Macro ReviewHow to read
Macro · Consumer · Retail sales

Retail sales rose 6.8% in dollars; volume's 3.0% is below its 2015–19 pace

How fast are retail sales growing, and how much of it is volume?

Census advance report · 17 Nov 2026Data to Oct 2026 · updated 17 Nov 2026
Basis
3-Month Momentum Method
Headline sales, nominal+6.8%y/y, Oct 2026 advance · m/m +0.2% · 84th 2010
Headline sales, real+3.0%y/y, Oct 2026 · +3.6% · 46th pct since 2010
Price inside the headline+3.7ppOct 2026 · of the 6.8% y/y, the
, real+6.7%., Oct 2026 · y/y +3.7% vs 2015–19 +3.7%above pre-pandemic norm
Gasoline stations+2.3ppOct 2026 · of nominal growth; +0.02pp of real · price +30% y/y
Warehouse clubs & supercenters, real+2.8%y/y, Sep 2026 · 2015–19 average +4.8%below its norm

In brief

What the advance report says, in a few lines; what would change the read beneath
  • Sales rose +6.8% on the year to Oct 2026 in dollars but +3.0% in volume.→ Exhibit 1
  • Gasoline is 60% of the gap between the two.→ Exhibit 5
  • The real is up +3.7% on the year, in line with its of +3.7%.→ Exhibit 6
  • Online and mail-order retailers supply 1.44 of the 3.05 points of real growth.→ Exhibit 5
What would change this view
What would change this viewTriggerTodayDecided by
Headline strength turns to pricereal control group, 3m < 3.7% while nominal sales grow > 5% y/y+6.7%; nominal +6.8% (Oct 2026)not crossedthe Nov 2026 advance retail sales report (Census)
Warehouse clubs & supercenters recoverreal y/y > +4.8% (2015–19 average) with total volume near 3%+2.8% (Sep 2026)not crossedthe Oct 2026 monthly retail trade report (Census)
The reasoning behind each point
  • Level
    Sales rose +6.8% on the year to Oct 2026 in dollars but +3.0% in volume.

    Sales rose +6.8% on the year to Oct 2026 (84th percentile since 2010). Deflated component by component, volume rose +3.0% — the 46th percentile, below the 2015–19 average of +3.6%. Price accounts for 3.7 points of the headline.

  • Source
    Gasoline is 60% of the gap between the two.

    Gasoline stations: +30.3% nominal, +0.3% real. They supply 2.28pp of nominal growth and +0.02pp of real. Ex autos and gasoline, sales rose +5.9% nominal and +3.6% real.

  • Momentum
    The real control group is up +3.7% on the year, in line with its 2015–19 average of +3.7%.

    Real total sales moved −0.05% on the month (−0.6% annualised). The real control group is running +6.7% on the three-month average and +3.7% on the year, against +3.7% in 2015–19.

  • Channel
    Online and mail-order retailers supply 1.44 of the 3.05 points of real growth.

    Online and mail-order (nonstore) retailers supply 1.44 of the 3.05 points of real growth (47%). Grocery volume is −1.1% on the year; warehouse clubs & supercenters +2.8% in Sep 2026 against a 2015–19 average of +4.8%.

Next: Income & outlays — can income keep it up?

Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; company releases (dated); Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026growth.retail-read

How fast are sales growing?

Total retail sales on the momentum ladder — the month , three months and the year — and the split of the year's rise into price and volume

Exhibit 2 · Real retail sales growth over one month, three months and a year

%, last five years to Oct 2026; bars: one month annualised; lines: three months annualised, year on year; dashed: 2015–19 average; shaded: Oct 2025, no CPI
Smooth
About
About this exhibit
For the selected series and basis (total, real by default): bars of month-on-month annualised growth and lines of three-month annualised and year-on-year growth, over the last five years, with a dashed 2015–19 average and the month without CPI shaded.
Retail & food services, total — real: latest +3.0% y/y, +4.3% over three months annualised
%, Nov 2021 to Oct 2026.
Bars: month on month, annualised. Lines: three-month annualised (basis chosen above) and year on year. Dashed: the 2015–19 average year-on-year rate. Shaded: Oct 2025 (BLS CPI not published; geometric mean of the adjacent months; affects real and price series).
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026growth.retail-2

Exhibit 1 · Total retail sales growth in dollars, in volume and in price

% change on a year earlier, monthly, to Oct 2026; follows the series picked in the growth chart or the table. Nominal ≈ volume + price.
About
About this exhibit
Three lines for the selected series (total retail & food services by default): year-on-year % change in nominal sales, in real sales (volume) and in the implied price, monthly; the chart follows the series picked in the growth chart or the momentum table.
Retail & food services, total: +6.8% nominal = +3.0% volume and +3.7% price, year to Oct 2026
Selected series, % change on a year earlier. Nominal ≈ volume + price.
Source: The publisher's nominal series; the deflators are Macro Review calculations.growth.retail-3

Where is it coming from?

Contributions by kind of business, every kind of business on the ladder in nominal, real and price terms, and the heatmap

Exhibit 5 · Contributions to year-on-year sales growth by kind of business, nominal and real

Percentage points of the change in total retail & food services sales over twelve months to Oct 2026; bars: nominal and real
About
About this exhibit
Paired horizontal bars for the kinds of business: each one's contribution to year-on-year sales growth in the latest month, in percentage points, nominal and real.
Where the year-on-year growth comes from
Percentage points, year to Oct 2026. Sums: nominal 6.8pp, real 3.0pp.
Contribution = prior-year share of the total × the component's growth. Real contributions use the same shares on volume growth.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026growth.retail-4

Exhibit 6 · Retail sales growth by kind of business, against 2015–19 averages

Oct 2026, real unless the selector says otherwise; % annualised except MoM and YoY; shaded against each line's 2015–19 average; select a row to chart it
above its 2015–19 averagebelow its 2015–19 averageShading scales with distance in standard deviations (full at 2σ). Select a row to chart it.
Retail sales momentum, real, Oct 2026
SeriesYoY3m ann.MoM ann.MoMShare2015–19 YoYYoY, 36 monthsMonth
Aggregates
Retail & food services, total+3.0+4.3−0.6−0.05100.03.6Oct ’26
Total ex motor vehicles & parts+3.2+6.2+2.7+0.223.4Oct ’26
Total ex gasoline stations+3.3+3.8−1.3−0.113.8Oct ’26
Total ex autos & gasoline+3.6+5.9+2.1+0.173.6Oct ’26
Control groupex autos, gasoline, building materials, food services+3.7+6.7+3.1+0.253.7Oct ’26
Retail ex food services+3.0+3.8−0.2−0.013.7Oct ’26
Kinds of business
Motor vehicles & parts+2.0−3.7−13.8−1.2318.34.6Oct ’26
Furniture & home furnishings+2.9+8.3−32.0−3.161.45.3Oct ’26
Electronics & appliances+7.1+7.8−5.1−0.441.0-1.4Oct ’26
Building materials & garden+3.1−3.7+4.7+0.395.94.1Oct ’26
Food & beverage stores−1.1+0.8−6.5−0.5611.42.7Oct ’26
Health & personal care+2.3+16.3+12.5+0.995.41.8Oct ’26
Gasoline stations+0.3+8.7+7.6+0.619.21.8Oct ’26
Clothing & accessories−0.5+4.7−9.5−0.833.51.5Oct ’26
Sporting goods, hobby, music, books+2.4−3.4−15.5−1.391.21.4Oct ’26
General merchandise+2.1+2.8−1.7−0.1410.92.0Oct ’26
Miscellaneous store retailers+12.3+12.8+70.4+4.542.23.3Oct ’26
Online and mail-order (nonstore)+8.8+10.9+12.2+0.9717.110.6Oct ’26
Food services & drinking places+3.2+7.3−3.2−0.2712.42.8Oct ’26
Memo lines
Grocery stores−1.1+1.2−6.4−0.552.6Oct ’26
Warehouse clubs & supercentersCostco, Sam's Club, BJ's, Walmart supercenters+2.8+3.8−4.2−0.364.8Sep ’26
Department stores−2.4−2.6−2.8−0.24-14.7Oct ’26
Electronic shopping & mail order+9.4+6.2+6.6+0.5312.0Sep ’26
About this exhibit
A table of the aggregates, kinds of business and memo lines in the latest month: growth year on year, three months annualised, month on month annualised and month on month, share of sales, each line's 2015–19 average and a sparkline, shaded by distance from that average; the basis switches between nominal, real and price.
Momentum by kind of business, Oct 2026
% annualised except MoM (as the publisher releases it) and YoY. Share = % of total retail & food services sales. Amber month = one month behind the advance report. Select a row to chart it above.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Monthly Retail Trade Survey (MRTS); U.S. Census Bureau, Advance Monthly Retail Trade Survey (MARTS); U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U seasonally adjusted. Real series and aggregates computed here (method below).growth.retail-1

Exhibit 7 · Monthly real sales growth by kind of business against 2015–19 averages

Three-month annualised growth, %, last three years to Oct 2026; colour: standard deviations from each series' 2015–19 average, blue above, orange below
About this exhibit
A heatmap of real three-month annualised growth (switchable to month-on-month or year-on-year) for the total, the control group, the kinds of business and the memo lines, each month over the last three years, coloured by standard deviations from each series' own 2015–19 average.
Three years of momentum — real, 3m avg vs prior 3m, annualised
Nov 2023 to Oct 2026. Blue: above the series' 2015–19 average; orange: below. Memo lines at the foot.
Cell colour: distance from the series' own 2015–19 average on that measure, in standard deviations. Values on hover.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; Macro Review calculations · data to Oct 2026growth.retail-5

Retail vs PCE goods

Does this retail print tell you the PCE goods print? Census retail sales against BEA's spending on the same goods, on the year, and the gap between them against its
Basis
Pairing

Exhibit 3 · Retail control group and matching PCE goods, year-on-year growth

% change on a year earlier, nominal, monthly, last five years to Aug 2026; Census retail sales and BEA spending on the matching PCE goods
About this exhibit
Two lines for the selected pairing (the control group by default): Census retail sales and BEA's spending on the matching PCE goods, % change on a year earlier, nominal, over the last five years.
Retail control group ↔ PCE goods ex motor vehicles, motor fuel, garden & building: retail against PCE
% change on a year earlier, nominal, Aug 2021 to Aug 2026
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-2

Exhibit 4 · Gap between retail and PCE growth against its 2015–19 average

Percentage points, retail minus PCE year-on-year growth, control group, nominal, last five years to Aug 2026; dashed: 2015–19 average (−0.1pp)
About
About this exhibit
One line: the gap between retail and PCE year-on-year growth for the selected pairing (the control group by default), percentage points, over the last five years, with the dashed 2015–19 average.
Gap, retail − PCE
pp, retail y/y − PCE y/y, Aug 2021 to Aug 2026
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-3

Exhibit 8 · Retail and PCE growth by kind of business, and the gap

Aug 2026, year-on-year % change, nominal unless the selector says otherwise; gap = retail − PCE, shaded against the pairing's 2015–19 gap; levels: $bn a year
About
PairingCensus NAICSPCE lines (Table 2.4.5U)Retail ×12PCERetail y/yPCE y/yGap2015–19 gap
Kinds of business
Motor vehicles & parts441Motor vehicles and parts (4)1,674810+2.3+6.7−4.4+0.4
Furniture, furnishings, electronics & appliances442 4435 lines: Furniture and furnishings; Household appliances; Glassware, tableware, and household utensils; …220982+3.1+7.4−4.3−4.0
Building materials & garden444Tools and equipment for house and garden (35); Flowers, seeds, and potted plants (129)532154+5.4+9.8−4.4−2.8
Food & beverage stores445Food and nonalcoholic beverages purchased for off-premises consumption (74); Alcoholic beverages purchased for off-premises consumption (99)1,0171,570+0.3+2.3−2.0−0.6
Health & personal care446Pharmaceutical and other medical products (121); Therapeutic appliances and equipment (66); Personal care products (137)4711,094−0.8+3.7−4.5−1.0
Gasoline stations447Motor vehicle fuels, lubricants, and fluids (114)767469+21.0+23.8−2.8+1.1
Clothing & accessories448Clothing and footwear (104); Jewelry and watches (63); Luggage and similar personal items (70)318776+4.3+6.3−2.0−1.1
Sporting goods, hobby, music & books451Sporting equipment, supplies, guns, and ammunition (52); Recreational books (60); Musical instruments (61); Games, toys, and hobbies (127)105342+9.5+10.0−0.6−5.0
Food services & drinking places722Purchased meals and beverages (236)1,1031,344+5.8+5.8±0.0+0.2
Aggregates
Retail sales (ex food services) ↔ PCE goods44X–45X8 lines: Motor vehicles and parts; Furnishings and durable household equipment; Recreational goods and vehicles; …7,7696,944+5.5+6.3−0.8+0.1
Retail ex autos & gasoline ↔ PCE goods ex motor vehicles & motor fuel44X–45X − 441 − 4477 lines: Furnishings and durable household equipment; Recreational goods and vehicles; Other durable goods; …5,3285,665+4.6+5.0−0.4−0.1
Retail control group ↔ PCE goods ex motor vehicles, motor fuel, garden & building44X–45X − 441 − 447 − 44416 lines: Furniture and furnishings; Household appliances; Glassware, tableware, and household utensils; …4,7965,497+4.5+4.9−0.4−0.1
About this exhibit
A table of the retail–PCE pairings and the aggregates in the latest month: Census code, matched PCE lines, levels ($bn at annual rates), retail and PCE year-on-year growth, the gap and the pairing's 2015–19 gap, shaded by how unusual the gap is; the basis switches between nominal and real.
Retail kinds of business and their PCE counterparts, Aug 2026
Year-on-year growth, Nominal. Gap = retail − PCE, shaded against the pairing's own 2015–19 gap (blue: retail stronger than usual; orange: weaker). Levels: retail × 12 and PCE at annual rates, $bn. Select a row to chart it above.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-1

The warehouse-club channel against the companies' own reports

Club and grocery volumes against the total and e-commerce, and the channel beside quoted company figures

Exhibit 13 · Real sales growth at warehouse clubs and grocers against total and online

Real sales, % change on a year earlier, since 2022, to Oct 2026. Warehouse clubs & supercenters are published a month after the advance total.
About this exhibit
Four lines of real year-on-year sales growth (total retail & food services, warehouse clubs & supercenters, grocery stores and nonstore retailers), monthly.
Club and grocery volumes against the total and e-commerce
Real sales, % change on a year earlier, January 2022 onwards. Warehouse clubs & supercenters are published a month after the advance total.
Source: Census MRTS (NAICS 452311, 4451, 454) and MARTS; BLS CPI-U; deflators computed here.growth.retail-8

Exhibit 14 · Census sales growth by store type beside Costco's reported comparable sales

Latest year-on-year readings, %, nominal and real; Census and BLS for store types, Costco releases (quoted, dated) for company figures.
ReadingPeriodNominalReal
Channel, year on year
Retail & food services, totalOct 2026+6.8+3.0
General merchandiseOct 2026+3.5+2.1
Warehouse clubs & supercentersSep 2026+4.0+2.8
Grocery storesOct 2026+0.9−1.1
Online and mail-order (nonstore)Oct 2026+11.8+8.8
Company-reported (quoted)
US comparable salesAug 2026, 4 weeks+9.0–
US comparable sales ex gasoline & FXAug 2026, 4 weeks+5.6–
Worldwide traffic / average ticketQ3 FY26+2.4 / +7.3–

Company comparable sales include gasoline, whose price is up about a fifth on the year; the ex-gasoline figure is the one comparable to the channel. Traffic against ticket is the company's own price/volume split.

About this exhibit
A table of the latest nominal and real year-on-year readings for total sales, general merchandise, warehouse clubs & supercenters, grocery and nonstore retailers, beside Costco's quoted US comparable sales (with and without gasoline and FX) and worldwide traffic and average ticket.
The channel against the company
Latest readings, %

Retail vs PCE goods, in detail

Every retail kind of business beside its PCE counterpart on the momentum ladder, the gaps since 2015, the widest months, and how the pairs are matched

Exhibit 9 · Retail and PCE growth by pairing, one month to a year

Aug 2026, nominal unless the selector says otherwise; % annualised except MoM and YoY; PCE rows under their retail pairing; shaded against each line's 2015–19 average
above its 2015–19 averagebelow its 2015–19 averageShading scales with distance in standard deviations (full at 2σ). Select a row to chart it.
Series% of retailMoMMoM ann.3m ann.YoY2015–19 YoYYoY, 36 monthsMonth
Aggregates
Retail sales (ex food services)100.0+1.28+16.5+4.4+5.53.2Aug 2026
PCE goods+1.48+19.3+3.3+6.33.1Aug 2026
Retail ex autos & gasoline68.6+1.09+13.9+4.6+4.63.6Aug 2026
PCE goods ex motor vehicles & motor fuel+1.16+14.8+5.1+5.03.7Aug 2026
Retail control group61.7+1.19+15.3+4.7+4.53.6Aug 2026
PCE goods ex motor vehicles, motor fuel, garden & building+1.11+14.2+5.0+4.93.6Aug 2026
Kinds of business
Retail: Motor vehicles & parts21.6+0.68+8.5+7.7+2.34.3Aug 2026
PCE: Motor vehicles & parts+2.33+31.8+8.0+6.73.9Aug 2026
Retail: Furniture, furnishings, electronics & appliances2.8+1.00+12.6+1.9+3.10.6Aug 2026
PCE: Furniture, furnishings, electronics & appliances+1.73+22.9+6.1+7.44.7Aug 2026
Retail: Building materials & garden6.8+0.20+2.5+4.1+5.44.0Aug 2026
PCE: Building materials & garden+2.88+40.5+9.9+9.86.8Aug 2026
About this exhibit
A table of each retail aggregate and kind of business above its matching PCE line in the latest month: share of retail, month on month, month on month annualised, three months annualised, year on year, the 2015–19 year-on-year average and a sparkline, shaded against each line's 2015–19 average.
Retail and PCE, Aug 2026 — Nominal
% annualised except MoM and YoY. Share = % of retail sales. PCE rows are indented under their retail pairing.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-4

Exhibit 10 · Three-month growth of retail and PCE pairs, last twelve months

% annualised, three months over the prior three months, nominal, last twelve months to Aug 2026; shaded against each series' 2015–19 average, blue above, orange below
Growth heat table
SeriesSep ’25Oct ’25Nov ’25Dec ’25Jan ’26Feb ’26Mar ’26Apr ’26May ’26Jun ’26Jul ’26Aug ’26
Retail control group+6.4+5.2+3.5+3.3+2.1+1.7+2.0+4.8+7.0+7.4+5.8+4.7
PCE goods ex motor vehicles, motor fuel, garden & building+6.3+4.9+2.9+2.8+2.3+3.4+5.0+7.1+8.0+7.4+5.7+5.0
Retail ex autos & gasoline+5.5+4.8+3.2+3.3+2.7+2.5+2.9+5.2+7.0+7.2+5.7+4.6
PCE goods ex motor vehicles & motor fuel+6.2+4.9+2.9+2.8+2.4+3.5+5.3+7.3+8.1+7.5+5.8+5.1
Retail sales (ex food services)+5.8+5.5+3.3+2.5+2.3+1.8+3.5+7.9+12.3+11.8+8.0+4.4
PCE goods+4.9+5.2+3.8+2.8+1.9+2.2+5.6+11.4+15.0+12.5+6.7+3.3
Retail: Food & beverage stores+3.8+3.6+0.5−0.2−0.5−1.2−1.4−1.0+3.0+3.9+3.1+0.2
PCE: Food & beverage stores+4.1+3.5+1.5+1.0+1.0+1.4+1.8+1.9+3.5+4.1+4.1+3.3
Retail: Gasoline stations+8.2+8.5+8.1+8.7+6.2+0.8+12.5+45.8+92.3+71.0+27.2−4.3
PCE: Gasoline stations+2.5+10.7+13.8+9.1+5.7−2.0+22.3+80.1+158.1+103.7+19.6−21.9
Retail: Motor vehicles & parts+5.6+6.6+1.7−2.3−0.4+0.1+2.2+3.2+4.2+6.3+7.4+7.7
PCE: Motor vehicles & parts−2.2+4.6+5.5−0.2−3.5−4.5−0.2+11.7+13.1+10.5+5.7+8.0
About this exhibit
A heat table of three-month annualised growth (switchable to month-on-month or year-on-year) for the paired retail and PCE series, each of the last twelve months, shaded against each series' 2015–19 average.
Last 12 months — nominal, 3m ann.
Each cell shaded against the series' own 2015–19 average on that measure (blue above, orange below; full at two standard deviations). Basis follows the selector above.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-5

Exhibit 11 · Retail minus PCE growth for the aggregates, since 2015

Percentage points, retail minus PCE year-on-year growth, nominal, monthly, Jan 2015 to Aug 2026; control group, ex autos & gasoline, retail ex food services · loading history
About this exhibit
Three lines: the gap between retail and PCE year-on-year growth for the control group, ex autos & gasoline, and retail ex food services against PCE goods, percentage points, nominal, monthly, since 2015.
The aggregate gaps over time
pp, nominal y/y gap, Aug 2016 to Aug 2026
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-6

Exhibit 12 · Widest control-group gaps since 2015

Largest absolute nominal twelve-month gaps; z against the 2015–19 distribution of the gap.
MonthRetailPCEGapReal gapz
Jun 2023+1.1%+3.3%−2.3−2.2−3.7
Jul 2023+2.0%+4.2%−2.2−2.1−3.6
Sep 2023+1.3%+3.6%−2.3−2.3−3.8
Oct 2023+1.3%+3.5%−2.2−2.1−3.6
Nov 2023+2.5%+4.9%−2.4−2.4−3.9
Dec 2023+3.1%+5.4%−2.3−2.3−3.8
Latest
Aug 2026+4.5%+4.9%−0.4−0.4−0.5
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-7

Exhibit 17 · Definitions and caveats

  • Mapping
    Version 1.

    Mapping version 1 (2026-09-17): 9 pairings of Census kinds of business (NAICS 2017, monthly retail trade survey) with lines of BEA's Table 2.4.5U, plus three aggregates. General merchandise (452), miscellaneous store (453) and nonstore (454) retailers sell across many PCE categories and are compared only inside the aggregates.

  • Real
    Both sides on the same prices.

    Real retail sales = nominal sales ÷ the price index of the matched PCE lines. For a single PCE line that is BEA's own chain-type price index; for several, a Fisher index calculated by the site from BEA's line-level prices weighted by BEA's line-level spending (checked against BEA's published goods and major-type price changes). The PCE side's real series is BEA's chained dollars for single lines and nominal ÷ the same Fisher index for composites, so real gaps are coverage and timing differences, not price.

  • Units
    Monthly against annual rates.

    Retail sales are monthly totals (seasonally adjusted, $m); PCE lines are seasonally adjusted annual rates. Levels are compared as retail × 12 against PCE; growth rates need no conversion.

  • Sources
    Not independent sources.

    Census data are the October 15, 2026 advance release (retail through Sep 2026; the comparison stops at Aug 2026, the latest month both BEA's PCE and Census's retail detail carry). BEA data are the personal income and outlays release of 4 Nov 2026. BEA's monthly goods PCE draws on Census retail data among other sources, so the two are not independent; they differ in coverage (households only in PCE), used-vehicle and fuel accounting, and in BEA's later benchmark revisions.

  • Divergence
    Ranked by size.

    Months listed are the largest absolute nominal twelve-month gaps for the control-group pairing since the display start, with the gap's z-score against its 2015–19 distribution.

  • v1
    17 Sept 2026

    First mapping, made for the retail ↔ PCE goods cross-check owed from the 17 Sep retail work.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-8

Exhibit 18 · Caveat for each pairing

  • mv
    Motor vehicles & parts

    Dealers' sales include business and government purchases and the full price of used vehicles; PCE counts only household purchases, and used vehicles as net purchases plus dealer margins.

  • furn_elec
    Furniture, furnishings, electronics & appliances

    PCE includes these goods wherever bought (general merchandise and online retailers sell a large share); the stores also sell to businesses.

  • bldg
    Building materials & garden

    A large part of building-material dealers' sales goes to contractors and becomes residential investment, not PCE; the pairing is the weakest on the page.

  • food
    Food & beverage stores

    PCE food off premises is bought at any outlet (supercenters, clubs, online); grocery stores also sell non-food items. Food produced and consumed on farms (line 103) is left out.

  • hlth
    Health & personal care

    PCE pharmaceuticals include prescriptions paid by insurers and filled by mail order and hospitals; pharmacies' sales include front-of-store goods.

  • gas
    Gasoline stations

    Gasoline stations also sell food, tobacco and other convenience goods; PCE motor fuel excludes business fuel purchases, which station sales include.

  • clth
    Clothing & accessories

    Clothing is sold heavily by general merchandise and nonstore retailers, which are not mapped individually.

  • sprt
    Sporting goods, hobby, music & books

    Small category; books and toys are sold largely online and in general merchandise stores.

  • fsvc
    Food services & drinking places

    PCE purchased meals and beverages is a service; restaurant sales include business meals and purchases by visitors from abroad.

  • goods
    Retail sales (ex food services) ↔ PCE goods

    Broadest comparison: all retail kinds of business against all PCE goods.

  • exmvgas
    Retail ex autos & gasoline ↔ PCE goods ex motor vehicles & motor fuel

    Removes the two categories where price swings and used-vehicle accounting differ most.

  • control
    Retail control group ↔ PCE goods ex motor vehicles, motor fuel, garden & building

    The retail control group excludes autos, gasoline stations, building materials and food services. Net expenditures abroad (line 145, no price index) is left out of the PCE side.

Fisher index against BEA, m/m since 2015Price medianPrice maxReal max
Goods0.0020.1160.105
Furnishings and durable household equipment0.0010.0120.031
Recreational goods and vehicles0.0020.0120.020
Other durable goods0.0030.0570.066
Food and beverages purchased for off-premises consumption0.0000.0010.012
Clothing and footwear0.0010.0150.106
Gasoline and other energy goods0.0040.0520.388
Source: U.S. Census Bureau; U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; Macro Review calculations · data to Aug 2026growth.reconcile-9

Appendix

How the real series are made, and what the single-deflator shortcut gets wrong102 checks, all pass
About this page
Census publishes retail sales in current dollars, seasonally adjusted but not adjusted for price changes. This page reads every kind of business three ways — nominal, real (deflated by matched CPI components) and the implied price — on the momentum ladder: month on month annualised, three months annualised, and year on year.

Exhibit 15 · Deflator for each kind of business

Fixed-weight composites of CPI-U seasonally adjusted indices, chained in log changes
Kind of businessCPI-U components (weight)Price y/y
Motor vehicles & parts
Transportation commodities less motor fuel SATCLTB · 100%
−0.7
Furniture & home furnishings
Furniture and bedding SEHJ · 60%
Window and floor coverings and other linens SEHH · 10%
Other household equipment and furnishings SEHL · 30%
−0.4
Electronics & appliances
Information technology commodities SEEE · 50%
Video and audio SERA · 25%
Appliances SEHK · 25%
+0.5
Building materials & garden
Tools, hardware, outdoor equipment and supplies SEHM · 100%
+2.4
Food & beverage stores
Food at home SAF11 · 90%
Alcoholic beverages at home SEFW · 10%
+2.0
Health & personal care
Medical care commodities SAM1 · 70%
Personal care products SEGB · 30%
−1.2
Gasoline stations
Gasoline (all types) SETB01 · 80%
Food at home SAF11 · 10%
Tobacco and smoking products SEGA · 10%
+29.9
Clothing & accessories
Apparel SAA · 100%
+3.7
Sporting goods, hobby, music, books
Recreation commodities SARC · 100%
+4.6
General merchandise
Commodities less food and energy commodities SACL1E · 60%
Food at home SAF11 · 40%
+1.4
Miscellaneous store retailers
Commodities less food and energy commodities SACL1E · 100%
+0.8
Online and mail-order (nonstore)
Commodities less food and energy commodities SACL1E · 95%
Fuel oil and other fuels SEHE · 5%
+2.8
Food services & drinking places
Food away from home SEFV · 100%
+3.8
Warehouse clubs & supercenters
Commodities less food and energy commodities SACL1E · 50%
Food at home SAF11 · 50%
+1.2
Aggregates are Fisher chain-linked from the real components, scaled to chained 2017 dollars, so volume and implied price multiply back to the published nominal aggregate. Where a constituent index is not yet published its weight is spread over the others; with none published, Commodities less food and energy commodities is used. The component sum matches the published total to 0.000% in every month shown.
Source: BLS CPI-U item codes (CUSR0000 + code).growth.retail-6

Exhibit 16 · Real retail sales growth with component deflators and with headline CPI

Total retail & food services, real year-on-year, %, monthly since 2015; latest Oct 2026
  • Shortcut
    Headline CPI alone: real +2.8% y/y. Component deflators: +3.0%.

    CPI all items rose +3.95% but carries shelter and services that retail sales do not sell; the prices of what retailers do sell rose +3.70%. The shortcut puts real sales +0.9pp from their 2015–19 average; component deflators put them −0.6pp.

  • Data gap
    Oct 2025: no BLS CPI.

    Filled by the geometric mean of the adjacent months; affects real and price series. Real month-on-month rates for that month and the next carry the assumption, as will year-on-year rates twelve months later.

About this exhibit
Two lines of real year-on-year growth in total retail & food services sales: one deflated by component price indexes, one by headline CPI alone.
Headline CPI overstates retail prices
Total retail & food services, real year-on-year, %
Source: Computed here; the headline-CPI line replicates the common single-deflator method.growth.retail-7

Before you read

Macro Review is a personal research site, still being built.

Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation or a solicitation.

Check every figure for yourself. Each names its publisher — confirm it there before you rely on it.

Figures can be revised, delayed or wrong.

Cones, fans, scenarios, fair values and “what followed” tables are conditional on the model each page names: they describe, they do not predict.

No warranty is given; use is at your own risk.