Macro ReviewHow to read
Cross Asset · Fair value · Statements value

On its own statements, today's index price implies a 1.84pp premium

What is the index worth on its own projected statements, and what premium does today's price imply?

Statements filed to 16 Nov 2026Updated 17 Nov 2026
Implied premium, the index's own statements+1.84ppthree forms agree · 10-year 5.12% · 16 Nov 2026
Value at the −52.8%3,499 against 7,417 · +5.17pp · 16 Nov 2026
The page's two-stage premium+3.50pp−1.66pp to the statements' · 16 Nov 2026
Damodaran's implied premium+4.20pphis growth 14.6% for five years · 1 Oct 2026
Forward P/E on the base23.8×FactSet 19.0× on operating · 2 Oct 2026
Justified forward P/E, long-run state27.2×at the implied rate · observed 23.8× · 16 Nov 2026

In brief

The premium today's price implies when the index's own statements are carried forward and discounted, and the value at the site's premium bases
  • On the index's own statements, today's price implies a premium of 1.84pp over the 10-year Treasury.→ Exhibit 1
  • At the page's of 5.17pp, the statements value the index 53% below its price.→ Exhibit 3
  • Damodaran's 4.20% premium assumes earnings grow 14.6% a year for five years; the base's grow far less.→ Exhibit 1
  • Shares retired at the market price rather than their value move the per-share premium by +0.48pp.→ Exhibit 1
  • Of the 1.66pp between the page's two-stage premium and the statements', the largest step is payout on the index basis, −0.96pp.→ Exhibit 4
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
Trailing earnings for Q3 2026 leave the base's one-quarter 80% bandbelow $296.31 or above $321.87$292.58 · Q2 2026pendingthe members' Q3 2026 filings
The premium the statements imply climbs halfway to the yield-gap premiumimplied premium > 3.50pp1.84pp (16 Nov 2026)not crossedeach close and Treasury close
The price falls to the statements' value at the yield-gap premiumS&P 500 ≤ 3,4997,417 (16 Nov 2026)not crossedeach close
The reasoning behind each point
  • Implied
    On the index's own statements, today's price implies a premium of 1.84pp over the 10-year Treasury.

    The dividend discount model per share, the total-equity cash flows and residual income all return the S&P 500's close of 7,416.59 on 16 Nov 2026 at one discount rate, 6.96%: the 10-year at 5.12% plus 1.84pp. The path is the earnings base's — trailing earnings of $292.58 per index unit in Q2 2026, a margin that reverts toward its mean, payout rising to 79% of earnings — then growth of 4.0% a year for ever. Model-conditional: the premium these statements and this price imply, not a forecast of returns.

  • Basis
    At the page's yield-gap premium of 5.17pp, the statements value the index 53% below its price.

    Discounted at 10.29% the base's cash flows are worth 3,499 index points against a close of 7,417. The two-stage model above, on its own inputs, puts the value at 4,338 at the same premium (−41.5%). At the Full-history premium of 6.64pp the statements' value is 2,842 (−61.7%). At the Yield-gap, apart months premium of 6.79pp the statements' value is 2,787 (−62.4%). At the Damodaran premium of 4.20pp the statements' value is 4,133 (−44.3%).

  • Damodaran
    Damodaran's 4.20% premium assumes earnings grow 14.6% a year for five years; the base's grow far less.

    His figure for 1 Oct 2026 (reproduced here from his calculator's inputs) starts from the trailing cash returned, $198.17, grows earnings at the analysts' five-year rate and lets growth fall to the 10-year after; with sustainable payout it is 4.20% over his 10-year of 5.29%. The base starts from the cash on SPY's basis but carries the margin back toward its mean, so its net income grows +1.6% a year over the next two. At his premium over this page's 10-year the statements' value is 4,133 (−44.3%).

  • Spread
    Shares retired at the market price rather than their value move the per-share premium by +0.48pp.

    The per-share dividend model on the base's own share path — repurchases at the market value its constant multiple implies, and its measured non-cash dilution — implies 2.32pp; at value the three forms agree at 1.84pp. After year ten its dividend per share grows 6.18% a year, against 5.69% when shares are retired at value.

  • Bridge
    Of the 1.66pp between the page's two-stage premium and the statements', the largest step is payout on the index basis, −0.96pp.

    Earnings on the index basis: −0.05pp. Payout on the index basis: −0.96pp. Net of the shares issued: −0.12pp. The same growth for the whole equity: −0.08pp. The base's near-term growth: −0.95pp. The whole path in place of the two-stage shortcut: +0.49pp. The steps are taken in this order and add to the whole move; each changes one input of the two-stage identity, and the last replaces the identity with the whole path.

  • Multiples
    The base's next four quarters put the index at 23.8× forward earnings, against 27.2× that its long-run state justifies at the same rate.

    Trailing, the index trades at 25.3× earnings and 5.57× book on SPY's basis. At the implied rate the long-run state — return on equity 18.8% on opening book, growth 4.0%, 80.3% of earnings paid out net of issuance — justifies 27.2× forward earnings and 5.11× book. FactSet's consensus forward multiple, on operating earnings, was 19.0× on 2 Oct 2026. S&P's operating earnings ran 8.5% above as-reported in the four quarters to 2025Q3.

Next: Fair value board — the same question for every asset

Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculations · data to 16 Nov 2026cross.index_value-read

On the index's own statements, the premium the price implies

: the dividend discount model per share, the total-equity cash flows and residual income on the earnings base's path, at today's price and at the page's premium bases, beside Damodaran's premium

Exhibit 1 · The premium the latest price implies, by valuation method

Premium, pp, over the 10-year (5.12%), and discount rate that return the close, 16 Nov 2026, for each method; model-conditional.
Range: other modelsAbout
FormDiscount ratePremium over the 10-yearWhat it discounts
Total-equity cash flows6.96%+1.84ppevery flow to the equity: dividends + buybacks − issuance
Dividends per share, repurchases at value6.96%+1.84ppper share, the shares retired at what they are worth
Residual income6.96%+1.84ppbook plus the earnings above the charge on it (comprehensive income)
Dividends per share, repurchases at the market price7.44%+2.32ppper share, on the base's own share path
The Valuation page's two-stage model8.62%+3.50pppayout 84.5% of as-reported earnings (S&P Dow Jones Indices), Shiller's E₀, consensus near-term growth 15.1% a share
Damodaran, 1 Oct 20269.49%+4.20pphis calculator: trailing cash $198.17 grown 14.6% for five years, then the 10-year (5.29%) — past its age

Per-share dividends at the market price grow 6.18% a year after year ten, against 5.69% when shares are retired at value: the buyback-price spread is +0.48pp.

About this exhibit
Table: the discount rate and premium over the 10-year that each valuation method needs to return the close, from the three statement-based forms to the two-stage model and Damodaran.
The premium today's price implies, three ways
At the S&P 500's close of 7,416.59 on 16 Nov 2026 and the 10-year at 5.12%: the discount rate each form needs to return the price, less the 10-year.
Model-conditional: the earnings base's statements carried forward — eight quarters, a fade to year ten, growth of 4.0% a year after — valued three ways at the rate that returns the price. At value the three agree to the solver's tolerance; buying shares back at the market price instead moves the per-share model.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-2

Exhibit 2 · Index value from projected statements at each equity risk premium

Index points per unit on 16 Nov 2026, at each premium over the 10-year; the close, the implied premium and the page's bases marked.
Range: assumed values
About this exhibit
Two curves: the statement-based value in index points at each premium over the 10-year, for total-equity cash flows and per-share dividends at the market price; the close, the implied premium and the page's bases marked.
The statements' value against the premium
Index points per unit on 16 Nov 2026, at each premium over the 10-year; the close, the implied premium and the page's bases marked.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-3

Exhibit 3 · Projected-statement value and gap to the price, by premium basis

Discount rate = the 10-year (5.12%, 16 Nov 2026) + each basis's premium; the gap is to the close of 7,417.
Range: other models
BasisPremiumDiscount rateThe statements' valueGap to the priceThe two-stage model abovePer share, market price
Yield-gap premium (the page's headline)+5.17pp10.29%3,499−52.8%4,338 (−41.5%)2,273
Full-history median, as a distance+6.64pp11.76%2,842−61.7%3,516 (−52.6%)1,674
Yield-gap premium, months when stocks and bonds moved apart+6.79pp11.91%2,787−62.4%3,448 (−53.5%)1,629
Damodaran's implied premium, 1 Oct 2026+4.20pp9.32%4,133−44.3%–2,975

The two-stage column is the Valuation page's own value at the same premium, on its inputs: payout, earnings and growth on another basis — the bridge below takes the one to the other.

About this exhibit
Table by premium basis: premium, discount rate, statement-based value, gap to the price, the two-stage model's value and the per-share value at the market price.
The statements' value at each premium basis
Discount rate = the 10-year (5.12%, 16 Nov 2026) + each basis's premium; the gap is to the close of 7,417.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-4

From the Valuation page's two-stage premium to the statements', one basis at a time

: the earnings, the payout and the growth on one basis, then the whole path in place of the two-stage shortcut; the multiples the long-run state justifies beside the observed

Exhibit 4 · Implied premium from the two-stage model to the statements, step by step

Each row changes one input of the two-stage identity and re-solves the premium, pp, at 16 Nov 2026; the last row uses the statement path.
Range: other modelsAbout
StepPayout kE₀ ÷ PNear-term growthPremiumChangeWhat changes
The Valuation page's two-stage premium84.5%3.98%+15.1%+3.50pp–payout 84.5% of as-reported earnings (S&P Dow Jones Indices), Shiller's E₀, consensus near-term growth 15.1% a share
Earnings on the index basis84.5%3.94%+15.1%+3.46pp−0.05ppE₀ = the base's trailing $292.58 per index unit (Q2 2026, the four quarters filed) over the close
Payout on the index basis66.8%3.94%+15.1%+2.50pp−0.96ppdividends + buybacks ÷ earnings on the index basis, 66.8%
Net of the shares issued64.5%3.94%+15.1%+2.38pp−0.12ppless issuance, 64.5% — the cash that leaves the equity
The same growth for the whole equity64.5%3.94%+14.1%+2.30pp−0.08ppconsensus 15.1% a share less the share-count effect of 1.03%, 14.1% for the aggregate
The base's near-term growth64.5%3.94%+1.6%+1.35pp−0.95ppthe base's net income over its eight quarters, +1.6% a year, in place of the consensus
The whole path in place of the two-stage shortcut––the path+1.84pp+0.49ppthe base's eight quarters and ten years, its long-run state after; the three forms agree
Dividends per share at the market price+2.32pp–the base's own share path: repurchases at its constant-multiple market value, and its measured non-cash dilution
The page's convention on the index basis+2.50pp–the gross payout held, growth per share: dividends and buybacks counted as cash and again as the growth they buy
About this exhibit
Bridge table: the implied premium re-solved as each input of the two-stage model moves to the index basis, ending with the whole statement path.
From the two-stage premium to the statements', step by step
Each row changes one input of P = k·E₀·[(1 + g_L) + H(g_S − g_L)] ÷ (r − g_L) and solves for the premium; the last replaces the identity with the whole path. In this order the steps add to the whole move.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-5

Exhibit 5 · The index's multiples observed and justified by its long-run state

Price ÷ trailing earnings, ÷ forward four-quarter earnings and ÷ book (×), SPY's basis, 16 Nov 2026; justified at the rates the price and yield gap imply (6.96%, 10.29%).
Range: other models
MultipleObservedJustified, implied rateJustified, yield-gap premiumBasis
Price ÷ trailing earnings25.3×28.2×13.3×the four quarters filed to Q2 2026
Price ÷ the next four quarters' earnings23.8×27.2×12.8×the base's, $311.28 — model-conditional
Price ÷ book value5.57×5.11×2.40×book per unit $1,331, Q2 2026

Yields on the trailing four quarters: dividends 1.08%, buybacks 1.56%, all cash to the equity net of issuance 2.55%. The long-run state: return on equity 18.8% on opening book (19.1% on comprehensive income), 80.3% of earnings paid out net of issuance. FactSet's consensus forward P/E, on operating earnings, 19.0× on 2 Oct 2026 (past its age). S&P's operating earnings ran 8.5% above as-reported in the four quarters to 2025Q3 (release of 18 Dec 2025): the gap between the two bases.

About this exhibit
Table: price to trailing earnings, to next four quarters' earnings and to book, observed and justified by the long-run state at the implied rate and at the yield-gap premium.
The multiples observed, and what the long-run state justifies
SPY's basis on 16 Nov 2026. Justified: the long-run state's k ÷ (r − g) and (ROE − g) ÷ (r − g), at the rate the price implies (6.96%) and at the yield-gap premium's (10.29%).
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-6

Exhibit 6 · The index's multiple since 2020, against its justified level

Each quarter's close over trailing earnings or book (×) on SPY's basis, to Q2 2026, and the long-run state's justified level at the implied rate.
About this exhibit
Quarterly line since 2020: price ÷ trailing earnings on SPY's basis (a selector shows price ÷ book), with the justified level at the implied rate dashed.
The index basis's multiples since 2020
Each quarter's close over trailing earnings or book on SPY's basis (the Profitability page's), and the long-run state's justified level at the implied rate.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-7

The index value's sensitivities, alternatives and cash flows

The value by and long-run growth, and by long-run return on equity and payout; the base's named alternatives valued; Damodaran's figure month by month; every flow the forms discount

Exhibit 7 · Projected-statement value's gap to the price, by discount rate and growth

Gap to the close, %, 16 Nov 2026: the path re-run at each long-run growth rate and valued at each discount rate; last row, implied rate.
Range: assumed values
Discount rate \ g_L3.0%3.5%4.0%4.5%5.0%
6.00%+8%+24%+48%+87%+166%
7.00%−19%−11%−1%+13%+34%
8.00%−35%−31%−26%−19%−10%
9.00%−46%−44%−41%−37%−33%
10.00%−54%−52%−51%−48%−46%
11.00%−60%−59%−58%−56%−55%
6.96% (implied)−18%−10%±0%+15%+37%
About this exhibit
Grid: the projected-statement value's gap to the close, %, by discount rate and long-run growth.
The gap to the price by discount rate and long-run growth
The base re-run at each long-run growth rate (the fade's target) and valued at each rate; the last row is the rate the price implies. Percent of the close.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-8

Exhibit 8 · Projected-statement gap to the price, by return on equity and payout

Gap to the close, %, 16 Nov 2026, at the implied rate of 6.96%; growth follows as return on equity × retention, printed under each gap.
Range: assumed values
ROE* \ k*70.0%75.0%78.7%82.0%85.0%
14.0%−9%
g 4.2%
−21%
g 3.5%
−28%
g 3.0%
−32%
g 2.5%
−36%
g 2.1%
16.0%+17%
g 4.8%
−7%
g 4.0%
−17%
g 3.4%
−24%
g 2.9%
−29%
g 2.4%
18.8%+89%
g 5.6%
+22%
g 4.7%
±0%
g 4.0%
−12%
g 3.4%
−20%
g 2.8%
21.0%+268%
g 6.3%
+59%
g 5.3%
+18%
g 4.5%
−1%
g 3.8%
−13%
g 3.2%
24.0%–
g 7.2%
+175%
g 6.0%
+56%
g 5.1%
+18%
g 4.3%
−1%
g 3.6%
About this exhibit
Grid at the implied rate: the projected-statement value's gap to the close by long-run return on equity and payout, with the growth each pair implies.
The gap to the price by long-run return on equity and payout
At the rate the price implies (6.96%), the base re-run with each long-run return on equity and payout; growth follows, g_L = ROE* × (1 − k*), printed under each gap. Empty where growth reaches the rate.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-9

Exhibit 9 · Implied premium and gap under each alternative earnings path

Each alternative earnings path, valued at 16 Nov 2026: the premium the price implies, pp, and its gap at the premium the yield gap implies, %.
Range: assumed values
RunEPS, year 10Implied premiumGap at the yield-gap premium
The base$460.71+1.84pp−52.8%
μ at the 2017–19 mean$414.95+1.55pp−56.6%
μ at the mean since 2021$488.20+2.01pp−50.6%
ROE* at the 2017–19 level$440.36+1.64pp−57.0%
ROE* at today's$486.72+2.09pp−47.7%
The market value at a constant price$467.16+1.84pp−52.8%
A five-year fade$442.55+1.74pp−53.9%
The margin fitted with the pandemic's quarters in$438.98+1.70pp−54.8%
The start at the filed margin, not the filtered$462.74+1.86pp−52.2%
About this exhibit
Table: each alternative run of the Earnings outlook's earnings path, with its tenth-year EPS, the premium the price implies on it, and its gap at the yield-gap premium.
The base's named alternatives, valued
Each of the Earnings outlook's alternative runs re-run here and valued: the premium the price implies on it, and its gap at the yield-gap premium.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-10

Exhibit 10 · Damodaran's implied premium reproduced and read year by year

His premium, %, for 1 Oct 2026, reproduced from his calculator's inputs; then the plain two-stage model on his monthly file's columns, year by year.
Implied premium, sustainable payout (his headline)4.20%reproduced: 4.205%
Implied premium, trailing cash yield3.70%his goal seek: 3.698%
His inputsthe index 7,651.54; trailing cash $198.17; growth 14.59% for five years; 10-year 5.29%
This page's value at his premium4,133−44.3% to the close, on the base's statements and this page's 10-year
Year200920102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
Months within 5bp12/1210/1212/1212/1212/1212/1211/129/1211/1212/1211/1211/1212/120/120/120/110/123/10

The monthly file carries the index, the trailing cash flow, the growth and the 10-year, not the estimate of base-year earnings his calculator has grown since 2022, nor its timing of the first year: the plain model on its columns is a reading of his figure, and the calculator, formula for formula, is the reproduction.

About this exhibit
Two tables: Damodaran's latest calculator reproduced from his inputs, and the plain two-stage model on his monthly file's columns by year.
Damodaran's implied premium, on his own inputs
His figure for 1 Oct 2026, reproduced from the inputs of his calculator for the month; the plain two-stage model on his monthly file's columns, a reading by year.
Source: Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-11

Exhibit 11 · The cash flows every form discounts

Projected flows, $ per index unit, from Q4 2026 quarterly then by year to June; each at its period's end; the earnings path's share count.
Period toYears outDividendsBuybacksIssuanceCash to equityNet incomeResidualBookShares
Q4 20260.12$21.33$31.10$3.00$49.43$77.85$1.03$1,390.70.9918
Q1 20270.37$21.98$30.87$3.13$49.72$76.78$1.05$1,418.80.9880
Q2 20270.62$22.61$30.78$3.14$50.25$76.08$1.07$1,445.70.9843
Q3 20270.87$23.21$30.81$2.99$51.03$75.68$1.09$1,471.50.9803
Q4 20271.12$23.80$30.95$2.98$51.76$75.53$1.11$1,496.30.9764
Q1 20281.37$24.37$31.10$2.95$52.51$75.45$1.13$1,520.40.9724
Q2 20281.62$24.92$31.34$2.94$53.32$75.55$1.15$1,543.80.9684
Year to 30 Jun 20292.62$93.69$179.40$11.74$261.34$291.07$4.67$1,578.20.9456
Year to 30 Jun 20303.62$96.70$156.40$11.31$241.79$297.44$4.77$1,638.60.9254
Year to 30 Jun 20314.62$101.37$151.60$11.56$241.41$308.72$4.96$1,710.90.9066
Year to 30 Jun 20325.62$106.85$155.11$12.00$249.96$322.21$5.18$1,788.30.8885
Year to 30 Jun 20336.62$112.74$162.58$12.52$262.79$336.67$5.41$1,867.60.8706
Year to 30 Jun 20347.62$118.83$171.97$13.08$277.72$351.46$5.65$1,947.00.8530
Year to 30 Jun 20358.62$125.03$182.15$13.66$293.52$366.27$5.89$2,025.60.8354
Year to 30 Jun 20369.62$131.27$188.99$14.23$306.02$380.92$6.13$2,106.60.8182
The year after, then 4.0% a year+1$136.52$196.55$14.80$318.26$396.15$6.37$2,190.90.8014

On the valuation date the book is $1,361.2 and the share count 0.9958 — the base's after the quarters already past.

About this exhibit
Table of projected dividends, buybacks, issuance, cash to equity, net income, residual income, book and shares by period.
The cash flows every form discounts
Per index unit at the start; each flow at its period's end, the years out from the valuation date. The share count is the base's.
Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-12

Appendix

How the three forms rest on one path, why they agree at value and differ at the market price, and every source67 checks, all pass
About this page

The S&P 500 valued the way an analyst values one company. Its own statements are carried forward — revenue, a margin that reverts toward its mean, payout and the share count — then discounted. Three forms agree at value; the page solves for the premium today's price implies and values the index at each premium basis the Valuation page uses. Model-conditional: a present value on stated inputs, not a forecast.

Three forms on one path

V0=∑tDt+BBt−ISSt(1+r)τt+CFn+1(r−gL) (1+r)τn,v0DCF=V0/N0V_0 = \sum_t \frac{D_t + BB_t - ISS_t}{(1+r)^{\tau_t}} + \frac{CF_{n+1}}{(r-g_L)\,(1+r)^{\tau_n}}, \qquad v^{DCF}_0 = V_0 / N_0
v0DDM=∑tDt/Nt−1(1+r)τt+dpsn+1(r−gdps) (1+r)τn,Nt=Nt−11+(BBt−ISSt)/Vt at valuev^{DDM}_0 = \sum_t \frac{D_t / N_{t-1}}{(1+r)^{\tau_t}} + \frac{dps_{n+1}}{(r - g_{dps})\,(1+r)^{\tau_n}}, \qquad N_t = \frac{N_{t-1}}{1 + (BB_t - ISS_t)/V_t}\ \text{at value}
v0RI=[B0+∑tCIt−((1+r)Δτt−1) Bt−1(1+r)τt+CIn+1−rBn(r−gL)(1+r)τn]/N0v^{RI}_0 = \Big[B_0 + \sum_t \frac{CI_t - ((1+r)^{\Delta\tau_t} - 1)\,B_{t-1}}{(1+r)^{\tau_t}} + \frac{CI_{n+1} - r B_n}{(r-g_L)(1+r)^{\tau_n}}\Big] / N_0
SymbolMeaningFromAssumed or estimated
DD, BBBB, ISSISS, CI=NI+XCI = NI + X, BB, NNthe base's dividends, buybacks, issuance, comprehensive income, book and share countthe Earnings outlook–
τt\tau_tyears from the valuation date to each period's endthe dates–
rrthe discount rate: the 10-year plus a premium, or the rate that returns the pricethe Treasury curve page; the price–

Model-conditional. At value the three forms are one number to 1e−9; the per-share model at the market price is the buyback-price row.

The two-stage bridge

P=k E0 (1+gL)+H (gS−gL)r−gL,r=gL+kE0P[(1+gL)+H(gS−gL)]P = k\,E_0\,\frac{(1 + g_L) + H\,(g_S - g_L)}{r - g_L}, \qquad r = g_L + \frac{k E_0}{P}\big[(1+g_L) + H (g_S - g_L)\big]
SymbolMeaningFromAssumed or estimated
kk, E0E_0, gSg_Spayout, trailing earnings and near-term growth, moved one basis at a timethe Valuation, Payout and Earnings outlook pages–

The steps add to the whole move; the last replaces the identity with the whole path.

Exhibit 12 · Specification: the value on the index's own statements

How the numbers are made, step by step

  1. The base. Source: the Earnings outlook's printed parameters, drivers and starting state. Transform: re-run; the path after the valuation date. Check: equal to the published path; clean surplus on every period (11 checks, all passing).
  2. The forms. Source: step 1, the 10-year, the close. Transform: three forms and the per-share model at the market price; each form's implied rate. Check: one rate at the price; the forms agree at value (10 checks, all passing).
  3. The comparison. Source: step 2, the Valuation page's bases, Damodaran. Transform: the value at each premium; his premium reproduced. Check: his figures from his calculator; each basis on the right side of the price (22 checks, all passing).
  4. The bridge and the multiples. Source: steps 1–2, the Valuation, Payout and Profitability pages, S&P. Transform: one basis at a time; observed, justified and forward. Check: the page's premium reproduced; the steps add up; P/B = P/E × ROE (8 checks, all passing).
  5. The sensitivities. Source: step 1 re-run. Transform: (r, g_L), (ROE*, k*), the alternatives. Check: each grid's base cell returns the price (3 checks, all passing).
  • Forms
    One path, three forms.

    Model-conditional: the values here are what the earnings base's statements imply at a stated discount rate, not a target or a forecast of returns. One path, three forms (the author's decision of 12 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-12-VP15)): the per-share dividend discount model, the total-equity cash flows (dividends plus buybacks less issuance) and residual income on comprehensive income. The path is the Earnings outlook's base, re-run here from its printed parameters and equal to its published path; every figure is per index unit at the start quarter, as there.

  • Timing
    The valuation date and the flows after it.

    The valuation date is the Treasury curve page's date for its risk-free rate, 16 Nov 2026, and the price is the S&P 500's close that day. Periods that ended before it are past: the state on the date is the base's book and share count after 1 quarter(s). Each later flow sits at its period's end — quarters for the explicit stage, whole years after — discounted at (1 + r) to the years between; after year ten every flow grows at g_L = 4.0% and the terminal value is a Gordon sum on the year after.

  • Agreement
    Why they agree at value and differ at the market price.

    The total-equity cash flows do not depend on the price paid for the shares retired; the per-share dividend does, because the share count does. When shares are retired at their value the per-share model equals the total-equity value divided by the share count, period by period; at the market price — the base's own path, which retires shares at its constant-multiple market value and adds its measured non-cash dilution — it differs, and that difference is the buyback-price row. Residual income equals the total-equity value because the base's book follows clean surplus with its residual: the charge on opening book and the change in book cancel term by term. All three are solved for the rate that returns the price, each to 1e−10, and checked to agree.

  • Bridge
    From the two-stage premium, one basis at a time.

    The Valuation page's two-stage identity, P = k·E₀·[(1 + g_L) + H(g_S − g_L)] ÷ (r − g_L), solved for r on its own inputs, then one input at a time on the base's basis (the author's decision of 12 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-12-VP11)): E₀ on SPY's basis; the payout on that basis, gross and then net of issuance; the consensus growth turned from per share to the whole equity by the Payout page's share-count effect; the base's own near-term growth; then the whole path in place of the shortcut. The order is stated; each step is a difference of two solved premiums, so the steps add to the whole move.

  • Multiples
    Observed, justified and forward.

    Observed: the close over trailing earnings and book on SPY's basis on the valuation date (the filed four quarters to the start quarter and the base's book after its repurchases since), and over the base's earnings for the four quarters after the last filed — a forward multiple on the model's own earnings, model-conditional. Justified: the long-run state's — k ÷ (r − g) on the next year's earnings with k the payout net of issuance, and (ROE − g) ÷ (r − g) on book with ROE on comprehensive income — the terminal value the forms use, over earnings and over book. S&P's operating earnings over as-reported is printed beside as the wedge between the basis here (as-reported) and the consensus's (operating).

  • Grids
    The sensitivities.

    The (r, g_L) grid re-runs the base at each long-run growth rate — the fade's target — and values it at each rate, with the implied rate as a row; the (ROE*, k*) grid re-runs it at each long-run return on equity with g_L = ROE*·(1 − k*), at the implied rate. Cells where r − g is at or below the floor are left empty. Assumed values, not probabilities.

  • Damodaran
    His premium, reproduced.

    Damodaran's implied premium is read from his home page and reproduced from his calculator's inputs, formula for formula, on every update (his checks are copied into these cards' own); his monthly file alone does not carry his base-year earnings estimate, so the plain model on its columns is printed as a reading, month by month, and never as his figure. An optional input (the author's decision of 12 Oct 2026 (D-2026-10-12-VP12)): missing, past its age or not reproduced, his row is a dated notice.

67 of 67 reproduction checks pass for these cards · computed 2026-11-17 13:53 UTC
CheckPublishedComputedToleranceResult
The earnings base re-run here from its printed parameters, drivers and starting state equals its published path on every quarter, year and the year after (eleven lines; the snapshot prints six decimals; max relative difference)000.00002pass
The earnings base is this week's: built 17 Nov 2026, 0 days before this build (days over 21; blocking, inputs that block and inputs that degrade — desk decision of 2026-10-12 (D-2026-10-12-VP12))000pass
Trailing earnings at the start, Q2 2026: the re-run's four quarters equal the base's printed E4 ($292.58; abs difference, $)292.575246292.5752460.00001pass
The price and the 10-year are read on one day: the S&P 500's close of 7,416.59 (Yahoo file of 17 Nov 2026) is the session of 16 Nov 2026, the date of the Treasury curve page's risk-free rate (5.12% on 16 Nov 2026) (days apart)000pass
The valuation date's state is the base's after 1 quarter(s) (30 Sep 2026): book and share count carried, flows after 16 Nov 2026 discounted (15 periods; the schedule's first flow 0.1232 years out; problems)000pass
The schedule is clean surplus on every period and the year after: B = B₋₁ + NI + X − (D + BB − ISS) (max abs difference, $)000pass
The year after the last period is the base's steady state: book grows at g_L = 4.0% into it (abs difference)000pass
Every form has a rate in [g + 0.5pp, 30%] at which it returns the price (forms without one)000pass
The three forms imply one rate at the price: the per-share DDM at value, the total-equity cash flows and residual income (6.9584%; widest difference, the solver's tolerance 1e−10)000pass
At the implied rate, dividends per share, repurchases at value equals the total-equity value (7,416.5898 against 7,416.5898; relative difference)000pass
At the implied rate, residual income equals the total-equity value (7,416.5898 against 7,416.5898; relative difference)000pass
At the implied rate the total-equity value is the price (7,416.59; relative difference)000pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.date_is_latest_month (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPbymonth.xlsx vs home page)000pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.erp (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.0420.0420.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.erp_t12m (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.0370.0370.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.erp_smoothed (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.05670.05670.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.erp_net_cash (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.03610.03610.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.erp_normalized (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.0330.0330.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.tbond (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.05290.05290.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.previous.erp (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.04140.04140.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.previous.erp_t12m (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.04090.04090.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.previous.erp_smoothed (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.06050.06050.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.previous.erp_net_cash (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.0380.0380.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.previous.erp_normalized (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)0.03560.03560.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.home.previous.tbond (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); home page)0.04750.04750.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.cash_yield.annual_max_abs_dev (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx (Buyback & Dividend computation, 2001 on))00.0000190.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.cash_yield.trailing_four_quarters (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx)0.0258990.0258990pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.cash_yield.calculator_B7 (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx)0.0258990.0258990pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.cash.trailing_equals_monthly_cf (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx vs ERPbymonth.xlsx)198.17198.1669450.005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.histimpl.dividend_yield_max_abs_dev (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); histimpl.xls)00.0000280.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.reproduce.calculator_is_latest_month (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx (October) vs ERPbymonth.xlsx (October 2026))000pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.reproduce.calculator_goal_seek (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx (C45))0.0369750.0369750.000001pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.reproduce.calculator_is_monthly_t12m (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx (C45) vs ERPbymonth.xlsx (ERP (T12m), two decimals of a percent))0.0370.0369750.00005pass
Damodaran's own figures reproduce: damodaran.reproduce.sustainable_payout_headline (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar); ERPOct26.xlsx inputs vs ERPbymonth.xlsx headline)0.0420.0420460.0005pass
Every premium basis prices the base: r − g_L above the floor at each (4 bases; bases without a value)000pass
A premium above the implied one values the index below its price, and below it above (bases on the wrong side)000pass
The value falls as the premium rises on every step of the curve (33 points; steps up)000pass
Step 0 reproduces the Valuation page's implied premium from its own inputs (k 0.8448, E₀ ÷ P 3.9846%, g_S 15.1%, g_L 4.0%, H 3, the 10-year 5.12%: 3.502pp against 3.502pp; abs difference, the page's three decimals)3.5023.5016950.0006pass
The bridge's steps add to the whole move, −1.66pp, from the page's premium to the statements' (identity)000pass
The two-stage bridge reduces to the one-stage identity at g_S = g_L (P = k·E₀·(1 + g_L) ÷ (r − g_L); relative difference)000pass
Justified multiples at implied r = 6.96%: P/B = forward P/E × ROE (5.1067 = 27.1562 × 18.805%; the payout and ROE of the long-run state; abs difference)5.1067485.1067480pass
Justified multiples at headline r = 10.29%: P/B = forward P/E × ROE (2.4019 = 12.7726 × 18.805%; the payout and ROE of the long-run state; abs difference)2.4019072.4019070pass
The justified forward P/E at the implied rate is the total-equity terminal value over the next year's earnings (identity; relative difference)000pass
The forward multiple's earnings are the base's for the four quarters after the last filed: the re-run's year 1 against the published $311.28 (relative difference; the snapshot's six decimals)000.00002pass
The Profitability page's trailing P/E on the index basis for Q2 2026 is the base's start: its close over its E4 (7,499.36 ÷ $292.58 = 25.632× against 25.632×; abs difference, the copy's three decimals)25.63225.6322430.0006pass
The operating wedge: S&P's operating over as-reported earnings for the four quarters to 2025Q3 (2,164.58 ÷ 1,994.76 $bn; identity)1.0851331.0851330pass
The (r, g_L) grid's implied row at the base's g_L (4.0%) returns the price (gap, %)000pass
The (ROE*, k*) grid's base cell (ROE* 18.8%, k* 78.7%, so g_L 4.00%) returns the price at the implied rate (gap, %)00.0000020.0001pass
Each named alternative re-run here from the base's printed parameters and its stated changes reaches the base page's year-10 earnings (9 runs; max relative difference)000.00002pass
The alternatives' base row is the headline's implied premium (abs difference, pp)1.8383671.8383670pass
Range kinds: each range this panel prints names its kind (4 ranges; problems)000pass
cross.earnings_outlook: source snapshot is published with all its checks passing (dated 17 Nov 2026, 41 checks)110pass
cross.earnings_outlook: the site still serves the snapshot read at build time (dated 17 Nov 2026)110pass
rates.curve: source snapshot is published with all its checks passing (dated 17 Nov 2026, 39 checks)110pass
rates.curve: the site still serves the snapshot read at build time (dated 17 Nov 2026)110pass
cross.valuation: source snapshot is published with all its checks passing (dated 17 Nov 2026, 278 checks)110pass
cross.valuation: the site still serves the snapshot read at build time (dated 17 Nov 2026)110pass
cross.payout: source snapshot is published with all its checks passing (dated 17 Nov 2026, 38 checks)110pass
cross.payout: the site still serves the snapshot read at build time (dated 17 Nov 2026)110pass
cross.profitability: source snapshot is published with all its checks passing (dated 17 Nov 2026, 39 checks)110pass
cross.profitability: the site still serves the snapshot read at build time (dated 17 Nov 2026)110pass
cross.payout: every copied observation equals the source snapshot, matched by date (45 values in 1 arrays; mismatches)000pass
cross.profitability: every copied observation equals the source snapshot, matched by date (90 values in 2 arrays; mismatches)000pass
cross.earnings_outlook: every copied single value equals the source snapshot (6 values; mismatches)000pass
rates.curve: every copied single value equals the source snapshot (4 values; mismatches)000pass
cross.valuation: every copied single value equals the source snapshot (11 values; mismatches)000pass
Decisions: every desk decision this page's specification names is in the decisions file (D-2026-10-12-VP8, D-2026-10-12-VP15, D-2026-10-12-VP12, D-2026-10-12-VP9, D-2026-10-12-VP2; ids missing)000pass

Data dates: the earnings base of 17 Nov 2026 (filings to Q2 2026); the 10-year and the close on 16 Nov 2026; the Valuation page of 17 Nov 2026; Damodaran's figures of 1 Oct 2026; read on 17 Nov 2026.

Source: SEC EDGAR and SPY's holdings (the earnings base); U.S. Treasury; Yahoo Finance; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; S&P Dow Jones Indices; FactSet Insight, quoted; Macro Review calculationscross.index_value-1

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.