Macro ReviewHow to read
Outlook · Ledger · Expectations ledger

The market prices a 10-year 100bp above the site's value on the Committee's path

Where does what the market prices differ from the site's own view, and what would close each gap?

Market prices to 16 Nov 2026Every cell carries its own dateUpdated 18 Nov 2026
10-year Treasury yield less the site's value, Committee's path+101bp5.12% vs 4.12% · 16 Nov 2026 · beyond its band
forward less the Committee's end-2027 median+13bp4.23% vs 4.1% · 6 Nov 2026 · net of its premium
Consensus 2027 EPS growth less the site's model+10.4pp+15.1% vs +4.7% · 11 Sep 2026 · inside its band
Core PCE, Oct 2026: +0.30%Committee's pace 0.33% a month · data to 10 Nov 2026
Real GDP, Q4 2026: this site's nowcast+2.7%Committee's pace 1.1% · data to 17 Nov 2026

In brief

What the market prices against the Committee and the site's own models, row by row, with the test that would close each gap
  • The 10-year sits 100bp above the site's value on the Committee's path, beyond its band; each Treasury close tests it.→ Exhibit 2
  • The 1y1y forward, 4.23% net of its , sits 13bp above the Committee's end-2027 median.→ Exhibit 3
  • Consensus prices +15.1% EPS growth for 2027 against the site's +4.7%, inside its band.→ Exhibit 1
  • 8 of the ledger's 14 rows have no market price on the site.→ Exhibit 1
  • The site's core PCE for Oct 2026, +0.30%, runs below the 0.33% monthly pace the Committee's median implies.→ Exhibit 1
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
The 10-year completes the move to a hold10-year ≤ 4.065%5.12% (16 Nov 2026)not crossedeach Treasury close
The market drops its tightening path forward < 4.15% ( + 25bp)5.05% (16 Nov 2026)not crossedeach Treasury close
Trailing earnings for Q2 2027 leave the four-quarter 80% bandbelow $262.09 or above $369.71$292.58 · Q2 2026pendingthe members' Q2 2027 filings
Consensus moves halfway to the modelFactSet calendar-2027 EPS growth < 9.9% (halfway from +15.1% to the model's +4.7%)+15.1% (11 Sep 2026)not crossedthe next FactSet Earnings Insight quote
The reasoning behind each point
  • Gap
    The 10-year sits 100bp above the site's value on the Committee's path, beyond its band; each Treasury close tests it.

    Market 5.12 (Treasury par yield, 16 Nov 2026) against the site's 4.12 (fair value on the Committee's path, 13 Nov 2026); the site's band runs 3.10 to 4.62 (assumed values). What closes it: the 10-year completes the move to a hold — 10-year par yield ≤ 4.065%, decided by each Treasury close.

  • Policy path
    The 1y1y forward, 4.23% net of its term premium, sits 13bp above the Committee's end-2027 median.

    1y1y forward net of its term premium 4.23% (6 Nov 2026): the median of 2 models' expected paths (ACM, Kim–Wright); the Treasury 1y1y with its premium is 5.05% (16 Nov 2026). The Committee's median for the end of 2027 is 4.1% (16 Sep 2026). The site's policy rules put the rate at 4.98% for Q4 2026 (4.57 to 5.08% across 6 rules), −75bp from the market.

  • Earnings
    Consensus prices +15.1% EPS growth for 2027 against the site's +4.7%, inside its band.

    Consensus is analysts' calendar-2027 growth (FactSet, quoted 11 Sep 2026) on operating earnings; the site's is the default earnings model's median on reported earnings, with its 10th–90th band −9.3 to +21.8% (past misses).

  • Absent
    8 of the ledger's 14 rows have no market price on the site.

    Policy rate, Dec 2026: fed funds and SOFR futures are not among the site's sources; Core PCE, Oct 2026: the site reads no inflation swaps; Core PCE, 2026: the site reads no inflation swaps; Real GDP, Q4 2026: no traded contract on GDP is among the site's sources; published nowcasts are not market prices; Payrolls, Nov 2026: no traded contract on payrolls is among the site's sources; S&P 500 EPS growth, 2026: FactSet's reading is past its age or not on file; the site holds it as an optional, dated quote; S&P 500 trailing EPS, next four quarters: no traded contract or quoted consensus on trailing four-quarter earnings is among the site's sources; WTI crude, end-2026: EIA's futures series ends 5 Apr 2024; the site has no current oil futures price.

  • Inflation
    The site's core PCE nowcast for Oct 2026, +0.30%, runs below the 0.33% monthly pace the Committee's median implies.

    The nowcast's band is +0.21 to +0.38% (out-of-sample record); the Committee's a month from Oct 2026 to Dec 2026: the pace the 3.4% median for 2026 (Q4 on Q4) implies. No market price for core PCE is on the site, so this row carries no gap.

Next: This quarter's growth — the nowcasts behind this site's column

Source: U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve; BEA; BLS; FactSet, as quoted; marketdata.app; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.ledger-read

One row per variable: the market, the Committee, the site and the gap

The market-implied level with its source, the Committee's September projections, the site's estimate with its band, the gap, what closes it and the asset it moves

Exhibit 1 · Market price against Committee projection and site estimate, by variable

14 variables: market-implied value, Committee median, site estimate and band, gap (market less site), what closes it; units by row, mostly %; to 16 Nov 2026
About
VariableMarket-impliedThe Committee's September projectionsThis siteGap, market less siteWhat closes itAsset implication
Policy rate, Dec 2026end of 2026 · %no market price on the sitefed funds and SOFR futures are not among the site's sources4.1median, end of 2026 · 16 Sep 2026 · What is priced4.981policy rules: Taylor (1993) · Q4 2026 · Policy rulesband 4.57 to 5.08 other modelsnoneInflation falls to where the Taylor (1993) rule meets IORBfour-quarter core PCE ≤ 2.40% (unemployment 4.10%, r_LR 1.2%)decided by BEA Personal Income and Outlays, 25 Nov 2026 (Oct 2026 data) · Policy rulesThe policy rate → the 2-year and the 1y1y forward+100bp on the federal funds effective rate (monthly average) → 2-year +58bp, 1y1y +48bp in the monthlives on Policy rates
Policy rate, Sep 2027one-year rate a year ahead · %4.2321y1y forward net of its term premium · 6 Nov 2026 · Inside the 10-year4.1median, end of 2027 · 16 Sep 2026 · What is priced4.983policy rules: Taylor (1993) · Q4 2026 · Policy rulesband 4.57 to 5.08 other models−75bpbeyond its band+13bp against the CommitteeThe market drops its tightening path1y1y forward < 4.15% (IORB + 25bp)decided by each Treasury close · What is pricedThe policy rate → the 2-year and the 1y1y forward+100bp on the federal funds effective rate (monthly average) → 2-year +58bp, 1y1y +48bp in the monthlives on Policy rates
10-year Treasury yieldpar yield · %5.12Treasury par yield · 16 Nov 2026 · Treasury curveno projectionthe Committee projects no 10-year yield4.124fair value on the Committee's path · 13 Nov 2026 · What is pricedband 3.10 to 4.62 assumed values+100bpbeyond its bandThe 10-year completes the move to a hold10-year par yield ≤ 4.065%decided by each Treasury close · What is pricedThe 10-year → the S&P 500, through the valuation identity+100bp on the 10-year, so on the required return; premium and growth held → S&P 500 −21.6% per point at today's rate (the identity's slope)lives on Valuation
Core PCE, Oct 2026next print · % on the monthno market price on the sitethe site reads no inflation swaps+0.335the monthly pace its median implies · 16 Sep 2026 · Inflation nowcast+0.30the site's core PCE nowcast · 10 Nov 2026 · Inflation nowcastband +0.21 to +0.38 out-of-sample recordnoneCore PCE for Oct 2026 missespublished change outside 0.21 to 0.38% (nowcast ± record RMSE)decided by Personal Income and Outlays for Oct 2026, 25 Nov 2026 (BEA) · Inflation nowcastnot on the transmission table
Core PCE, 2026Q4 on Q4 · %no market price on the sitethe site reads no inflation swaps3.4median, 2026 · 16 Sep 2026 · What is pricedno site estimatethe site's nowcast covers the next two prints, not the yearnoneno estimate to testnot on the transmission table
Real GDP, Q4 2026this quarter · % annualisedno market price on the siteno traded contract on GDP is among the site's sources; published nowcasts are not market prices+1.16the pace its median implies · 16 Sep 2026 · GDP nowcast+2.7the site's GDP nowcast · 17 Nov 2026 · GDP nowcastband +0.8 to +4.6 out-of-sample recordnoneAdvance GDP lands outside the nowcast's rangeBEA's first Q4 2026 estimate outside 0.8–4.6% (nowcast ± one record RMSE)decided by BEA advance GDP, 28 Jan 2027 · GDP nowcastnot on the transmission table
Payrolls, Nov 2026next report · thousandsno market price on the siteno traded contract on payrolls is among the site's sourcesno projectionthe Committee projects unemployment, not payrolls+163the site's payrolls nowcast · 12 Nov 2026 · Labour nowcastband +52 to +274 out-of-sample recordnoneNov 2026 payrolls land outside the nowcast's rangefirst estimate outside +52k to +274k (nowcast ± record RMSE)decided by Employment Situation for Nov 2026, 4 Dec 2026 (BLS) · Labour nowcastnot on the transmission table
S&P 500 EPS growth, 2027calendar year · %+15.1analysts' consensus (FactSet, quoted), not a traded price · 11 Sep 2026 · Earningsno projectionthe Committee projects no earnings+4.77the site's earnings model, median · Q2 2026 · Earningsband −9.3 to +21.8 past misses+10.4ppinside its bandConsensus moves halfway to the modelFactSet calendar-2027 EPS growth < 9.9% (halfway from +15.1% to the model's +4.7%)decided by the next FactSet Earnings Insight quote · Earningsnot on the transmission table
S&P 500 EPS growth, 2026calendar year, the earnings base · %no market price on the siteFactSet's reading is past its age or not on file; the site holds it as an optional, dated quoteno projectionthe Committee projects no earnings+34.38the site's earnings base · Q2 2026 · Earnings outlookband +25.1 to +45.5 simulated shocksnoneTrailing earnings for Q3 2026 leave the one-quarter 80% bandbelow $296.31 or above $321.87decided by the members' Q3 2026 filings (10-Qs due 9 Nov 2026) · Earnings outlooknot on the transmission table
S&P 500 EPS growth, 2027calendar year, the earnings base · %+15.1analysts' consensus (FactSet, quoted), not a traded price · 11 Sep 2026 · Earningsno projectionthe Committee projects no earnings−4.19the site's earnings base · Q2 2026 · Earnings outlookband −24.7 to +19.9 simulated shocks+19.2ppinside its bandTrailing earnings for Q2 2027 leave the four-quarter 80% bandbelow $262.09 or above $369.71decided by the members' Q2 2027 filings · Earnings outlooknot on the transmission table
S&P 500 trailing EPS, next four quartersgrowth from the last filed quarter, the earnings base · %no market price on the siteno traded contract or quoted consensus on trailing four-quarter earnings is among the site's sourcesno projectionthe Committee projects no earnings+6.410the site's earnings base · Q2 2026 · Earnings outlookband −10.4 to +26.4 simulated shocksnoneTrailing earnings for Q2 2027 leave the four-quarter 80% bandbelow $262.09 or above $369.71decided by the members' Q2 2027 filings · Earnings outlooknot on the transmission table
WTI crude, end-2026end of 2026 · $ a barrelno market price on the siteEIA's futures series ends 5 Apr 2024; the site has no current oil futures priceno projectionthe Committee projects no oil priceno site estimatethe Hormuz page's branches are named paths, not a forecastnoneno estimate to testPump price → CPI energy → headline CPI+10% on the monthly average pump price → headline CPI +0.45% (energy +5.0%, gasoline +9.3%)lives on CPI
Equity volatility, 1 monthS&P 500 (SPY) · % move over a month±5.411SPY's implied move, one standard deviation over 21 sessions · 16 Nov 2026 · What options priceno projectionthe Committee projects no market volatility−6.9 to +7.4the site's cone, 10th to 90th percentile over 20 sessions · 13 Nov 2026 · Conessimulated shocksnot subtractedSPY's move is one standard deviation over 21 sessions; the site's cone is the 10th to 90th percentile band over 20 sessions: two measures of the spread, set side by sideThe CPI on 10 Dec 2026 and the FOMC decision on 9 Dec 2026the next dates on the release calendar · US Macro overviewthe transmission table has no volatility row
Variance risk premium, 1 monthS&P 500 (SPY), implied less realised · vol points−3.912SPY: one-month implied less 21-session realised volatility, the 11th percentile of 476 sessions · 16 Nov 2026 · What options priceno projectionthe Committee projects no market volatilityno site estimatethe site makes no volatility forecast; realised volatility, the premium's other side, is the past month'sitself a gapimplied less realised volatility, as the options page measures it; the site makes no volatility estimate to set against itInsurance on SPY turns cheapone-month implied below 21-session realised volatilitydecided by each session's close (next 17 Nov 2026) · What options pricethe transmission table has no volatility row
  1. a prescription for Q4 2026 on today's inputs, not a forecast of the Committee
  2. the median of 2 models' expected paths (ACM, Kim–Wright); the Treasury 1y1y with its premium is 5.05% (16 Nov 2026)
  3. a prescription for Q4 2026 on today's inputs, not a forecast of the Committee
  4. One further +25bp, then hold, at today's ACM premium; the band spans the premiums the rules grid assumes
  5. a month from Oct 2026 to Dec 2026: the pace the 3.4% median for 2026 (Q4 on Q4) implies
  6. annualised over the last 1 quarters of 2026: the pace the 2.3% median for 2026 (Q4 on Q4) implies
  7. reported EPS on national-accounts profits; consensus is on operating EPS
  8. GAAP earnings on the index basis (SPY's holdings); consensus is on operating earnings
  9. GAAP earnings on the index basis (SPY's holdings); consensus is on operating earnings
  10. GAAP earnings on the index basis (SPY's holdings); consensus is on operating earnings
  11. SPY's one-month at-the-money implied volatility, 18.8 points, scaled to 21 sessions: what the market prices, not this site's forecast
  12. SPY's one-month implied volatility, 18.8 points, against its realised volatility, 22.7 points: what insurance costs over what the market has delivered
About this exhibit
A table with one row for each variable (policy rate, 10-year yield, core PCE, real GDP, payrolls, S&P 500 earnings growth, oil, equity volatility): the market-implied level and its instrument, the Committee's median, the site's estimate with its band, the gap (market less site), the test that would close it and the asset it moves; each cell dated
The ledger, row by row
Each variable's market-implied level, the Committee's September median, the site's estimate with its band, the gap, what closes it and the asset it moves.
Every cell is copied from the page that owns it and carries that page's date; the unit is printed once, under the variable. The gap is the market less the site, in basis points for rates and percentage points for growth, and says whether the market lies inside or beyond the site's band; where the two measure different things the row says so instead. A variable no market instrument on the site prices says so, with the reason, and borrows no number from elsewhere.
Source: U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve; BEA; BLS; FactSet, as quoted; marketdata.app; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.ledger-1

The 10-year is beyond its band: 100bp above the site's value on the Committee's path

Each gap as a multiple of the site's band on the market's side: beyond one, the market prices what the site's band does not reach

Exhibit 2 · Market-to-site gap of each variable in multiples of the site's band

×: gap (market less site) over the distance to the site's band edge on the market's side; dashed: the band's edges; to 16 Nov 2026
About
About this exhibit
Bar chart with one bar for each variable that has both a market price and a site estimate: the market-less-site gap divided by the reach of the site's band on the market's side; dashed lines mark the band's edge, and each bar is labelled with the gap in its own unit
Each gap as a multiple of the site's band
Each gap over the reach of the site's band on the market's side: a bar past a dashed line is a gap beyond the band.
A multiple above one means the market prices a level the site's own band does not reach. Each band is its page's, with its kind under the row's name; each bar is labelled with the gap in the row's own unit. Rows without a market price or a site estimate have no gap and are not drawn.
Source: U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve; BEA; BLS; FactSet, as quoted; marketdata.app; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.ledger-2

The market's policy path and how it is measured

The forward the policy row reads, with the beside it, and a year of the market's path against the Committee's median

Exhibit 3 · The market's one-year rate a year ahead, against the Committee's median

%, latest: the Treasury 1y1y forward (16 Nov 2026) and net of its premium (6 Nov 2026); the Committee's median, end of 2027 (16 Sep 2026)
About
Treasury 1y1y forward, which includes a term premium16 Nov 20265.05%
1y1y net of its term premium, the models' median (the row's market price)6 Nov 20264.23%
ACM6 Nov 20264.36%
Kim–Wright6 Nov 20264.11%
10-year term premium, four models' median6 Nov 2026 · the four run 0.64 to 1.75%0.89%
The Committee's median, end of 202716 Sep 20264.1%
Market less the Committee+13bp
About this exhibit
Table: the Treasury 1y1y forward with its term premium; the same forward net of its term premium (the median of the expected-path models); the 10-year term premium; the Committee's median for the end of next year; and market less Committee
What the policy row reads
The 1y1y forward the policy row prints, the term premium beside it, and the Committee's median for the end of 2027.
The policy row reads the 1y1y forward net of its term premium (the decomposition's expected-path models): the 10-year decomposition serves its expected-path 1y1y, so the policy row reads it. The one-year rate one year ahead starts in late September 2027, so it is set against the Committee's median for the end of 2027.
Source: U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve; BEA; BLS; FactSet, as quoted; marketdata.app; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.ledger-3

Exhibit 4 · The 1y1y forward and 10-year yield daily, against the Committee's median

Daily closes, %, to 16 Nov 2026: 1y1y forward with and without its premium, 10-year yield; flat: Committee's end-2027 median 4.1% and IORB 3.90%
About this exhibit
Line chart of daily closes over the past year (toggles to longer ranges): the 1y1y forward with its term premium, the 1y1y forward net of its premium (the models' median) and the 10-year Treasury yield, against flat lines at the Committee's median and IORB, the rate the Fed pays on bank reserves
A year of the market's path
Daily closes to 16 Nov 2026: the 1y1y forward and the 10-year, against the Committee's end-2027 median and the rate on reserves.
Source: U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve; BEA; BLS; FactSet, as quoted; marketdata.app; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.ledger-4

Appendix

What each column is, where every cell is copied from, and what the band on each row is101 checks, all pass
About this page

The ledger sets what the market prices beside what the Committee projects and what the site's own models estimate, one row per variable, with the gap between the market and the site, the test that would close it and the asset it moves. Every cell is copied from the page that owns it and carries that page's date; a variable no market instrument on the site prices says so rather than borrowing a number. The bands are the owning pages' ranges, each with its kind, and the site's estimates are model-conditional.

The gap and the band multiple

gap=(m−s)×k\text{gap} = (m - s)\times k
x=m−s b−s ,b={him>slom<sx = \frac{m - s}{\,b - s\,}, \qquad b = \begin{cases} \text{hi} & m > s \\ \text{lo} & m < s \end{cases}
SymbolMeaningFromAssumed or estimated
mmthe market-implied levelthe page that copies the market price–
ssthe site's estimatethe page that owns the variable–
lo, hi\text{lo},\ \text{hi}the ends of the site's band, with its kindthe same page–
kk100 for a rate (basis points), 1 for growth (percentage points)the ledger's rows–
xxthe gap as a multiple of the band's reach on the market's side: beyond the band when |x| > 1computed–

Model-conditional: a gap is the difference between two published numbers; the multiple says how far the market sits from the site's band, not how likely either is.

Exhibit 5 · The 14 rows' columns, and where each cell comes from

What each column is, where each cell comes from, and what the band on each row is.
MarketThe market-implied level and the instrument that prices it, with its date. Where none of the site's sources prices the variable the cell says so and gives the reason; a published nowcast or a survey is not a market price, and no number is borrowed from another row.
The Committee's September projectionsThe median of the Committee's projections of 16 Sep 2026 as What is priced parses them; for the next core PCE print and this quarter's GDP, the pace the nowcast pages derive from that same median (checked equal to it).
This siteThe estimate of the page that owns the variable — the policy rules, the fair 10-year on the Committee's path, the three nowcasts, the earnings model — with its band and the band's kind.
GapMarket less site, in basis points for rates and percentage points for growth, recomputed from the two pages' values and checked to 1e-9; blank where either is missing, and not computed where the two measure different things (the volatility rows say why on the row).
What closes itThe owning page's own test of the estimate, re-used as that page prints it, with the date that decides it.
Asset implicationThe matching row of the transmission table: the shock, the response and the asset it moves. A variable with no row there says so.
The policy row's market pricePolicy row, Sep 2027: the 1y1y forward net of its term premium (the decomposition's expected-path models). The 10-year decomposition serves its expected-path 1y1y, so the policy row reads it, as the author's decision of 3 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-03-C) sets. The one-year rate one year ahead starts in late September 2027, so it is set against the Committee's median for the end of 2027, the nearest date the projections give. The 10-year's term premium printed beside it is the four premium models' median from the 10-year decomposition; the 1y1y's own premium is smaller and is not split by any page, so nothing is subtracted.
The site's policy readingThe site has no forecast of the policy rate. Its policy reading is the rules page's prescription on today's inputs — the rule that page leads with, the band the span of every rule it prints — which says where the rules put the rate now, not where the Committee will set it.
Bands, not weightsNo row carries a probability or odds: until dated judgement odds are written in the never-revised log, no central forecast is claimed (the author's decision of 3 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-03-B)). The bands are the owning pages' ranges, each with its kind: past misses, other models or assumed values.
Rows with no market pricePolicy rate, Dec 2026: fed funds and SOFR futures are not among the site's sources; Core PCE, Oct 2026: the site reads no inflation swaps; Core PCE, 2026: the site reads no inflation swaps; Real GDP, Q4 2026: no traded contract on GDP is among the site's sources; published nowcasts are not market prices; Payrolls, Nov 2026: no traded contract on payrolls is among the site's sources; S&P 500 EPS growth, 2026: FactSet's reading is past its age or not on file; the site holds it as an optional, dated quote; S&P 500 trailing EPS, next four quarters: no traded contract or quoted consensus on trailing four-quarter earnings is among the site's sources; WTI crude, end-2026: EIA's futures series ends 5 Apr 2024; the site has no current oil futures price.
The volatility rowsThe volatility rows copy what options price from the options page: the S&P 500's implied one-month move, one standard deviation over 21 sessions, and the premium of one-month implied volatility over realised volatility, with its percentile. Beside the move the row sets the site's own cone, the 10th to 90th percentile band of the S&P 500's return over 20 sessions (simulated shocks). A standard deviation and a percentile band are two measures of the spread, so the two are set side by side and not subtracted: turning one into the other would need an assumed distribution, which neither page states. The premium is itself a difference, implied less realised, and the site makes no volatility estimate to set against it. Neither row has a gap, so neither is drawn among the gaps or leads the page. What closes the equity row is the next CPI and FOMC decision on the release calendar.
About this exhibit
Definitions
Source: U.S. Treasury; Federal Reserve; BEA; BLS; FactSet, as quoted; marketdata.app; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.ledger-5

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.