028, and the miss that remains
Strategic refills outside the US the curve would need, by rule
Times the base restocking; refills in 2028, million barrels a day.
The base restocking's pace and volume outside the US are scaled together and refitted with the premium and its half-life; the trim rule's response to stocks is held at 0.15. A scale at its bound of 6 means even that multiple of the base restocking leaves the miss shown.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-5

Exhibit 11 · Average Brent by US reserve return schedule, against no returns

$ a barrel, calendar 2027 to 2029, other settings as chosen; the change from no US returns beside each average
ScheduleReturned, mb202720282029Change, 2027Change, 2028Change, 2029
No returnsNo US returns: a counterfactual0$83.55$75.17$71.59–––
As fast as the sites allowFrom January 2027 at the sites' top fill rate, 0.672 mb/d, until the 203 mb are back (Nov 2027)203$85.04$74.24$70.96+$1.50−$0.93−$0.63
Over one yearDOE's schedule over 52 weeks from a day in the first half of 2027, slowed by a fill rate of 0.25–0.67 mb/d203$84.21$75.56$71.75+$0.66+$0.39+$0.16
Over two yearsOver 104 weeks from a day in the first half of 2027: the drawdown simulation's default203$83.96$75.66$71.74+$0.41+$0.49+$0.15
Deferred six monthsOver 104 weeks, every first return 26 weeks later; 203 mb back by December 2029203$83.67$75.60$71.86+$0.13+$0.43+$0.27
Cheapest monthsThe 203 mb bought in the cheapest months from Jan 2027 to Jun 2029, at most 0.672 mb/d203$83.55$75.54$71.90$0.00+$0.37+$0.31
About this exhibit
Table: for each US reserve return schedule, the barrels returned, average Brent in each year and its change from the counterfactual of no returns, other settings as chosen
Average Brent by US reserve return schedule, against no returns
$ a barrel, 2027 to 2029; other settings as chosen. Select a row to draw it.
Every schedule repays what the reserve drawdown simulation says the US reserve is owed: 133 mb lent in 2026's completed exchanges plus the new loans, times one plus a premium of 18–28%, 203.3 mb on average. Returns start on a day in the first half of 2027 and run no faster than the sites take them, 0.252–0.672 mb a day. Each schedule is the simulation's flows averaged over its draws. The change is each schedule's yearly average less that of no returns, every other setting as chosen. Model-conditional.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-8

Exhibit 12 · The multiplier on China's refill pace by month

Ratio, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: one when last month's Brent equals its twelve-month average, rising by one per $20 below it
About this exhibit
The multiplier on China's refill pace each month, from last month's Brent against its 12-month average, between zero and one and a half, for the chosen and the compared setting
The multiplier on China's refill pace by month
Ratio, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
China's refill pace is its setting times this multiplier: 1 when last month's Brent equals its twelve-month average, one more for each $20 below it, between 0 and 1.5. October 2026's Brent averaged $108.34 against a twelve-month average of $86.12, so the multiplier starts at zero. Société Générale reads China's state buying the same way; the rule is the model's setting.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-9

Exhibit 13 · Strategic refill demand by quarter, against Kpler's estimate

Thousand barrels a day, Q4 2026 to Q4 2027, the default setting: refills by every holder beside Kpler's estimate
QuarterThe default settingKpler
Q4 202673506
Q1 2027294–
Q2 2027720–
Q3 2027815664
Q4 2027805–

By restocking setting outside the US, thousand barrels a day

RestockingQ4 2026Q3 20272028 average
None0281279
Slow37426545
Base73815702
Fast2001,688373
About this exhibit
Table: gross strategic refills by every holder in the default setting by quarter, thousand barrels a day, beside Kpler's published estimate for two quarters, and the same for each restocking setting
Strategic refill demand by quarter, against Kpler's estimate
Thousand barrels a day, the default setting.
Gross refills by every holder — the US reserve, other IEA members and China — before any releases still due. Kpler's estimate of 9 Jul 2026 covers crude refills in Q4 2026 and Q3 2027; the rows below the line give the same reading for each restocking setting outside the US.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-10

Exhibit 14 · Excess shipping cost per Gulf barrel and the part in Brent

$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029: war-risk insurance and freight above pre-war levels, falling with tension; the line is Brent's share
About this exhibit
Stacked monthly excess shipping cost per Gulf barrel — war-risk insurance and freight above their pre-war levels — and the part of it passed into Brent, $ a barrel, for the chosen de-escalation and demand response
Excess shipping cost per Gulf barrel and the part in Brent
$ a barrel, Nov 2026 to Dec 2029.
De-escalation: As the curve implies; demand response 2026 replay, −0.050. War-risk insurance at 8% of a $120m hull per 2 mb cargo against 0.25% before the war (quoted at 6–9% by Reuters on 25 September and 7.5–12.5% by Breakwave on 8 September), plus $5 a barrel of excess freight, a setting; both fall with tension. Half reaches Brent; the rest comes off the Gulf producers' netback.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-13

Exhibit 15 · Average Brent across the site's oil models, the futures and the EIA

$ a barrel, calendar 2027: the default setting, the Brent price simulation's median and mean, the futures strip and the EIA's path
Figure2027 averageHow it is made
Producers and refills, the default setting$83.96one path, fitted to the futures closes; producers trim as stocks rise
Brent price simulation, median$73.27the middle of its simulated paths on market odds for the reopening (Survey timing · 2026-calibrated demand · no strike risk after December)
Brent price simulation, mean$73.95the average of the same paths
Futures strip$83.75the twelve quoted contracts read two months ahead, 13 Nov 2026
Brent price simulation's futures strip$83.75front-month equivalent, Jan-27 to Feb-28 contracts, 13 Nov 2026
EIA's November path, futures basis$84.11the EIA's spot path moved onto the futures basis, as the Brent price simulation publishes it
About this exhibit
Table: average Brent in 2027 in the default setting, the Brent price simulation's median and mean, the futures strip on the same basis and the EIA's path, and how each is made
Average Brent across the site's oil models, the futures and the EIA
$ a barrel, 2027.
The two models differ on timing and demand, not on stocks: the producers-and-refills model fits one path to the futures and lets Gulf producers respond; the Brent price simulation draws 20,000 paths on market odds for the reopening and a demand response fitted to 2026. Each page labels its 2027 figure for what it is. The simulation's figures are copied from its page as published on 17 Nov 2026.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-15

Appendix

How one path is made, where each input comes from, and the checks the run passes95 checks, all pass
About this page

Brent, month by month from November 2026 to December 2029, from a model of oil stocks and prices. Commercial stocks clear the price; Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Kuwait trim output as stocks rise, produce at their OPEC+ targets or ramp to capacity; the US reserve is repaid on one of six schedules, on the reserve drawdown simulation's inputs, while other IEA members and China refill what they drew; and the Gulf's tension fades at the pace the futures imply, carrying a premium and a shipping cost. The premium, its half-life and the producers' response are fitted to the futures; demand responds as the Brent price simulation found in 2026 by default; every other input is a published figure or a named setting. One path per setting and no odds: model-conditional, not a forecast.

One path, month by month

Xt=Xt−1+30.4 [Nt+Qt+Ut+Ot+Relt−Dt−Rt]−ΔZtX_t = X_{t-1} + 30.4\,\big[N_t + Q_t + U_t + O_t + \mathrm{Rel}_t - D_t - R_t\big] - \Delta Z_t
Rt=USt+IEAt+CNt,CNt=pace⋅mt,mt=min⁡ ⁣(1.5,max⁡(0, 1+(P‾t−112−Pt−1)/20))R_t = \mathrm{US}_t + \mathrm{IEA}_t + \mathrm{CN}_t,\quad \mathrm{CN}_t = \mathrm{pace}\cdot m_t,\quad m_t = \min\!\big(1.5,\max(0,\,1 + (\overline{P}^{12}_{t-1} - P_{t-1})/20)\big)
Pt=max⁡ ⁣(45, PLR e−κXt/105)+g Tt+φ WtP_t = \max\!\big(45,\ P_{LR}\,e^{-\kappa X_t / 105}\big) + g\,T_t + \varphi\,W_t
Dt=Dt0 (Pˉtd/Pˉtd,ref)εd,Nt=Nt0 (Pˉts/Pˉts,ref)εsD_t = D^0_t\,\big(\bar P^{d}_t / \bar P^{d,\mathrm{ref}}_t\big)^{\varepsilon_d},\qquad N_t = N^0_t\,\big(\bar P^{s}_t / \bar P^{s,\mathrm{ref}}_t\big)^{\varepsilon_s}
Qt=min⁡ ⁣(Qˉt, Qt∗),Qt∗=Qt−1∗−k Xˉt−2/105−0.5 ΔXt−2 (trim rule)Q_t = \min\!\big(\bar Q_t,\ Q^{*}_t\big),\quad Q^{*}_t = Q^{*}_{t-1} - k\,\bar X_{t-2}/105 - 0.5\,\Delta X_{t-2}\ \text{(trim rule)}
SymbolMeaningFromAssumed or estimated
XtX_tcommercial stocks against their long-run level, mb; the price clears itthe ledger: IEA, S&P Global–
Qt, Ut, OtQ_t,\ U_t,\ O_tGulf core output (Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Kuwait), the UAE, the other Gulf producersOPEC; the note's settings–
Rt, ReltR_t,\ \mathrm{Rel}_tstrategic refills by the US, other IEA members and China; releases still duethe reserve drawdown simulation (DOE); IEA; Energy Aspects–
PLR, κP_{LR},\ \kappathe long-run level ($69.93, the December 2030 contract) and the stock slope (0.04 a day of cover)Yahoo Finance; Goldman Sachs–
g, Ttg,\ T_tthe premium at full tension ($14.31, fitted) and tension, fading at a fitted half-lifefitted to the futures–
φ, Wt\varphi,\ W_tthe share of the shipping cost in Brent (0.50) and the cost: war-risk insurance plus excess freightReuters; Breakwave; the note's settings–
εd, εs\varepsilon_d,\ \varepsilon_sthe price elasticities of consumption and of supply outside the Gulfthe 2026 replay (the Brent price simulation); the literature–
ZtZ_tcontango storage, filled while a month's spread exceeds full carrythe note's settings–

Model-conditional: what these inputs imply, setting by setting; not a forecast.

Exhibit 16 · Each input and where it comes from

What each path is made of: the value in the model, the kind of figure it is and its source, with the date.
InputIn the modelKindSource
Brent front month (BZ=F) daily closes: the monthly averages from November 2025 to October 2026 China's rule reads, and February 2026's for the pre-war overhangOctober 2026 average $108.34; 12-month average to October $86.12; February 2026 $69.41Yahoo FinanceYahoo Finance, BZ=F daily closes — completed sessions, 13 Nov 2026
Brent delivery-month contracts, January 2027 to February 2028, December 2028 and December 2029: closes of the last completed session, read two months ahead (the January 2027 contract prices November 2026)BZF27.NYM $95.84 (November 2026) to BZZ29.NYM $71.89; the long-run level BZZ30.NYM $69.93; 2027 $83.75, 2028 $75.84, 2029 $72.71 between quoted contractsYahoo FinanceYahoo Finance, Brent delivery-month contracts (NYMEX BZ) — BZF27.NYM, BZG27.NYM, BZH27.NYM, BZJ27.NYM, BZK27.NYM, BZM27.NYM, BZN27.NYM, BZQ27.NYM, BZU27.NYM, BZV27.NYM, BZX27.NYM, BZZ27.NYM, BZF28.NYM, BZG28.NYM, BZH28.NYM, BZM28.NYM, BZZ28.NYM, BZM29.NYM, BZZ29.NYM, BZZ30.NYM, 13 Nov 2026
The Brent price simulation's default setting: monthly median, 2027 median and mean, and the EIA's path on the futures basis, from that page's first month to December 2027, matched by month (D-2026-11-05-BP7)2027 median $73.27, mean $73.95; EIA path's 2027 average $84.11 on the futures basisThis siteThe Brent price simulation (Survey timing · 2026-calibrated demand · no strike risk after December) — the default setting's median, mean and the EIA path, 17 Nov 2026
Gulf core OPEC+ required production for November 2026: Saudi Arabia 10.478, Iraq 4.431, Kuwait 2.676 mb/d; 17.6 in the model17.6 mb/dPublishedOPEC, press release of the seven countries' meeting of 4 October 2026 — November 2026 required production, the table, 4 Oct 2026
Gulf core output: 9.2 mb/d restricted today, 19.7 at capacity with the Strait open; the trim rule keeps at least 12.0 and moves at most 0.5 a month; the share rule ramps 0.4 a month9.2–19.7 mb/dThe note's settingresearch note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) — §2 the producers' rules, 1 Nov 2026
UAE output outside the quotas: 2.4 mb/d through Fujairah, 1.5 more from July 2027 on a second line; capacity 4.85, 5.0 from January 2027; ramp 0.15 a month2.4 mb/d, 3.9 from July 2027; capacity 5.0The note's setting on Kpler's second Fujairah lineKpler — the UAE's second pipeline to Fujairah, mid-2027, 10 Jul 2026read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §2
Other Gulf output (Iran, Qatar, Bahrain, Oman): 6.0 mb/d pre-war, 2.0 lost at full tension; half of the Gulf core's open-strait output passes Hormuz in November 20266.0 mb/d less 2.0 at full tensionThe note's settingresearch note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) — §2 the Gulf, 1 Nov 2026
World consumption at the futures price: 102.8 mb/d in November 2026, 103.3 to 106.6 through 2027, then 0.8 and 0.7 mb/d a year in 2028 and 2029Nov 2026 102.8; Dec 2026 103.2; Jan 2027 103.3; Dec 2027 106.6; Jan 2028 106.8; Dec 2028 107.6; Jan 2029 107.8; Dec 2029 108.5IEA to 2027; growth after 2027 the note's settingIEA, Oil Market Report, August and October 2026 — fourth-quarter 2026 demand 2.5 mb/d below a year earlier (October); 2027 demand up 2.4 mb/d to about 105.7 (August), 14 Oct 2026read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §1
Supply outside the Gulf at the futures price: 80.4 mb/d in November 2026, up 2.2 mb/d through 2027, then 1.0 and 0.5 mb/d a yearNov 2026 80.4; Dec 2026 80.5; Dec 2027 82.7; Dec 2028 83.7; Dec 2029 84.2IEA to 2027; growth after 2027 the note's settingIEA, Oil Market Report, July and October 2026 — non-OPEC+ supply up 2.2 mb/d in 2027 (July); world supply 100.7 mb/d in 2026 (October), 14 Oct 2026read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §1
Short-run price elasticities in the literature: consumption −0.05, −0.10 or −0.20 on a six-month average of price (the prototype's three; the page sets −0.10 and −0.20 beside the 2026 replay); supply outside the Gulf 0.10 on a nine-month averagedemand −0.05 / −0.10 / −0.20; supply 0.10Literature rangeresearch note: oil demand and supply elasticities (18 Oct 2026) — rows 1–3 and 6–8 (Hamilton 2009 survey −0.06; Baumeister–Hamilton 2019 −0.35 and 0.15; Caldara–Cavallo–Iacoviello 2019 about 0.08), 18 Oct 2026
The demand setting fitted to 2026: the Brent price simulation's calibrated elasticity (the literature centre times the scale its 2026 replay fitted) at 1 month, 1 quarter and 12 months; this page's replay setting gives the same response at 12 months−0.0496 on a 6-month average of price: the simulation's 0.012 / 0.024 / 0.044 at 1, 3 and 12 months, matched at 12; this page's 0.008 / 0.021 / 0.044This siteThe Brent price simulation, its calibrated demand response — the literature centre × the 2026 replay's scale, 17 Nov 2026
Brent's response to stocks: 4% for each day of world demand that stocks sit away from their long-run level; a floor of $45 and a steeper fall beyond 450 mb above itκ = 0.04; floor $45Published (the slope); the floor and the overhang the note's settingGoldman Sachs, via Reuters — Brent to average $56 in 2026 on an ~800 mb rise in global stocks from late 2025 to late 2026, from a fair value in the mid-$70s, 26 Aug 2025read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §2: ln(56/75) over 800/105 days ≈ −0.038
Commercial stocks against their long-run level at end-October: 509 mb drawn from global stocks by end-September, 40 mb more in October, 331 mb of it from strategic and obligated stocks (refilled explicitly), plus the pre-war overhang at February 2026's Brent−509 − 40 + 331 + 20 = −198 mb (February 2026's $69.41 against the long-run $69.93)Published (IEA, S&P Global); October's draw the note's settingIEA, Oil Market Report, October 2026; S&P Global Commodity Insights — global observed stocks 509 mb below end-February at end-September (IEA); 331 mb released, 240 mb state and 91 mb obligated industry (S&P Global, 15 Oct), 15 Oct 2026read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §2
The IEA's collective action of 11 March 2026: 426 mb pledged, 172.2 mb by the US; 254 mb by other members to refill; 96 mb still to deliver, 40 mb by the US in November–December and 56 mb by others to February 2027426 mb pledged; 96 mb to deliverPublishedIEA collective action of 11 March 2026; IEA statements of 7 and 15 October 2026 — pledges by member; about 96 mb outstanding, 15 Oct 2026read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §1
The US reserve's flows other than a new sale, from the reserve drawdown simulation: the September award and the 16 October offer still to deliver, the October and next season's weather exchanges, the owed pool (the barrels lent in 2026 and the new loans, with their premium), the first-return window, a fill rate between EIA's best week since 2023 and the sites' combined top rate, and the one- and two-year schedules (the values in the next column are copied)203.3 mb owed on average: (133 + the new loans) × 1 + 18–28%; first returns 1 Jan 2027 to 30 Jun 2027; fill 0.252–0.672 mb/d; 52 or 104 weeks; 30.3 mb still to deliver from NovemberThis siteThe reserve drawdown simulation (Reserve drawdown simulation) — its inputs for the returns and the deliveries still due, averaged over its draws, 17 Nov 2026
China's onshore crude stocks 1.192 bn bbl on 19 October, 162 mb below the 4 May record; its buying rises by one pace for each $20 Brent sits below its 12-month average, at most 1.5 times; 104 mb of new storage in the fast setting162 mb to refill; 104 mb of new storagePublished (the stocks and storage); the buying rule the note's setting on Société Générale's readingEnergy Aspects, via Reuters (The Star); Kpler, via Hellenic Shipping News — 1.192 bn bbl on 19 Oct, 162 mb below the 4 May record of 1.354 bn; about 80 mb of new state storage and 24 mb of other capacity starting in 2026, 22 Oct 2026read in research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) §1
Kpler's estimate of refill demand: about 506 kb/d of crude in the fourth quarter of 2026, up to 664 kb/d by the third quarter of 2027 (a comparison, not an input)506 kb/d (4Q26), 664 kb/d (3Q27)PublishedKpler, via Reuters — strategic refills add about 506 kb/d of crude demand in 4Q26 and up to 664 kb/d by 3Q27, 9 Jul 2026
Tension falls from 1 in October 2026 at a half-life fitted to the curve, to a floor of 0.05; fast halves the half-life, slow doubles it from February 2027; a relapse returns to full tension from July to September 2027floor 0.05; half-life fittedThe note's setting; the half-life is fittedresearch note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026) — §2 tension and the premium, 1 Nov 2026
Shipping: war-risk insurance at 8% of a $120m hull per 2 mb cargo against 0.25% pre-war, plus $5 a barrel of excess freight, both falling with tension; half reaches Brent$9.65 a barrel in November 2026; 50% in BrentPublished (the insurance rates); hull, freight and pass-through the note's settingsReuters, via OilPrice; Breakwave Advisors; Insurance Business — Hormuz war-risk 6–9% of hull value per transit (25 Sep); 7.5–12.5% (8 Sep); about 0.25% pre-war (28 Jun), 25 Sept 2026read in research note: the Middle East and Russia–Ukraine baseline (14 Oct 2026) §5b
Contango storage at full carry: $0.60 a barrel a month onshore plus 3.9% a year financing$0.60 a barrel a month; 3.9% a yearThe note's settingresearch note: the oil refill and producer simulator (31 Oct 2026) — contango storage at full carry, 31 Oct 2026
About this exhibit
A published figure is used as the source states it. A setting is the model's choice, named as such; the reader moves the main ones with the controls. The futures closes and the front month are Yahoo Finance's completed sessions; the Brent price simulation's figures are copied from its page with its date.
Source: Yahoo Finance; OPEC; IEA; S&P Global; Energy Aspects; Kpler; Goldman Sachs; US Department of Energy; Reuters · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-16

Exhibit 17 · The model, its fit and the reference run

Model-conditional: every path on this page follows from the equations and inputs below, one path per setting; none is a forecast and none carries odds.

  • path

    Each path runs month by month from Nov 2026 to Dec 2029. Commercial stocks move with supply less demand less strategic refills plus releases still due, and Brent clears them: it sits above its long-run level of $69.93 when stocks are short, plus a premium that fades with tension and the part of the shipping cost that reaches it.

  • fit

    The default fits three numbers to the 19 quoted contracts of 13 Nov 2026: the premium at full tension ($14.31), its half-life (11.6 months) and how hard the Gulf core trims as stocks rise (0.001); its average miss is 0.92%. The stock slope and the starting gap are fixed at outside anchors, because the curve cannot tell them from the premium.

  • settings

    864 settings: six US return schedules, three producer rules, four de-escalation paths, three demand responses and four restocking settings outside the US. Each demand response is refitted; every other setting keeps its fit.

  • changed

    From the author's decision of 5 Nov 2026 (D-2026-11-05-OB9), the four further contracts are read. The long-run level is the December 2030 contract, $69.93, where before it was the December 2029 contract, $71.89, on the same closes of 13 Nov 2026. The starting stock gap moves with it, to −198 mb from −126 mb, because February 2026's Brent is read against the new level. The fit reads 19 quoted contracts where before it read 16, adding the March 2028 contract, the June 2028 contract, the June 2029 contract.

The fit at each demand response (producers trim, base restocking, even US returns)

Demand responsePremium, $Half-life, monthsResponse to stocksAverage miss, %
2026 replay, −0.05014.3111.60.0010.92
−0.1014.4311.50.0060.92
−0.2014.8911.00.0020.84

The starting commercial gap, each refitted

Gap, mbPremium, $Gulf core 2028, mb/dBrent 2028At targets, 2028Fast restocking less none, 2028
−30011.714.50$75.93$56.54+$0.45
−15016.414.58$75.30$57.96−$0.42
−198(default)14.314.60$75.66$58.08+$0.56

The engine on the research run's own inputs (research note: the oil-balance simulator with global restocking (1 Nov 2026)): 38 months of the curve and a long-run level of $71.06

FigureResearch runEngine
Premium at full tension, $32.655532.6555
Half-life, months11.477211.4772
Response to stocks0.112850.11285
Average miss, %0.88850.8885
Largest path difference over 5 settings–under one millionth
About this exhibit
How one path is made, the three numbers fitted to the futures, how the starting stock gap moves them, and the engine against the research run.
The stock slope and the starting gap are fixed at outside anchors because the curve cannot tell them from the premium; the table shows how the fit and the main readings move with the starting gap. The reference run is the research prototype on its own inputs; the checks hold this engine to it.
Source: Yahoo Finance (futures closes); OPEC; IEA; Kpler; Energy Aspects; Macro Review simulation on the inputs in the inputs table · data to 13 Nov 2026themes.oil_balance-17

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.