The growth fund has run 61% ahead of the value fund since January 2017
Is growth dear against value, and has the market paid for beta while the ratio moved?
In brief
The growth fund's price against the value fund's, technology's multiple against staples', and the reward for beta- The growth fund's total return has run 60.8% ahead of the value fund's since January 2017.→ Exhibit 1
- Over the last 13 weeks growth lost 8.4% against value.→ Exhibit 1
- Technology's forward P/E was 0.76× staples' in Nov 2026, the lowest ratio of any month since 2017.→ Exhibit 3
- Since 2014 the ratio's 13-week change has not tracked the reward for beta: their correlation is 0.00.→ Exhibit 4
- Growth's forward P/E was 1.08 times value's in Nov 2026, against a 2017–26 average of 1.39.→ Exhibit 2
| What would change this view | Trigger | Today | Decided by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Growth gains on value again | the growth-to-value ratio's 13-week change above zero | −8.4% (13 Nov 2026)not crossed | the next Friday close |
| Technology's multiple back at its usual ratio to staples' | technology's forward P/E over staples' at or above its 2017–26 median of 1.13× | 0.76× (Nov 2026)not crossed | the next FactSet report added to the import |
| Growth's multiple back at its usual ratio to value's | growth's forward P/E over value's at or above its 2017–26 average of 1.39× | 1.08× (13 Nov 2026)not crossed | the next consensus read for the baskets |
| Beta pays again | the reward for beta at 63 sessions above zero | −8.3pp (13 Nov 2026)not crossed | the next Friday on Risk sentiment |
The reasoning behind each point
- RatioThe growth fund's total return has run 60.8% ahead of the value fund's since January 2017.
On 13 Nov 2026 the price ratio sat at the 92nd percentile of the weeks since October 2000.
- LatelyOver the last 13 weeks growth lost 8.4% against value.
Over 52 weeks the change is −6.3%; the ratio is 13.5% below its peak of 6 Oct 2000.
- MultipleTechnology's forward P/E was 0.76× staples' in Nov 2026, the lowest ratio of any month since 2017.
The 2017–26 median is 1.13×. FactSet's figures put technology at 18.0× and staples at 23.7× forward earnings.
- BetaSince 2014 the ratio's 13-week change has not tracked the reward for beta: their correlation is 0.00.
The reward for beta at 63 sessions was −8.3pp on 13 Nov 2026. A description of what has happened, not a signal.
- BasketsGrowth's forward P/E was 1.08 times value's in Nov 2026, against a 2017–26 average of 1.39.
Only 2% of months since 2017 sat lower; the figures are the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026, history estimated.
Next: Method and record — how far each basket model is trusted
Growth against value in price and in multiple, and technology against staples
Growth's forward P/E over value's since 2017, the growth-to-value price ratio since 2000, and technology's forward P/E over staples'Exhibit 2 · Growth's forward P/E was 1.08 times value's in Nov 2026
About this exhibit
Exhibit 1 · Over the last 13 weeks growth lost 8.4% against value
About this exhibit
Exhibit 3 · Technology's forward P/E was 0.76× staples' in Nov 2026
About this exhibit
The ratio's 13-week change beside the reward for beta
Whether growth gained on value in the weeks the market paid for beta, Friday by Friday since 2014Exhibit 4 · Since 2014 the ratio's 13-week change has not tracked the reward for beta: their correlation is 0.00.
About this exhibit
Exhibit 5 · Reward for beta across the S&P 500's members at 63 sessions, weekly since 2014
Each reading against its range, and technology's price against staples'
Each ratio today against its range, and technology's price against staples' since 2000
Exhibit 6 · Each growth-against-value reading against its range
| Reading | Today | Against its range |
|---|---|---|
| Growth over value, price ratio (100 in Jan 2017) | 160.8 | 92th percentile since 2000; 80th since 2017 |
| Growth over value, 13-week change | −8.4% | 52 weeks −6.3%; 13.5% below the peak of 6 Oct 2000 |
| Technology over staples, price ratio (100 in Jan 2017) | 330.4 | 97th percentile since 2000 |
| Technology's forward P/E over staples' | 0.76× | 2017–26 median 1.13×, range 0.76× to 1.54×; 1th percentile |
| Reward for beta, 63 sessions | −8.3pp | 13 Nov 2026, copied from Risk sentiment |
| Correlation of the 13-week change with the reward for beta | 0.00 | 672 Fridays since 2014 |
Exhibit 7 · Price of the technology fund against the consumer staples fund, total return, weekly
Exhibit 8 · Price change of the growth and value baskets since each date, split into earnings, the multiple and membership
| Since | Basket | Price | Forward EPS | Multiple | Membership | Forward P/E, then → now |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31 Jan 2017 | Growth | +378.7% | +618.5% | +6.9% | +60.5% | 17.9× → 19.2× |
| 31 Jan 2017 | Value | +133.5% | +116.0% | +9.1% | +1.0% | 16.1× → 17.6× |
| 30 Sept 2025 | Growth | +6.3% | +62.6% | −32.9% | +2.6% | 28.6× → 19.2× |
| 30 Sept 2025 | Value | +20.0% | +25.4% | −3.7% | +0.6% | 18.3× → 17.6× |
| 31 Dec 2025 | Growth | +5.0% | +55.0% | −30.5% | +2.6% | 27.6× → 19.2× |
| 31 Dec 2025 | Value | +16.1% | +20.7% | −3.4% | +0.4% | 18.2× → 17.6× |
| 31 Aug 2026 | Growth | −6.0% | +4.4% | −10.1% | ±0.0% | 21.3× → 19.2× |
| 31 Aug 2026 | Value | +2.9% | +2.5% | +0.6% | +0.2% | 17.5× → 17.6× |
Exhibit 9 · Tech's forward P/E over staples', annual, 2007 to 2016
| Year | Tech ÷ staples |
|---|---|
| 2007 | 1.08× |
| 2008 | 1.04× |
| 2009 | 1.15× |
| 2010 | 0.97× |
| 2011 | 0.85× |
| 2012 | 0.79× |
| 2013 | 0.79× |
| 2014 | 0.83× |
| 2015 | 0.79× |
| 2016 | 0.80× |
Exhibit 10 · Growth's forward P/E over value's a year ahead, on each P/E level the model carries
About this exhibit
Appendix
Where the prices and multiples come from, and what the page cannot show yet14 checks, all pass
Growth's forward P/E against value's since 2017, the S&P 500 growth fund's price against the value fund's since 2000, technology's forward P/E against consumer staples', and the ratio beside the market's reward for beta. The baskets' multiples are the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026, with the history before it estimated.
Exhibit 11 · Definitions
- PricesTotal-return ratios of the funds.
Adjusted closes from Yahoo Finance for SPYG (the S&P 500 growth fund), SPYV (value), XLK (technology) and XLP (staples): the last close of each week, dated its Friday, counting only sessions that had closed when the prices were read. The adjusted close carries dividends, so each ratio is one fund's total return against the other's.
- MultipleFactSet's sector figures.
Technology's and staples' forward 12-month P/E as FactSet prints them in its weekly Earnings Insight, one report a month since January 2017, read from the report's chart (the import Sector valuation reads). The ratio is the first over the second.
- BetaThe reward for beta, copied.
The reward for beta is the slope of 63-session excess returns on beta across the S&P 500's members, as the Risk sentiment page computes it each Friday; it is copied, not recomputed. The correlation is over the Fridays both series have since 2014.
- BasketsGrowth's multiple against value's.
Growth's and value's forward P/E are the S&P 500 growth and value baskets' own, from the earnings-stretch canvas run of 13 Nov 2026: consensus on that day, and before it a reconstruction from the members' filings scaled to FactSet's sector figures, published as it is under the author's decision of 18 Nov 2026. On the consensus of 13 Nov the two baskets' forward P/E are 18.4× and 18.0×, a ratio of 1.03, the figures Sector valuation prints; the month-end reconstruction behind the chart puts the ratio where the chart shows it.
- AheadThe ratio a year ahead.
Model-conditional: the ratio a year ahead on each P/E level is the spread of the canvas simulation's paths, with no record yet; it sits in a fold until it is scored.
- LicenceWhose numbers these are.
Prices and multiples are shown with their attribution; the ratios and the correlation are computed here.
How the numbers are made
Yahoo Finance prices ──▶ SPYG, SPYV, XLK and XLP's adjusted closes read for the sessions that had closed; Friday closes from October 2000 ──▶ the weekly closes the weekly closes ──▶ growth over value and tech over staples as price ratios, 100 on the first Friday of 2017; the 13-week change of the first ──▶ the price ratios factset_sector_pe ──▶ the monthly file checked against its manifest's SHA-256; technology's forward P/E over staples', one report a month since January 2017 ──▶ the multiple ratio the price ratios + The reward for beta ──▶ the ratio's 13-week change beside the reward for beta at 63 sessions, Friday by Friday since 2014, and their correlation ──▶ the ratio beside the reward for beta canvas_baskets + Yahoo Finance consensus + SEC EDGAR company facts ──▶ the canvas run of 13 Nov 2026, checked against its SHA-256 manifest: growth's and value's forward P/E, monthly since 2017, their ratio, the ratio a year ahead on each P/E level, and the price change split into earnings and the multiple ──▶ the baskets' ratio the price ratios + the multiple ratio + the ratio beside the reward for beta + the baskets' ratio ──▶ tiles, takeaways, falsifier rows and section titles generated from the numbers ──▶ the page
Sources
- licensedYahoo Finance prices
Source: Yahoo Finance (daily adjusted closes of SPYG, SPYV, XLK and XLP) · https://finance.yahoo.com
- licensedFactSet Earnings Insight: forward 12-month P/E by sector (monthly, read from the report's chart)
Source: FactSet Earnings Insight · https://insight.factset.com/topic/earnings
- licensedYahoo Finance consensus
Source: Yahoo Finance analyst estimates for each S&P 500 member, read on 13 Nov 2026 · https://finance.yahoo.com
- publicSEC EDGAR company facts
Source: SEC EDGAR, the members' filed EPS · https://www.sec.gov/edgar
- computed hereThe reward for beta
The reward for beta: the slope of 63-session excess returns on beta across the S&P 500's members, computed by the site's engine on the Risk sentiment page
Pages this one copies from
| Page | Title | Updated | Data to | Arrays | Values | Source checks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risk sentiment | Risk sentiment: the cross-sectional line | 2026-11-17 | 13 Nov 2026 | 1 | 0 | 112 pass |
Reproduction checks
| Check | Published | Computed | Tolerance | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Both style funds have a Friday close in every week from 6 Oct 2000 (weeks missing one) | 0 | 0 | 0 | pass |
| The growth-to-value ratio on 13 Nov 2026 = 100 × (SPYG ÷ SPYV) ÷ (SPYG ÷ SPYV on 6 Jan 2017) | 160.8248 | 160.8248 | 0 | pass |
| The 13-week change = the ratio over its value 13 Fridays earlier, less one (%) | -8.4221 | -8.4221 | 0 | pass |
| The FactSet sector file's SHA-256 equals its manifest's (2026-11-13; files that differ) | 0 | 0 | 0 | pass |
| Bars read alone at the chart's ceiling (31.1×) are left out, not replaced (cells left out) | 4 | 4 | 0 | pass |
| Technology over staples in Nov 2026 = FactSet's two forward P/Es divided | 0.7595 | 0.7595 | 0 | pass |
| Technology and staples both have a forward P/E in every monthly report since Jan 2017 but the 2 with a cell left out (technology Nov 2018, staples Feb 2020; reports missing one otherwise) | 2 | 2 | 0 | pass |
| The correlation is over the Fridays both series have since 3 Jan 2014 (weeks counted twice or missed) | 672 | 672 | 0 | pass |
| Every file of the canvas import of 2026-11-13 has its manifest's SHA-256 (17 files; files that differ) | 0 | 0 | 0 | pass |
| Growth's and value's forward P/E histories cover the same months as the other baskets' (months) | 119 | 119 | 0 | pass |
| The Risk sentiment page: the source page is published with all its checks passing (dated 17 Nov 2026, 112 checks) | 1 | 1 | 0 | pass |
| The Risk sentiment page: the site still serves the page this one copied (dated 17 Nov 2026) | 1 | 1 | 0 | pass |
| The Risk sentiment page: every copied observation equals the source page, matched by date (672 values in 1 arrays; mismatches) | 0 | 0 | 0 | pass |
| Decisions: every desk decision this page's specification names is in the decisions file (D-2026-11-17-OR16; ids missing) | 0 | 0 | 0 | pass |
- Yahoo Finance prices — Source: Yahoo Finance (daily adjusted closes of SPYG, SPYV, XLK and XLP)
- FactSet Earnings Insight: forward 12-month P/E by sector (monthly, read from the report's chart) — Source: FactSet Earnings Insight
- Yahoo Finance consensus — Source: Yahoo Finance analyst estimates for each S&P 500 member, read on 13 Nov 2026
- SEC EDGAR company facts — Source: SEC EDGAR, the members' filed EPS
- The reward for beta — The reward for beta: the slope of 63-session excess returns on beta across the S&P 500's members, computed by the site's engine on the Risk sentiment page