Macro ReviewHow to read
Cross Asset · Fundamentals · Payout & reinvestment

The index paid out 64.2% of its earnings, most as buybacks

Where do the index's earnings go?

Filings to Q2 2026 · Financial Accounts to Q2 2026Updated 17 Nov 2026
64.2%of net income, year to Q2 2026 · 2017–19 average 100.2%
Dividends25.9%of net income, year to Q2 2026 · −6.6pp on a year
Buybacks38.3%of net income, year to Q2 2026 · −7.5pp on a year
Share-count effect+1.03 log ptson per-share earnings, year to Q2 2026 · 2017–19 average +2.17
8.2%retention × ROE, Q2 2026 · assumed 4.0%above it
Corporate net share issuance+1.89%% of GDP, nonfinancial, Q2 2026 first estimate · −1.22 a year earliernet issuers

In brief

What the numbers say, and what would change the reading
  • The index paid out 64.2% of its earnings in the year to Q2 2026, against 100.2% in 2017–19.→ Exhibit 1
  • The shrinking share count added 1.03 to per-share earnings, while buybacks spent 38.3% of earnings in the year to Q2 2026.→ Exhibit 4
  • US nonfinancial companies issued, net, 1.89% of GDP in new shares in Q2 2026, on a first estimate.→ Exhibit 5
  • Keeping 35.8% of earnings at the index's return on equity sustains 8.2% growth in Q2 2026.→ Exhibit 6
  • A higher five-year payout has not meant slower earnings growth: correlation −0.07 since 1875.→ Exhibit 7
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
Buybacks fall below dividendsbuybacks ÷ earnings < dividends ÷ earnings38.3% vs 25.9% (Q2 2026)not crossedthe Q4 2026 10-Q filings, due 9 Feb 2027
The share count stops fallingshare-count effect ≤ 0 over four quarters+1.03 (Q2 2026)not crossedthe Q4 2026 10-Q filings, due 9 Feb 2027
Corporations return to net share issuance < 0% of GDP+1.89% (Q2 2026)not crossedthe Financial Accounts for the next quarter, December 2026
The reasoning behind each point
  • Payout
    The index paid out 64.2% of its earnings in the year to Q2 2026, against 100.2% in 2017–19.

    Dividends took 25.9% and buybacks 38.3%, summed over every company that files a cash-flow statement (98% of the index's weight). Valuation's measured payout, from S&P Dow Jones Indices' release to 2025 Q3, is 84.5%: S&P counts more as buybacks and fewer earnings per company (float adjustment).

  • Net
    The shrinking share count added 1.03 log points to per-share earnings, while buybacks spent 38.3% of earnings in the year to Q2 2026.

    Shares issued to employees and for acquisitions offset most of what is bought back. The share-count effect is a fixed-fraction holder's earnings growth less the companies' total earnings growth over four quarters.

  • Corporate sector
    US nonfinancial companies issued, net, 1.89% of GDP in new shares in Q2 2026, on a first estimate.

    The Financial Accounts of 11 Sep 2026 put it at $613bn a year; the latest quarter is the release's first estimate and the one it revises most. With the index's companies outside finance buying back $739bn in the year to Q2 2026, new shares would run near $1,352bn a year if those were the sector's only retirements. A year earlier the sector retired 1.22% of GDP net.

  • Retention
    Keeping 35.8% of earnings at the index's return on equity sustains 8.2% growth in Q2 2026.

    Retention × return on equity (23.0%) is the growth of earnings reinvestment can carry (Damodaran's fundamental growth); per-share growth adds the share-count effect. Since Q2 2015 it has averaged 1.7% (error 0.7), against the 4.0% the valuation assumes for the long run. The payout that would leave 4.0% is 82.6%.

  • History
    A higher five-year payout has not meant slower earnings growth: correlation −0.07 since 1875.

    Each year's payout averaged over five years, against the growth of five-year average earnings over the next five (146 years, the S&P composite in Shiller's data). Retention does not reliably buy growth: companies that pay out more have not grown less.

  • Capital spending
    Capital spending took 8.4% of revenue outside finance in the year to Q2 2026, against 5.8% in 2017–19.

    Free cash flow — operating cash flow less capital spending — was 79% of net income, against 104% in 2017–19.

Next: Profitability & balance sheet — the return on what is kept

Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System; Robert J. Shiller; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-read

How much of the earnings is paid out?

The trailing year's dividends and buybacks as a share of the companies' net income, beside the payout Valuation measures from S&P Dow Jones Indices

Exhibit 1 · Index payout as a share of earnings, buybacks and dividends since 2015

Trailing year, % of net income, quarterly since Q2 2015; dashed, the payout Valuation measures from S&P's release.
About
About this exhibit
Lines of total payout, buybacks and dividends as % of net income, trailing year, quarterly since Q4 2015, with S&P's measured payout (Valuation) dashed.
Dividends and buybacks as a share of net income
Trailing year, % of net income, quarterly since Q2 2015; dashed, the payout Valuation measures from S&P's release.
Every company that files a cash-flow statement in the quarter; a dividend or repurchase line it does not file counts as zero. Company totals as filed. S&P counts more as buybacks (the shares withheld for employees' taxes) and fewer earnings per company (float adjustment), so its measure runs higher; Valuation's 84.5% is the year to Q3 2025. 500 companies held by State Street's S&P 500 fund on 13 Nov 2026; today's members only before that date.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; S&P Dow Jones Indices (the Valuation page); Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-1

Exhibit 2 · Where the trailing year's earnings went, in dollars

Sums over the companies filing a cash-flow statement (98% of the index's weight), $bn, year to Q2 2026 and a year earlier.
UseYear to Q2 2026Year to Q2 2025
Net income2,6591,998
Dividends689650
Buybacks1,020916
Retained951432
The payout elsewherePayoutBasis
Measured payout, Valuation84.5%S&P Dow Jones Indices' release of 18 Dec 2025: dividends and buybacks ÷ as-reported earnings
Every US company, Damodaran87.0%dividends and buybacks ÷ net income, 8 Jan 2026; net of shares issued, 72.4%
About this exhibit
Retained is net income less dividends and buybacks: what is left to reinvest or to add to cash. Damodaran's row is every listed US company in his January update (5,994 firms), a wider set, for scale.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; S&P Dow Jones Indices (the Valuation page); Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-2

Exhibit 3 · Index-weighted payout against S&P's measure and the company-total payout

Dividends + buybacks ÷ earnings, trailing year, %, quarterly from Q2 2020; per index unit through SPY's holdings.
About this exhibit
Lines of payout per index unit (through SPY's holdings), S&P's measured payout (dashed) and the company-total payout, dividends plus buybacks ÷ earnings, trailing year, quarterly.
The payout of the index as weighted, against S&P's and the company totals'
Dividends + buybacks ÷ earnings, trailing year, %, quarterly from Q2 2020; per index unit through SPY's holdings.
Per index unit: each member's dividends, buybacks and earnings over its diluted share count, times the shares SPY held in it at each quarter's end, over their value, times the S&P 500's close. It weighs each company as the index does, which the company totals do not. Against S&P's measured payout it sat within 0.90–1.00 times in 10 of the 10 quarters S&P's release covers: S&P also counts the shares withheld for employees' taxes as buybacks. Net of the proceeds of shares issued the payout was 64.5% in Q2 2026; on today's holdings (13 Nov 2026) the year to Q2 2026 is 64.8%.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; S&P Dow Jones Indices (the Valuation page); U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Form N-PORT); Yahoo Finance; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-12

How much do buybacks shrink the share count?

The share count's net change after the shares issued to employees and for acquisitions, and the whole corporate sector's net issuance of shares

Exhibit 4 · What the falling share count adds to per-share earnings, since 2015

Four-quarter growth of a fixed-fraction holder's earnings less the companies' total, log points (pp), quarterly since Q2 2015.
About
About this exhibit
Line of the share-count effect: a fixed-fraction holder's earnings growth less the companies' total earnings growth, log points over four quarters, quarterly since Q4 2015.
What the change in share count adds to per-share earnings
A fixed-fraction holder's earnings growth less the companies' total earnings growth, log points over four quarters, quarterly since Q2 2015.
Positive when share counts shrink: , what is bought back less what is issued to employees and for acquisitions. A company whose count moves by more than a split's factor in a quarter is left out of that quarter. 500 companies held by State Street's S&P 500 fund on 13 Nov 2026; today's members only before that date.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-3

Exhibit 5 · Net share issuance by US nonfinancial companies relative to GDP, since 2009

Shares issued less shares retired, % of GDP, annual rates, quarterly since Q1 2009; Q2 2026 is a first estimate, released 11 Sep 2026.
About this exhibit
Line of US nonfinancial corporations' net share issuance (issued less retired), % of GDP, annual rates, quarterly since Q1 2009.
Net issuance of shares by US nonfinancial corporations
Shares issued less shares retired, % of GDP, annual rates, quarterly since Q1 2009; Q2 2026 is a first estimate, released 11 Sept 2026.
Every US nonfinancial corporation, listed or not, with the shares exchanged in mergers: wider than the index and measured net of all issuance. Federal Reserve series FA103164105.Q, over GDP (FA086902005.Q). The latest quarter is the release's first estimate, the one later releases revise most. For scale: net issuance of $613bn a year in Q2 2026, while the index's companies outside finance bought back $739bn in the year to Q2 2026 (S&P Dow Jones Indices counts $1,020bn for the whole index in the year to Q3 2025): new shares near $1,352bn a year if those buybacks were the sector's only retirements. Mergers retire shares too, so gross issuance is larger still.
Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-4

What does the retained part sustain?

Retention times return on equity — the growth reinvestment can carry — against the payout that would leave the assumed , and what higher payouts have meant for growth since 1871

Exhibit 6 · Growth the index's retained earnings can fund, against the assumed long-run rate

% a year, retention × return on equity, quarterly since Q2 2015; dashed, the long-run rate the valuation assumes.
About
About this exhibit
Line of retention × return on equity (the growth reinvestment can fund), % a year, quarterly, against the long-run rate the valuation assumes (dashed); a toggle shows the payout against its ceiling.
Growth the retained earnings sustain, against the assumed long-run rate
Retention × return on equity, % a year, quarterly since Q2 2015; dashed, the long-run rate the valuation assumes.
is the growth of total earnings that reinvesting what is kept at the index's return on equity would carry; per-share growth adds the share-count effect. The return on equity is the Profitability & balance sheet page's; the assumed rate is the Long-run growth page's. A payout above the ceiling keeps too little to grow at the assumed rate from reinvestment alone.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-5

Exhibit 7 · Five-year payout against the next five years' earnings growth

Each year's payout, % of earnings, averaged over five years, against the growth of five-year average earnings over the next five, 1875–2020; S&P composite.
About this exhibit
Scatter of each year's five-year average payout against the growth of five-year average earnings over the next five years, S&P composite, over the whole record.
The payout and the earnings growth that followed, since 1875
Each year's payout averaged over 5 years, against the growth of 5-year average earnings over the next 5, 1875–2020; the S&P composite.
Shiller's December values of the composite's trailing dividends and earnings (buybacks are not in a dividend, so a high-buyback era reads as a low payout). A description of the record, not a model. Correlation by era: 1875–2020 −0.07; 1881–1945 +0.26; 1946–1989 +0.42; 1990–2020 +0.66.
Source: Robert J. Shiller; Macro Review calculations · data to 2020cross.payout-6

Where does the corporate sector's cash go?

The Financial Accounts' uses of cash against after-tax profits, and the companies' capital spending and free cash flow

Exhibit 8 · The corporate sector's profits, and what it pays out and invests

US nonfinancial corporations, % of GDP, quarterly since Q1 2009: profits after tax, net dividends, net buybacks and net capital spending.
About this exhibit
Profits after tax are net dividends plus undistributed profits (book profits). Net buybacks are net share issuance with the sign reversed; net capital spending is gross fixed investment less depreciation. All at seasonally adjusted annual rates, from the Financial Accounts (Z.1).
Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-7

Exhibit 9 · The selected cash ratio outside finance, since 2015

Capital spending ÷ revenue, trailing year, %, quarterly since Q2 2015.
About this exhibit
Line of capital spending ÷ revenue for companies outside finance, trailing year, %, quarterly since Q4 2015 (a toggle shows free cash flow ÷ net income).
Capital spending ÷ revenue, companies outside finance
Capital spending ÷ revenue, trailing year, %, quarterly since Q2 2015.
Companies outside finance that file all the figures. Free cash flow above net income means depreciation and other non-cash charges exceed what is spent on new capital; below it, investment is outrunning them. 500 companies held by State Street's S&P 500 fund on 13 Nov 2026; today's members only before that date.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-8

Carried forward, the payout rises toward what the long-run return allows

: dividends, buybacks and the share count as the base carries them, to the terminal payout

Exhibit 10 · Model path of the payout, share count and dividend per unit

Model-conditional: the Earnings outlook's base case from Q2 2026, by year; the net payout reaches 78.7% in the terminal year
About
YearPayout, grossPayout, netDividends' shareShare count, year-endShare-count effectDividend per unit
168.2%62.9%41.2%0.9843+1.63%$87.44
273.0%67.5%43.7%0.9684+1.59%$98.84
393.8%88.2%34.3%0.9456+1.80%$97.90
485.1%79.7%38.2%0.9254+2.27%$103.38
581.9%76.6%40.1%0.9066+2.10%$110.67
681.3%76.0%40.8%0.8885+2.03%$119.05
781.8%76.5%40.9%0.8706+2.02%$128.18
882.7%77.4%40.9%0.8530+2.04%$137.89
983.9%78.5%40.7%0.8354+2.07%$148.11
1084.1%78.7%41.0%0.8182+2.08%$158.77

The share count is one at the start; the share-count effect is per-share growth less aggregate growth, in log points. After the terminal year per-share earnings grow 6.18% a year against 4.0% for the aggregate.

About this exhibit
Table of the Earnings outlook's base case, year by year: gross and net payout, dividends' share, year-end share count, share-count effect and dividend per unit
Carried forward: the payout and the share count
Model-conditional: the Earnings outlook's base, from Q2 2026; at the terminal year the payout is 1 − g_L ÷ ROE* = 78.7% net of issuance and the residual.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR: the members' filings; Form N-PORT); State Street Global Advisors; Yahoo Finance; BEA; Robert J. Shiller; Federal Reserve Board; EIA; Macro Review calculationscross.earnings_outlook-17

Reconciliation to S&P Dow Jones Indices

The filings' dividends, buybacks and earnings against S&P Dow Jones Indices' published quarters, the gap named

Exhibit 11 · Company filings against S&P's published dividends, buybacks and earnings

Trailing-year dividends, buybacks and earnings, $bn, Q2 2023 to Q3 2025: S&P's figures beside the filings summed over the current members, and their ratio.
Year toDividends, S&PFilingsRatioBuybacks, S&PFilingsRatioEarnings, S&P as reportedNet income, filingsRatioPayout, S&PPayout, filings
Q3 20256656661.001,0209350.921,9952,0991.0584.5%76.2%
Q2 20256546521.009989160.921,8832,0021.0687.7%78.4%
Q1 20256426441.009999160.921,7821,9561.1092.1%79.7%
Q4 20246306381.019438670.921,7261,9071.1191.1%79.0%
Q3 20246166271.029188520.931,6381,8151.1193.7%81.6%
Q2 20246036101.018778170.931,5981,7851.1292.7%80.1%
Q1 20245935961.018167620.931,6061,7341.0887.8%78.3%
Q4 20235885830.997957410.931,6101,7291.0785.9%76.6%
Q3 20235805710.997877300.931,5411,6551.0788.7%78.8%
Q2 20235765690.998127540.931,5151,5911.0591.7%83.4%
About this exhibit
Table by quarter: trailing-year dividends, buybacks and earnings from S&P and from the filings ($bn), with ratios and both payouts.
The filings against S&P Dow Jones Indices' published quarters
Trailing-year dividends, buybacks and earnings, $bn: S&P's figures for the index beside the filings summed over today's members, and the ratio of the two.
S&P's figures are float-adjusted and count the members of each quarter; the filings are company totals for today's members. Buybacks run lower in the filings because S&P also counts the shares companies withhold for employees' taxes. The bands each ratio is held to: dividends 0.9–1.1, buybacks 0.85–1. The S&P figures are the Valuation page's copy of the release.
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; S&P Dow Jones Indices (the Valuation page); Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-9

Appendix

The zero rule, the aggregation, each step of the calculation and every source79 checks, all pass
About this page

Where the S&P 500's earnings go, from the companies' own filings: how much is paid out as dividends and bought back as shares, how much of the buying merely offsets the shares issued to employees and for acquisitions, what the retained part can sustain at the index's return on equity, and what the whole corporate sector does with its cash. The payout the valuation uses is Valuation's, measured from S&P Dow Jones Indices' release, and is printed beside these figures, not replaced by them. The membership is today's (500 companies on 13 Nov 2026); the history before that date is today's members only.

Exhibit 12 · Definitions

How much of the index each figure covers

FigureCompaniesBasisCompanies filingShare of weight, Q2 2026Lowest, last four quartersPrinted
Net incomealltrailing four quarters48898.3%98.3%yes
Operating cash flowalltrailing four quarters48598.0%98.0%yes
Dividends paid (zero where not filed; 10 read from the equity statement)alltrailing four quarters49098.4%98.4%yes
Repurchases of common stock (zero where not filed; 28 read from the equity statement)alltrailing four quarters48898.2%98.2%yes
Diluted share countallquarter-end47996.0%94.6%yes
Capital spendingoutside financetrailing four quarters36491.1%91.1%yes
Revenueoutside financetrailing four quarters41097.9%97.9%yes
Proceeds from issuing shares (zero where not filed)alltrailing four quarters48698.1%98.1%yes
  • Zero rule
    A line not filed is zero, on a filed statement.

    A company that files a cash-flow statement for a quarter and no dividend or repurchase line paid none: the line is zero, not missing (a company that pays no dividend files no dividend line). A company that files no cash-flow line for repurchases or dividends but reports them in its statement of equity is read there — the value of the shares repurchased and the dividends declared, an accrual rather than the cash paid: in the year to Q2 2026, 28 companies' buybacks (2.7% of the index's weight: Palantir Technologies Inc, Palo Alto Networks Inc, Morgan Stanley, CME Group Inc, Constellation Energy) and 10 companies' dividends (0.6%: Targa Resources Corp, CRH plc, Bloom Energy Corp, Consolidated Edison Inc, P G & E Corp). Checked against S&P Dow Jones Indices' totals: the filings' dividends run 0.98–1.02 times S&P's over the 10 quarters its release covers and their buybacks 0.92–0.93 times — S&P also counts the shares companies withhold for employees' taxes as buybacks, and companies that have since left the index.

  • Payout
    Dividends and buybacks over net income.

    The total payout is the trailing year's dividends and buybacks over the trailing year's net income, summed over the companies that file a cash-flow statement in each quarter — company totals as filed, not float-adjusted.

  • Share count
    What a fixed-fraction holder gains.

    The share-count effect is what a holder who owns a fixed fraction of every company gains per share: 100 × the log of Σ net income × (shares a year ago ÷ shares now) over Σ net income. Positive when share counts shrink. A company whose count moves by more than a split's factor is left out of that quarter.

  • Retention
    Fundamental growth and the ceiling on the payout.

    Fundamental growth is retention × return on equity (Damodaran): the growth of total earnings that reinvesting what is kept at the index's return would carry. The payout that leaves the assumed long-run rate is 1 − g ÷ ROE, the terminal-year payout Damodaran's two-stage model fades to. Its mean since the history begins carries a Newey–West error over four lags: overlapping trailing years are not independent.

  • History
    Shiller's composite since the 1870s.

    Shiller's December values of the S&P composite's trailing dividends and earnings: the payout averaged over five years against the change in five-year average earnings over the next five, in log points a year. Correlations by era; a description, not a model.

  • Financial Accounts
    The whole corporate sector.

    The Financial Accounts' nonfinancial corporate business: every US nonfinancial corporation, listed or not. Net issuance of corporate equities (issuance less retirements, mergers included); net dividends; undistributed profits; gross fixed investment less consumption of fixed capital — each over GDP, all at seasonally adjusted annual rates. The release is the Board's of 11 Sep 2026; its latest quarter is a first estimate, the one later releases revise most. The new shares implied — net issuance plus the buybacks of the index's companies outside finance — is a size, not a measure: the sector also retires shares in mergers, so its gross issuance is larger still.

  • Three legs
    The long-run rate, three ways.

    Three readings of the long-run rate. Fundamental: retention × return on equity from the filings, its mean since the history begins with a Newey–West error. Statistical: Long-run growth's profile-likelihood estimate of the long-run rate of nominal GDP, with its standard error and 95% interval. Assumed: the Committee's longer-run medians for real GDP and PCE inflation added — an assumption, not an estimate. The fundamental leg measures total earnings; per-share growth adds the share-count effect.

  • The index basis
    The payout of the index as weighted.

    The payout on the index basis: dividends, buybacks and the proceeds of shares issued, each per index unit — every member's quarter over its diluted share count, times the shares SPY holds in it, over their value, times the S&P 500's close, each quarter on that quarter-end's holdings — summed over four quarters and set over earnings per index unit on the same basis. It is the payout of the index as weighted, which the company totals above are not. Against S&P's measured payout it sat inside [0.9, 1.0] in 10 of the 10 quarters S&P's release covers; dividends per index unit ran 0.987–1.033 times the S&P composite's in Shiller's file. S&P's buybacks include the shares withheld for employees' taxes, which the filings' repurchase line leaves out.

  • Licence
    Whose numbers these are.

    SEC filings and the Financial Accounts are published by federal agencies for reuse. State Street's holdings, Shiller's data and Damodaran's datasets are shown with their attribution. The aggregates are computed here.

Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (EDGAR); State Street Global Advisors; Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System; Robert J. Shiller; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern; Macro Review calculations · data to Q2 2026cross.payout-10

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.