Macro ReviewHow to read
Cross Asset · Sectors & styles · Sector valuation

The S&P 500 trades 8% below its five-year average forward P/E

How far is each sector's forward P/E from its own normal, and does that gap carry information about next year's multiple?

FactSet report of 13 Nov 2026 · monthly since Jan 2017 · baskets 13 Nov 2026Updated 18 Nov 2026
S&P 500 forward P/E18.3×Nov 2026 · 5-year average 19.8×
S&P 500 against its 5-year average−7.6%Nov 2026 · 10-year −4.2%fails the rule
Technology against its 5-year average−29.1%Nov 2026 · forward P/E 18.0×fails the rule
Staples against its 5-year average+13.4%Nov 2026 · forward P/E 23.7×fails the rule
Sectors above their 5-year average4of 11 · Nov 2026
Sectors whose normal 0of 11 · index fails

In brief

Each sector's forward P/E against its own five- and ten-year averages, and whether the gap has told anything about the next year
  • The S&P 500's forward P/E was 18.3× in Nov 2026, 7.6% below its five-year average.→ Exhibit 1
  • Technology's forward P/E was 18.0× in Nov 2026, 29.1% below its own five-year average.→ Exhibit 2
  • On the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026, tech's price assumes EPS growth of +5.5% a year for five years; the model has +15.8%.→ Exhibit 5
  • None of the 11 sectors' five-year averages passes the , and the index's does not.→ Exhibit 7
  • The index sat a median 3.6% above its normal in the 48 months the current regime has held.→ Exhibit 8
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
The index back at its normalS&P 500 forward P/E at or above its five-year average−7.6% (Nov 2026)not crossedFactSet's Earnings Insight for Dec 2026, added to the import
Technology back at its normaltechnology's forward P/E at or below its five-year average−29.1% (Nov 2026)crossedFactSet's Earnings Insight for Dec 2026, added to the import
Tech's multiple back at its basket normaltech's forward P/E at or above its of 24.3× (the canvas model's)18.0× (13 Nov 2026)not crossedthe next consensus read for the baskets
The normal earns a readingthe index's five-year average passing the stability ruleerror 1.07× the random walk'snot crossedFactSet's Earnings Insight for Dec 2026, added to the import
The reasoning behind each point
  • Index
    The S&P 500's forward P/E was 18.3× in Nov 2026, 7.6% below its five-year average.

    Its five-year average is 19.8× and its ten-year average 19.1×, as FactSet prints them.

  • Technology
    Technology's forward P/E was 18.0× in Nov 2026, 29.1% below its own five-year average.

    Consumer staples sit 13.4% above theirs.

  • Baskets
    On the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026, tech's price assumes EPS growth of +5.5% a year for five years; the model has +15.8%.

    Tech's forward P/E of 18.0× sits 26.1% below its normal level of 24.3×, a normal that passes the stability rule on the six baskets' quarterly history.

  • Rule
    None of the 11 sectors' five-year averages passes the stability rule, and the index's does not.

    The rule asks for a positive slope with |t| of 2 or more and the same sign in both halves of the sample. Its 12-month target must also beat today's multiple carried forward.

  • Regime
    The index sat a median 3.6% above its normal in the 48 months the current regime has held.

    The current regime is the one in which only the dollar hedges. In the regime in which bonds hedge (53 months) the median was 6.2% above. A description of what has happened, not a signal.

Next: Growth against value — growth's multiple against value's

Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; the four-regime vote (Regime page); Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-read

Forward P/E against each sector's own normal

The gap to the five-year average since 2017 for the index and three sectors, and every sector today

Exhibit 1 · The S&P 500's forward P/E was 18.3× in Nov 2026

About this exhibit
Forward P/E against its own five-year average for the index and three sectors
%, the forward 12-month P/E over its five-year average, less one, monthly, Jan 2017 to Nov 2026; shaded: the months of the current regime, in which only the dollar hedges.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; the four-regime vote (Regime page); Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-2

Exhibit 2 · Technology's forward P/E was 18.0× in Nov 2026

About
SectorForward P/E5-year average10-year averageGap to 5-yearGap to 10-yearGap to 5-yearStability rule
S&P 50018.3×19.8×19.1×−7.6%−4.2%
fails the rule
Information technology18.0×25.4×23.1×−29.1%−22.1%
fails the rule
Communication services16.8×18.3×17.7×−8.2%−5.1%
fails the rule
Consumer discretionary25.1×25.9×25.6×−3.1%−2.0%
fails the rule
Consumer staples23.7×20.9×20.1×+13.4%+17.9%
fails the rule
Health care20.0×17.4×16.7×+14.9%+19.8%
fails the rule
Financials15.1×14.6×14.0×+3.4%+7.9%
fails the rule
Industrials22.5×21.0×20.1×+7.1%+11.9%
fails the rule
Materials17.4×18.0×17.8×−3.3%−2.2%
fails the rule
Energy12.2×12.6×—−3.2%—
fails the rule
Utilities17.0×17.9×18.0×−5.0%−5.6%
fails the rule
Real estate18.0×18.0×18.6×±0.0%−3.2%
fails the rule
About this exhibit
Forward P/E of each sector against its own five- and ten-year averages
Forward 12-month P/E, Nov 2026, as FactSet prints it; the gap is the P/E over the average, less one, %; the badge is the stability rule's verdict on the five-year average.
A sector whose normal level fails the stability rule shows its gap with a fail badge and no direction: the gap is a description, not a reading of what comes next. The bar is drawn to the gap to the five-year average, centred on zero.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-1

Each sector's forward P/E against its own 2017–26 range

Where each sector's multiple sits in the months since 2017, and the index's against the on each premium basis

Exhibit 3 · Forward P/E of each sector and the index against its own range since 2017

About this exhibit
Forward 12-month P/E, FactSet, monthly since Jan 2017: the thin bar runs from the lowest to the highest month, the thick bar from the 25th to the 75th percentile; the dot is Nov 2026.
An observed range, not a model's: the months each sector has had since 2017. A dot near an end is a multiple near its extreme in this sample, which says nothing on its own about the next year.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-8

Exhibit 4 · S&P 500 forward P/E against its trading range and the model's value on each premium basis

About this exhibit
Forward P/E, FactSet, Nov 2026. The trading range is the months since Jan 2017; each premium basis is the Valuation page's two-stage value as a multiple: today's P/E times the value over the price of 16 Nov 2026.
Model-conditional. Each basis's bar is the spread of the model's estimated inputs, carried through the two-stage identity on the Valuation page; the trading range is observed. The model's value sits below the price on every basis, so each basis's multiple sits below today's.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; the Valuation page (two-stage model); Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-9

What each basket's price assumes, and how far its multiple is from normal

Five-year EPS growth by basket, priced, modelled and consensus; and each basket's forward P/E against its , on the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026

Exhibit 5 · On the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026, tech's price assumes EPS growth of +5.5% a year for five years; the model has +15.8%.

BasketPricedModelled (10th–90th)ConsensusPremium the price implies
Tech+5.5%+15.8% (+7% to +28%)+30.5%7.2pp
Semis−2.6%+16.1% (+2% to +33%)+41.1%11.1pp
Growth+6.9%+17.5% (+8% to +29%)+27.0%7.0pp
S&P 500+8.5%+11.1% (+4% to +20%)+20.9%4.7pp
Value+10.5%+3.8% (±0% to +8%)+14.0%2.9pp
Staples+17.0%+2.8% (+1% to +4%)+8.5%1.7pp
About this exhibit
Five-year EPS growth by basket: priced, modelled and consensus
% a year, 13 Nov 2026. Priced: the growth that returns today's forward P/E at a 9.29% cost of equity; modelled: the canvas model's median with its 10th–90th; consensus: analysts' long-term growth. The premium holds growth at the model's figure and solves for the return, less the 10-year.
Source: Yahoo Finance consensus, 13 Nov 2026; SEC EDGAR; State Street; FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculationssectors.multiple-10

Exhibit 6 · Forward P/E, normal level and justified level by basket

BasketForward P/ENormal levelGap2017–26 range (10th–90th)JustifiedVerdict
Tech18.0×24.3×−26%18.0× to 28.8×30.1×passes the rule
Semis12.3×16.3×−25%14.8× to 28.1×32.5×passes the rule
Growth18.4×23.6×−22%18.4× to 28.2×30.7×passes the rule
S&P 50018.3×20.1×−9%16.6× to 22.4×20.5×fails the rule
Value18.0×17.5×+3%14.2× to 18.5×14.1×fails the rule
Staples23.7×21.1×+12%18.3× to 22.0×13.6×fails the rule
About this exhibit
Multiples (×), 13 Nov 2026. Normal level: the basket's multiple since 2017 after the regime, the canvas model's; verdict: the stability rule on the gap to it, 108 basket-quarters. Justified: the canvas's DCF at modelled growth.
Not FactSet's five-year average: the basket's normal level is the canvas model's, tested on the six baskets' quarter-ends since 2017, so a basket can pass where the FactSet sector of the same name fails. The justified level is model-conditional; actual multiples have not followed it since 2017 (Method and record).
Source: Yahoo Finance consensus, 13 Nov 2026; SEC EDGAR; State Street; FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculationssectors.multiple-11

Which sectors' have earned a reading

The , sector by sector: the slope, the halves and the 12-month target test against the random walk

Exhibit 7 · None of the 11 sectors' five-year averages passes the stability rule

About
SectorMonthsSlopetFirst halfSecond halfError against random walkSignHalvesTargetVerdict
S&P 5001150.814.61.502.141.07×yesyesnofails the rule
Information technology1140.725.81.360.701.01×yesyesnofails the rule
Communication services92-0.04-0.20.034.221.25×noyesnofails the rule
Consumer discretionary1150.513.11.95-0.161.36×yesnonofails the rule
Consumer staples1141.142.80.451.341.13×yesyesnofails the rule
Health care1151.154.5-0.620.770.99×yesnoyesfails the rule
Financials1151.493.4-0.931.730.94×yesnoyesfails the rule
Industrials1140.964.01.893.281.15×yesyesnofails the rule
Materials1150.551.40.693.210.94×noyesyesfails the rule
Energy510.261.5-4.110.093.47×nononofails the rule
Utilities1150.170.50.90-2.730.96×nonoyesfails the rule
Real estate59-0.20-0.4-3.570.181.44×nononofails the rule
About this exhibit
The stability rule for each sector's five-year average
Log forward P/E on the log five-year average, monthly; the slope and its t-statistic, the slope in each half, and the 12-month target's error as a multiple of today's P/E carried forward.
The rule asks three things of a normal level before the page reads a direction from its gap: a positive slope with |t| of 2 or more, the same sign in both halves of the sample, and a target, re-estimated each month on the data to that month, whose 12-month error is below the random walk's. All three must hold.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-4

Each sector's gap to normal in each regime since 2017

The median gap to the five-year average in the months each of the four regimes held

Exhibit 8 · The index sat a median 3.6% above its normal in the 48 months the current regime has held.

SectorNothing hedges
14 months
Bonds hedge
53 months
Only the dollar hedges (current)
48 months
S&P 500+11.6%+6.3%+3.6%
Information technology+14.8%+17.4%+12.9%
Communication services+14.1%+28.4%−0.5%
Consumer discretionary+2.3%+11.5%−8.8%
Consumer staples+7.4%+2.1%+3.9%
Health care+3.3%+0.6%+6.9%
Financials+13.9%+3.1%+6.8%
Industrials+17.7%+3.4%+5.5%
Materials+13.2%+6.7%−0.3%
Energy+54.6%−37.2%+7.1%
Utilities+1.1%+7.8%−1.4%
Real estate−5.0%+1.4%−8.2%
About this exhibit
Median gap to the five-year average in each regime, by sector
%, the median over the months each of the four regimes held since Jan 2017; the regime of a month is the vote's in the week of the report.
A description of what has happened, not a signal: the months of each regime are few, and a sector's gap drifts with its own earnings cycle. No month since Jan 2017 fell in bonds and the dollar hedge.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; the four-regime vote (Regime page); Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-7

Every sector's gap to normal, and the index's multiple against its averages

The gap to the five-year average for all eleven sectors, and the index's forward P/E with its five- and ten-year averages

Exhibit 9 · Forward P/E against its own five-year average for all eleven sectors

%, monthly, Jan 2017 to Nov 2026; a month whose average FactSet took over months it printed as not meaningful is left out.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-5

Exhibit 10 · Forward P/E of the S&P 500 with its five- and ten-year averages

Forward 12-month P/E and FactSet's five- and ten-year averages of it, monthly, Jan 2017 to Nov 2026.
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-3

Exhibit 11 · Forward P/E against its normal level by basket, quarterly since 2017

About this exhibit
%, quarter-ends from Dec 2017 to 13 Nov 2026; below zero, the multiple is under the basket's normal level (the canvas model's). History before 13 Nov 2026 is estimated.
Source: Yahoo Finance consensus, 13 Nov 2026; SEC EDGAR; State Street; FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculationssectors.multiple-12

Exhibit 12 · S&P 500 justified forward P/E from the canvas's inputs to the Valuation page's, one input at a time

InputsCost of equityGrowthJustified P/E
The canvas's inputs9.29%10.9%20.3×
The 10-year at the Valuation page's 5.15%9.56%10.9%19.3×
Damodaran's premium, 4.20%9.35%10.9%20.1×
The yield-gap premium, 5.16%10.31%10.9%16.8×
The yield-gap premium with the site's growth of 5.8%10.31%5.8%13.7×
The implied premium, 3.38%, with consensus growth8.53%15.1%29.2×
The implied premium with the canvas's growth8.53%10.9%23.9×
The implied premium with the site's growth of 5.8%8.53%5.8%18.9×
About this exhibit
Cost of equity and five-year growth (%), and the justified multiple (×), on the canvas's DCF. The two pages differ by the premium and by growth, not by the model.
Model-conditional: each row changes one input of the canvas's discounted-payout model and reports the multiple it justifies.
Source: Yahoo Finance consensus, 13 Nov 2026; SEC EDGAR; State Street; FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculationssectors.multiple-13

Appendix

Where the figures come from, how they were read, and what the rule asks67 checks, all pass
About this page

How far each sector's forward P/E sits from its own five- and ten-year averages, as FactSet prints them each week, one report a month since January 2017, and what each basket's price assumes about growth. A gap earns a reading only where the normal level passes the stability rule the Fair value board applies. The baskets (tech, semis, growth, the S&P 500, value, staples) are the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026.

Exhibit 13 · Definitions

  • Source
    FactSet's figures, read from its chart.

    FactSet's weekly Earnings Insight prints a chart of each sector's forward 12-month P/E beside its 5-year and 10-year averages. One report a month since January 2017 was read from that chart: the printed labels by text recognition and the bars by their height, a figure kept where the two agree to 0.1, taken from the bar where the label is unreadable, and left empty where neither reads (24 bar, 4 clipped, 8 digitfix, 7 none, 1337 ocr+bar rows). A bar read alone at the chart's ceiling (31.1×) is a clipped bar, not a reading, and is left out. The file is maintained a month at a time and refused if changed after it was staged.

  • Normal
    The sector's own five-year average.

    The normal level of a sector's multiple is its own 5-year average as FactSet prints it; the gap is the forward P/E over that average, less one. FactSet's averages are of its weekly readings, so they are copied, not recomputed from the monthly file.

  • Rule
    When a gap earns a reading.

    A normal earns a reading only if it passes the stability rule the Fair value board applies: regress the log forward P/E on the log 5-year average with Newey–West errors (12 lags); the slope must be positive with |t| of 2 or more and keep its sign in both halves; and the normal, re-estimated each month on the data to that month from the 36th on, must beat the random walk as a 12-month target. A sector that fails prints its gap with a fail badge and no direction.

  • Scope
    Sectors from FactSet; baskets from the canvas run.

    Growth, value and semiconductors are not FactSet sectors. The six baskets (tech, semis, growth, the S&P 500, value and staples) are the earnings-stretch canvas run's of 13 Nov 2026, on each S&P 500 member's consensus that day, published as they are under the author's decision of 18 Nov 2026; they do not move from one update to the next until consensus is read again.

  • Baskets
    The baskets' normal level and priced growth.

    A basket's normal level is the multiple it has held since 2017 after allowing for the regime, from the canvas's model of the six baskets' quarterly history: not FactSet's five-year average. It is tested on that history's quarter-ends from Q3 2021, so a basket can pass where the FactSet sector of the same name does not. The growth the price assumes is the five-year EPS growth that returns today's forward P/E at one cost of equity (9.29%); the premium the price implies holds growth at the model's figure and solves for the return, less the 10-year of 5.15%.

  • Licence
    Whose numbers these are.

    FactSet's figures are shown with their attribution, as the site shows FactSet quotes elsewhere; the gaps and the rule are computed here.

Source: FactSet Earnings Insight; Macro Review calculations · data to Nov 2026sectors.multiple-6

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.