Macro ReviewHow to read
Macro · Labour · Wages

Pay is growing 3.1% a year, below the pace the inflation target allows

Is wage growth consistent with 2% inflation, and are real wages rising?

BLS Employment Situation · 6 Nov 2026Real Earnings · 10 Nov 2026 · ECI · 30 Oct 2026Earnings to Oct 2026 · ECI to Q3 2026Updated 16 Nov 2026
Average hourly earningsⓘ+3.1%y/y Oct 2026 · pace consistent with 2% ≈4.1%below that pace
Real hourly earningsⓘNo readingy/y Oct 2026 · last, Sep 2026: −0.5%
Production & nonsupervisory, realⓘNo readingy/y Oct 2026 · last, Sep 2026: −0.5%
Real aggregate weekly payrollsⓘNo readingy/y Oct 2026 · last, Sep 2026: +0.6%
wages ex incentive payⓘ+3.1%private, 12 months to Q3 2026 · pace consistent with 2% ≈4.1%at or below benchmark
Unit labour costs+2.4%nonfarm business, y/y Q3 2026 · productivity +2.1%
Basis
3-Month Momentum Method

In brief

What the earnings data say, in a few lines; what would change the read beneath
  • Average hourly earnings rose 3.1% on the year, below the ≈4.1% pace consistent with the inflation target.→ Exhibit 1
  • Real hourly earnings fell 0.2% over the three months to Oct 2026.→ Exhibit 2
  • The Employment Cost Index for private wages excluding incentive-paid occupations rose +3.1% over the year to Q3 2026.→ Exhibit 3
  • Unit labour costs are +2.4% on the year with productivity +2.1% (Q3 2026).→ Exhibit 7
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
Wage pace heats upaverage hourly earnings, 3m annualised > 4.6% for two months+3.2% (Oct 2026); +2.8% a month earliernot crossedthe Nov 2026 jobs report (BLS)
The confirmsECI private wages ex incentive pay, y/y > 4.1%+3.1% (Q3 2026)not crossedthe Q4 2026 Employment Cost Index (BLS)
The reasoning behind each point
  • Pace
    Average hourly earnings rose 3.1% on the year, below the ≈4.1% pace consistent with the inflation target.

    Over three months pay rose +3.2% annualised and over six +3.2%. The benchmark for wage growth consistent with 2% inflation — 2% plus trend productivity growth (2.1% a year over the last 10 years of nonfarm business productivity) — is 4.1%; 3.9% on a 5-year trend and 3.8% on 20 years. The three-month pace is at or below the central benchmark; the 2015–19 average year-on-year rate was +2.7%.

  • Real
    Real hourly earnings fell 0.2% annualised over the three months to Oct 2026.

    BLS publishes no twelve-month change in real earnings for Oct 2026, because it published no CPI for Oct 2025. This page estimates none. The last twelve-month change, for Sep 2026, was −0.5% with consumer prices +3.7%; for production and nonsupervisory workers it was −0.5% (deflated by CPI-W; all employees by CPI-U). Aggregate weekly payrolls — employment × hours × pay, a proxy for labour income — are +4.5% on the year before inflation; after it they were +0.6% in Sep 2026.

  • ECI
    The Employment Cost Index for private wages excluding incentive-paid occupations rose +3.1% over the year to Q3 2026.

    Private wages and salaries (seasonally adjusted) rose +3.1% annualised in the latest quarter and +3.3% over two; total private compensation +3.4% on the year. The ECI holds the job mix fixed, so it is free of the composition shifts that move average hourly earnings when low- or high-paid jobs are added or lost.

  • Costs
    Unit labour costs are +2.4% on the year with productivity +2.1% (Q3 2026).

    Across industries, hourly earnings growth ranges from utilities (+5.9%) to education and health services (+2.0%). Unit labour costs are the wage measure that maps onto prices: pay growth in excess of productivity.

Next: PCE — services inflation outside housing

BLS, Current Employment Statistics, CPI-U and CPI-W, the Employment Cost Index and Productivity and Costs; Macro Review calculations.labour.wages-read

How fast is pay rising, and is that consistent with 2%?

Hourly earnings in dollars and in purchasing power, against the benchmark that 2% inflation plus trend productivity allows, and the and unit labour costs beside them

Exhibit 2 · Hourly earnings growth for all employees in nominal, real and price terms

% change on a year earlier, Oct 2021 to Oct 2026; nominal ≈ real + price. Real and price run to Sep 2026, empty around Oct 2025.
About
About this exhibit
For the series selected in the earnings table (default: hourly earnings, all employees), year-on-year change in nominal pay, real pay and the consumer price index used to deflate it (CPI-U, or CPI-W for production and nonsupervisory workers), monthly, last five years by default.
Hourly earnings, all employees: nominal, real and price, year on year
% change on a year earlier; nominal ≈ real + price. Real and price are empty around October 2025 (no CPI).
Source: BLS, Current Employment Statistics and CPI; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026labour.wages-3

Exhibit 1 · Average hourly earnings growth against the pace consistent with the inflation target

All private employees, % change, monthly, Oct 2021 to Oct 2026; lines: year on year and three-month annualised; dashed: 2% plus 10-year trend productivity growth.
About
About this exhibit
Average hourly earnings growth, all private employees, monthly, last five years by default: year-on-year and three-month annualised lines, with the site's benchmark (2% plus 10-year trend productivity growth) dashed.
Against the pace consistent with 2% inflation
Average hourly earnings, all employees, % change; dashed: 2% plus trend productivity growth
Source: BLS, Current Employment Statistics and Productivity and Costs; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026labour.wages-4

Exhibit 3 · Twelve-month change in the Employment Cost Index, unit labour costs and productivity

% change on a year earlier, quarterly, last ten years to Q3 2026; ECI unadjusted, the others seasonally adjusted; line: the 2%-consistent benchmark (wage measures only). · loading history
About this exhibit
Twelve-month change, quarterly, last ten years by default: ECI private wages excluding incentive pay, ECI private compensation, nonfarm unit labour costs and productivity (dashed line), with the 2%-consistent benchmark as a dashed horizontal line.
Labour costs, 12-month change
Percent; ECI unadjusted, unit labour costs seasonally adjusted; dashed: the 2%-consistent benchmark (wage measures only)
Source: BLS, Employment Cost Index and Productivity and Costs; Macro Review calculations.labour.wages-7

Which measure, which industry?

Every earnings and labour-income series on the momentum ladder, the selected series charted, and the industries on a heatmap

Exhibit 4 · Earnings and labour income growth by measure and industry

% annualised except MoM and YoY, Oct 2026; on the chosen basis (real: CPI-U, or CPI-W for production and nonsupervisory). Share = industry share of private employment.
above its 2015–19 averagebelow its 2015–19 averageShading scales with distance in standard deviations (full at 2σ). Select a row to chart it.
Wages and labour costs, nominal, Oct 2026
SeriesYoY3m ann.MoM ann.MoMEmp. share2015–19 YoYYoY, 36 monthsMonth
Earnings
Hourly earnings, all employeesdeflated by CPI-U+3.1+3.2+4.5+0.372.7Oct ’26
Hourly earnings, nonsupervisoryproduction and nonsupervisory employees; deflated by CPI-W+3.3+3.4+4.5+0.372.7Oct ’26
Weekly earnings, all employeesdeflated by CPI-U+3.7+4.4+4.5+0.372.7Oct ’26
Labour income
Aggregate payrolls, all employeesindex of aggregate weekly payrolls, 2007=100: labour income proxy; deflated by CPI-U+4.5+5.3+5.8+0.474.6Oct ’26
Aggregate payrolls, nonsupervisoryproduction and nonsupervisory employees, 2002=100; deflated by CPI-W+4.6+4.4+2.2+0.184.5Oct ’26
By industry (all employees)
Goods-producing+4.2+3.6+8.3–15.92.4Oct ’26
Mining and logging+4.2+2.5+3.5–0.41.9Oct ’26
Construction+4.7+4.2+11.5–6.22.9Oct ’26
Manufacturing+3.8+3.4+6.0–9.32.2Oct ’26
Private service-providing+2.8+3.1+3.6–84.12.8Oct ’26
Trade, transportation and utilities+2.8+2.4+2.6–21.22.6Oct ’26
Wholesale trade+2.1+1.7−0.3–4.52.3Oct ’26
Retail trade+3.2+3.3+3.7–11.43.0Oct ’26
Transportation and warehousing+2.5+2.0+2.2–4.91.6Oct ’26
Utilities+5.9+2.8+1.9–0.53.2Oct ’26
Information+4.6+2.4−5.4–2.04.4Oct ’26
Financial activities+3.2+2.7+1.7–6.73.2Oct ’26
Professional and business services+3.0+3.9+4.0–16.62.8Oct ’26
Education and health services+2.0+3.3+4.0–20.62.2Oct ’26
Leisure and hospitality+3.9+3.3+3.1–12.53.5Oct ’26
Other services+2.9+3.7+3.2–4.42.8Oct ’26
About this exhibit
Table of hourly and weekly earnings, aggregate weekly payrolls (a labour-income proxy) and hourly earnings by industry, latest month, on the basis chosen above (nominal, real or price): year on year, three-month and one-month annualised, month on month, employment share, 2015–19 year-on-year average and a 36-month sparkline.
Earnings and labour income, Oct 2026
% annualised except MoM and YoY; basis chosen above (real: CPI-U, or CPI-W for production and nonsupervisory). Share = industry share of private employment. Select a row to chart it below.
Source: BLS, Current Employment Statistics, CPI and Real Earnings; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026labour.wages-1

Exhibit 5 · Hourly earnings growth for all employees over one, three and twelve months

% annualised, Nov 2021 to Oct 2026; bars: month on month; lines: three-month annualised and year on year; dashed: 2015–19 average yearly rate. Oct 2025 shaded.
Smooth
About
About this exhibit
For the series and basis selected: month-on-month annualised growth (bars), three-month annualised and year-on-year growth (lines), and the 2015–19 average year-on-year rate (dashed), over the last five years by default.
Hourly earnings, all employees — nominal: latest +3.1% y/y, +3.2% over three months annualised
%, Nov 2021 to Oct 2026.
Bars: month on month, annualised. Lines: three-month annualised (basis chosen above) and year on year. Dashed: the 2015–19 average year-on-year rate. Shaded: Oct 2025 (BLS CPI not published; real earnings and changes spanning the month left empty (as BLS leaves them), the year to Oct 2026 among them).
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026labour.wages-2

Exhibit 6 · Hourly earnings growth by industry and month, against 2015–19 averages

Three-month average against the prior three months, annualised, %, Nov 2023 to Oct 2026; colour: standard deviations from each industry's 2015–19 average, blue above, orange below.
About this exhibit
Heatmap of hourly earnings growth for each industry (all employees), the last 36 months: three-month average against the prior three months, annualised, nominal, each cell coloured by distance from that industry's 2015–19 average in standard deviations (blue above, orange below).
Three years of momentum — nominal, 3m avg vs prior 3m, annualised
Nov 2023 to Oct 2026. Blue: above the series' 2015–19 average; orange: below. Industries, all employees; price basis not shown per industry (the deflator is CPI-U for all).
Cell colour: distance from the series' own 2015–19 average on that measure, in standard deviations. Values on hover.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026labour.wages-5

Do labour costs explain inflation?

The Employment Cost Index, free of job-mix shifts, against productivity — and the services inflation that pay feeds is on the PCE page

Exhibit 7 · Employment Cost Index with productivity and unit labour costs

Q3 2026: changes in %, three-month seasonally adjusted (annualised where marked), twelve-month unadjusted; index levels as BLS publishes them; shading against 2015–19.
About
SeriesIndex3m chg, SA3m ann.6m ann.12m, NSA12m, SA12m pct since 200212-month change, 5 yearsAs of
Civilian and government
Civilian: total compensation178.6+0.8%+3.2%+3.4%+3.4%+3.4%68Q3 2026
Civilian: wages and salaries178.1+0.7%+3.0%+3.2%+3.1%+3.1%69Q3 2026
Civilian: benefits179.9+0.9%+3.6%+3.7%+3.9%+3.9%77Q3 2026
State and local government: total compensation181.4+0.6%+2.5%+3.2%+3.5%+3.5%63Q3 2026
State and local government: wages and salaries168.2+0.6%+2.3%+2.9%+3.2%+3.2%74Q3 2026
Private industry
Private: total compensation178.0+0.8%+3.3%+3.4%+3.4%+3.3%69Q3 2026
Private: wages and salaries180.4+0.8%+3.1%+3.3%+3.1%+3.1%66Q3 2026
Private: wages and salaries excluding incentive-paid occupationsnot seasonally adjusted––––+3.1%–62Q3 2026
Private: benefits172.2+0.9%+3.8%+3.8%+3.9%+3.9%78Q3 2026
Private wages by industry
Wages: goods-producing176.2+0.7%+2.9%+3.9%+3.1%+3.1%71Q3 2026
Wages: service-providing181.5+0.8%+3.2%+3.2%+3.1%+3.1%65Q3 2026
Wages: manufacturing176.0+0.7%+2.7%+3.4%+3.1%+3.1%77Q3 2026
About this exhibit
Table, latest quarter, of Employment Cost Index indexes (civilian, state and local, private; compensation, wages, benefits; private wages by industry and occupation) and nonfarm business productivity, hourly compensation and unit labour costs: index, 3-month and 6-month changes, 12-month changes, percentile since 2002 and a 5-year sparkline.
Employment Cost Index and productivity, Q3 2026
Index (Dec 2005 = 100; productivity 2017 = 100). 3-month changes seasonally adjusted, annualised where marked; 12-month changes unadjusted, as BLS publishes. Shading against own 2015–19 distribution.
Source: BLS Employment Cost Index; BLS Productivity and Costs.labour.wages-6

Appendix

Definitions, deflators, the benchmark and gaps17 checks, all pass
About this page

Wage growth is consistent with 2% inflation when it exceeds 2% by no more than productivity growth. This page reads hourly earnings on the monthly ladder in nominal and real terms, the fixed-weight Employment Cost Index that is free of job-mix shifts, and unit labour costs, against a stated productivity benchmark.

Exhibit 8 · Definitions and caveats

  • Earnings
    Averages move with the job mix.

    Average hourly earnings are gross pay before deductions, including overtime, divided by paid hours (CES definitions), for all employees on private nonfarm payrolls and, separately, for production and nonsupervisory employees (82% of private employment in Oct 2026). Averages shift when the mix of jobs shifts: adding low-paid jobs lowers them, losing them raises them.

  • Real
    CPI-U and CPI-W, as BLS.

    Real earnings = nominal earnings ÷ CPI × 100, in 1982–84 dollars: all employees with the CPI for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), production and nonsupervisory employees with the CPI for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W), both seasonally adjusted, as BLS's Real Earnings release does (reproduced above). Price basis = the deflator itself.

  • Income
    Aggregate weekly payrolls.

    Index of aggregate weekly payrolls = employment × average weekly hours × average hourly earnings, indexed to 2007 = 100: the payroll-survey proxy for wage and salary income. Deflated here with CPI-U (CPI-W for the production and nonsupervisory index).

  • ECI
    Fixed job mix, quarterly.

    The Employment Cost Index measures the change in the cost of labour for a fixed mix of jobs (Laspeyres, current employment weights), so it excludes composition effects. Quarterly (March, June, September, December). Three-month changes use seasonally adjusted indexes; twelve-month changes the unadjusted ones, as BLS publishes. Seasonally adjusted data for the most recent five years are revised each year (ECI Technical Note).

  • Benchmark
    2% plus trend productivity.

    The site's own rule: wage growth consistent with 2% inflation = 2% + trend growth of nonfarm business labour productivity, measured as the compound annual growth of the BLS productivity index over the last 10 years (sensitivity: 5 and 20 years). It assumes a stable labour share; it is a yardstick, not an estimate of the Fed's reaction function.

  • Costs
    Productivity and unit labour costs.

    Nonfarm business labour productivity (output per hour), hourly compensation and unit labour costs, BLS Productivity and Costs, seasonally adjusted, 2017 = 100.

  • Data gap
    Oct 2025: BLS CPI.

    The October 2025 CPI was not published (federal shutdown), so real earnings for October 2025 — and changes that span it — are left empty, as BLS leaves them. The year to Oct 2026 starts in that month: BLS's Real Earnings release prints no twelve-month change for Oct 2026 and this page prints none, so the three real tiles read "No reading" and show the last twelve-month change beside it. Shorter changes that do not touch Oct 2025 are unaffected.

  • Norms
    Own history, 2015–19.

    Shading compares each rate with its own 2015–19 distribution; percentiles run from January 2007 (all-employee earnings begin in March 2006).

Source: BLS Handbook of Methods (CES, ECI, Productivity); BLS Real Earnings; ECI Technical Note.labour.wages-8

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.